Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum The Dark Knight Rises
the Blog DVD Report - May 15th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film

Archive for July, 2008 Page 2 of 4



Neglected Gems: The Earrings of Madame de…

The Earrings of Madame de… @ Amazon

Max Ophüls‘ penultimate film is perhaps his masterpiece. 1953′s The Earrings of Madame de… has aged well, and its gorgeous, elegant camera work is still a major influence on directors today.

This is a romantic tale of lust, fidelity and intrigue, centered around a pair of earrings which the beautiful Madame Louise (Danielle Darrieux) has pawned to pay a debt. Cornered by her husband, she claims the earrings as stolen, which sets into motion a chain of events that play out in casinos, hotels and ballrooms from Vienna to Constantinople — all sumptuously shot by Ophüls.

“The greatest film of all time . . . Below the glittering surfaces, the lush decor, the sensuous fabrics, there is the cruel sensibility of an artist mourning the death of this world and all other worlds to come. Inside the beautiful ladies and lovers of romance lurk the grinning skeletons of tragedy.” Andrew Serris – The New York Observer

In September, The Earrings of Madame de… will be available from the Criterion Collection (#445), and you can preorder it now.

For further reading, here are some extended reviews at Metro Times Detroit, Roger Ebert and Slant Magazine


DVD Report – July 22nd

Gambling features in two of this week’s new releases: 21 and Turn the River. Criticker users wouldn’t be willing wager on these two becoming major cult hits on DVD… neither they nor any of the other films new in stores today got good scores. But, there are a couple interesting films which are seeing a very late release on DVD… 2005′s Duck and The Last Winter from 2006. That one had some really great reviews, mixed with some really terrible ones.

21159 Rankings – Average Tier 4.72
The fact-based story about six MIT students who were trained to become experts in card counting and subsequently took Vegas casinos for millions in winnings. 21 @ Amazon

The Last Winter12 Rankings – Average Tier 4.17
In the Arctic region of Northern Alaska, an oil company’s advance team struggles to establish a drilling base that will forever alter the pristine land. After one team member is found dead, a disorientation slowly claims the sanity of the others as each of them succumbs to a mysterious fear. The Last Winter @ Amazon

September Dawn5 Rankings – Average Tier 1.5
On September 11, 1857, in an unspoiled valley of the Utah territory–and in the name of God–120 men, women, and children were savagely murdered. Who ordered the massacre, and why, has been hidden in a cloak of secrecy and conspiracy. And the reputation of one of this nation’s mightiest religious figures has been preserved and protected. September Dawn @ Amazon

DuckLess than 5 Rankings
In 2009, when Los Angeles’ last city park is closed to the public, a dispossessed man — and the duck who follows him as a mother — quest west, on foot, in search of water and meaning, in the desert that is L.A. Duck @ Amazon

Turn the RiverLess than 5 Rankings
A pool shark (Janssen) takes the ultimate gamble when she kidnaps her own son and flees her ex-husband. Turn the River @ Amazon

Merging of Actors, Directors & Screenwriters

Over the weekend, we introduced an enhancement to the way we store and display actors, screenwriters and directors.

In the past, these three types of filmmakers were kept separate in our database. This made things easy for us, but wasn’t the best way to go about it. For instance, users had to do 2 different searches to see all the films Clint Eastwood has starred in or directed. Likewise, there is no reason that the biography or profile picture for “Eastwood the Director” should be different from “Eastwood the Actor”.

Also, we used the opportunity to change the Filmmaker Page, so that you can regenerate and sort on PSIs, rather than just film year. You have to regenerate before the sort, because the PSIs can quickly go out-of-date.

As is the case with all new changes, there will probably be issues we didn’t catch. Some of you already have alerted us to a couple, and we appreciate that. Keep bug reports coming… and I hope you like the new enhancements!


Heroes of Contentiousness #5 – Eyes Wide Shut

Eyes Wide Shut @ Amazon

What can be said about Eyes Wide Shut? This is truly one of the ultimate “love it or hate it” films, and is by far the most contentious film yet included in this series, with a FCQ of 59.79 (Film Contentiousness Quotient — details here).

Whether Kubrick’s final film provided a crowning touch to his legacy, or sadly tarnished it, is the subject of intense, passionate debate. Is the pacing excruciatingly slow, or beautifully dreamlike? Is the wooden acting of Tom Cruise & Nicole Kidman part of the concept — a comment on how the characters “act out” their dual lives — or just bad?

My answers: Tarnished, excruciatingly slow, bad acting. Do you disagree? Vote in this week’s poll — is Eyes Wide Shut GREAT or TERRIBLE? You must choose.

Eyes Wide Shut

  • Great! (63%, 10 Votes)
  • Terrible! (37%, 6 Votes)

Total Voters: 16

Loading ... Loading ...
 

Here are a couple opinions from Criticker users.

Cuculiza: “An excellent study of the human mind, obsession with sex and how the society reacts. Slow-paced rythm builds up a sustained suspense throughout the entire movie. The performances are on point.”

Droplet00: “If this is all Stanley Kubrick figured out about about love, sex and desire in his long years, god save him.”

Last week’s polls are closed, on King Kong and Marie Antoinette, and the results are in: both are great (Marie Antoinette by a single vote!)

 

And just to prove that we don’t always have to disagree, here are two more films that are the opposite of contentious:
Unanimously Crap (FCQ 0.49): I Still Know What You Did Last Summer… don’t you care?
Unanimously Sweet (FCQ 4.44): Vertigo. Perhaps Hitchcock’s greatest masterpiece.

Neglected Gems: Devils on the Doorstep

Today, we’re kick-starting another regular feature at Criticker’s Blog: Neglected Gems. These are films which not many of our users have seen, but which have been scored extremely high by those who have.

Devils on the Doorstep @ Amazon

 

First up, is Devils on the Doorstep (Guizi lai le), a Chinese production from 2000. It premiered at Cannes and won the festival’s Grand Prix (jury prize), but was banned in its own country.

The film is a black comedy, set in a small Chinese village along the Great Wall. Japanese soldiers have been delivered into the village as prisoners, and the townspeople are instructed to hold them until they’re picked up in the New Year. The promised pick-up never arrives, and as the villagers grow ever more nervous, they have to decide what to do about their unwanted guests.

Devils on the Doorstep is quickly paced and shot entirely in black and white. It garnered massive praise from the foreign press on release, but was banned by the Chinese government for inaccurate depictions of the Japanese occupation. The director, Wen Jiang, was banned from working in China for 7 years. The theatrical release of Devils on the Doorstep in the United States consisted of a single screen for 65 days.

More information can be found at the film’s Wikipedia entry


DVD Report – July 14th

Yet another weak slate of new releases on DVD, this week. Not a single one that our users whole-heartedly recommend, though The Bank Job does get higher than average scores. Interestingly, this week’s releases all follow a pattern… the fewer people have seen it, the poorer the score. Evidence that recommendations work? Or simply that people know to stay away from Joshua Jackson and Martin Lawrence?

The Bank Job192 Rankings – Average Tier 5.87
Based on the true story of the 1971 Baker Street bank robbery which was prevented from being told for over thirty years because of a Government gagging order. The real story of how one of the biggest robberies in British history took place with no arrests ever made nor money ever recovered. The Bank Job @ Amazon

Penelope34 Rankings – Average Tier 4.41
Penelope is a modern day offbeat fable about a young woman who, having spent her life trapped by a family curse sets out to find love and discover her true self. Penelope @ Amazon

Step Up 2 the Streets30 Rankings – Average Tier 2.9
Romantic sparks occur between two dance students from different backgrounds at the Maryland School of the Arts. Step Up 2 the Streets @ Amazon

Shutter21 Rankings – Average Tier 2.43
A newlywed couple Ben and Jane move to Japan for a promising job opportunity – a fashion shoot in Tokyo. During their trip on a dark forest road they experience a tragic car accident, leading to the death of a young local girl. Upon regaining consciousness, they find no trace of her body. A bit distraught the couple arrives in Tokyo to begin their new life… Shutter @ Amazon

College Road Trip 8 Rankings – Average Tier 2.13
When an overachieving high school student decides to travel around the country to choose the perfect college, her overprotective cop father also decides to accompany her in order to keep her on the straight and narrow. College Road Trip @ Amazon

Blindness – Trailer


Click for Full Size
One of the upcoming films we’re most excited about is Blindness, based on José Saramago’s excellent 1995 novel.

Basically, Blindness is about the plight of a woman who finds herself the leader of a group of blind people within an institution. Most of humanity has gone blind as the result of some strange disease but the heroine, played in the film by Julianne Moore, is immune — and only her husband knows it. The first afflicted have been locked into quarantine, where anarchy soon reigns, once the guards lose their sight as well.

The book was excellent, and though I’m normally wary of films made out of much-loved novels, I’m putting my faith into this one. The cast is great — Mark Ruffalo and Gabriel Gael Bernal also star — and director Fernando Meirelles (City of God, Constant Gardener) is no slouch, either.

Blindness arrives in theaters in September.
Official Site: http://www.blindness-themovie.com/