Being self-righteous pricks, we often trumpet the fact that Criticker is an insanely accurate recommendation system — dead on-target almost all the time — knows people’s taste in film better than they do themselves — possibly the greatest, most important website on the internet — just utterly pwning all over the place… all these are phrases which escape our sneering lips daily.

But, truth be told, Criticker doesn’t always get things right. And the users in our forums have taken it upon themselves to sniff out those times Criticker guesses wrong. User djross started this topic a couple months ago, and it’s quickly become one of the most active in the forums.

Criticker’s never wrong: you didn’t REALLY like Road to Wellville, admit it

There’s a lot of interesting information in this thread. Ang Lee’s films seem to be among the most frequently overrated by Criticker. And our intrepid forum users have discovered that when a PSI is wildly off the mark, it tends to be overly optimistic.

Have you encountered times where your PSIs have been completely different than your actual scores? Then head over to the forum and join in the discussion!