Although Winona Ryder has the starring role, Girl, Interrupted is mainly known as the film which unleashed The Angelina on an unsuspecting world. Perhaps that’s why the film has as many starry-eyed devotees as haters. But whatever one’s opinion of The Angelina, it’s hard to deny that She was luminescent in this role. She is good at crazy, and won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress for her work.

But the film as a whole? It’s received a high Film Contentiousness Quotient of 45.36 (details on the math here), which means significant and equal numbers of users hated and loved it, without many in between. Some saw it as an honest and powerful examination of mental illness, though many critics derided its dependence on cliche and uneven storytelling.

 Loading ...

Here are a couple battling opinions from Criticker users.

virgored: “Excellent film, amazing performances and heart-wrenching example of the bonds we form regardless of environment.”

wig: “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest never needed to be watered down with estrogen.”

Last week’s poll is closed and by a huge margin, Contact is redeemed. I… can’t believe it! Fine, Juergen, this time you win.

And here’s our up-to-date list of the top 10 most contentious films at Criticker:

1. Eyes Wide Shut - FCQ 58.76 - Poll Result: GREAT!
2. Dumb & Dumber - FCQ 52.62 - Poll Result: GREAT!
3. King Kong - FCQ 51.11 - Poll Result: GREAT!
4. I Am Sam - FCQ 49.77 - Poll Result: TERRIBLE!
5. Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest - FCQ 49.31 - Poll Result: TERRIBLE!
6. Saw - FCQ 49.23 - Poll Result: TIE!
7. Stay - FCQ 48.46 - Poll Result: GREAT!
8. Brotherhood of the Wolf - FCQ 48.08 - Poll Result: GREAT!
9. I Heart Huckabees - FCQ 47.86 - Poll Result: GREAT!
10. Contact - FCQ 46.79 - Poll Result: GREAT!