Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum What is your most HATED...
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
12 Angry Men (1997)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Twelve men must decide the fate of one when one juror objects to the jury's decision. (imdb)
Poster submitted by Gauntlet
Genre: Drama
Country: USA
Directed By: William Friedkin
Written By: Reginald Rose
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na Timmet
70
T3
na antonchigurh
85
T8
na 11harrylime
80
T5
na guliver
95
T10
na DavidJohnson
66
T4
na rdgb
79
T6
na m4th3u5
50
T2
na AAAutin
56
T7
na ResIpsa
78
T7
na Jorg
2
T6
na beat
50
T2
na saving
80
T7
na Domini
55
T4
na oak
70
T6
na lagartazul
78
T4
na theguest
65
T7
na bogancross
37
T3
na NickJacklson
83
T4
na landsome
79
T8
na turgay
80
T9
na cihadi
95
T9
na Voodoofly
50
T4
na saycho
96
T10
na rodrigoppb
82
T8
na TripleB
80
T10
na jksterup
80
T4
na Nes
74
T3
na Jerky
60
T8
na rattlemind
100
T10
na Cantstopdrew
90
T9
na sqw1rl
75
T6
na hellboy76
70
T8
na Jgreen
92
T8
na silentheaven
5
T4
na glumpy_99
90
T7
na scottlowry
100
T10
na samedge
100
T10
na iwalke
80
T7
na icebrain
72
T3
na theparaiba
74
T7
na dko
90
T10
na naeim
95
T10
na ilsensine
70
T7
na ellinikos
70
T5
It's not a bad remake, per se, but it is a clumsy one, and Friedkin takes great pains to point out subtleties that Lumet's version left for the audience to pick out for themselves. Everyone involved feels like a weak shadow of their 1957 selves, leaving the whole thing feeling distinctly washed-out and unnecessary.
na CryingGame
9
T4
na moviefreak
82
T6
na DougCollins
90
T7
na ElvisTR
89
T9
na jsopanen
52
T5
na chocobaby
70
T5
na dialM
70
T1
na fedrod
84
T8
na Cronos
80
T6
na avgcrtckr
64
T7
na fenixdown
76
T6
na glm
88
T9
87.500
na rafa_livrari
80
T8
na tetcyo
75
T8
na uprising
86
T7
na mrmoc
94
T10
na oguzhaners
79
T7
na Eddo
85
T9
na JJ1986
60
T6
na btopbas
80
T6
na amin323
80
T8
na some_trouble
80
T7
na Nadif91
85
T7
Didn't saw the original, but here's my opinion from this flick. Friedkin just got bored from watching nowadays TV and decided to make an reality show: 12 men in a room to discuss a boy sentence. With the plus that the chosen ones have personality and, most of them, intelligence. But, wait a minute, this movie is from the 90s, and, fortunately, reality shows weren't that popular. So, maybe, he just got bored and made a remake from a great film that I didn't watch, and it's better that any reality
na trailblazers
6
T5
na tef
90
T9
na ingridrodem
100
T10
na CritickerAvg
64
T7
na htcaetano
75
T8
na Scar
85
T9
na lyz-keaton
100
T10
na Biebobax223
75
T5
na killjoy
60
T2
na Diego_L
63
T3
na rant1229
80
T8
na paulmd
30
T2
na Tortuga Down
80
T5
na ipek
93
T10
na Marcastro
80
T7
na mdavid
73
T7
na Voodoo
90
T7
na sengir
80
T7
na esekherif
95
na Axel
75
T9
na filmcricket
72
T8
na aliaspider
90
T6
na auhasarderik
60
T7
na badger33
83
T7
na Natali
85
T7
na chris98383
80
T7
na arianemq
80
T8
na supergloo
9
T9
na drmike
86
T7
na mordecai
70
T1
na LOTNorm
90
T9
na Carpetgiant
83
T6
na MadMan
89
T7
na JJJames
60
T3
na amartin3
93
T10
na toanianaj
85
T8
na borges
2
T2
na Prince Sandy
81
T9
na hoolie
85
T7
na Travisbickle
80
T5
Likable remake of a classic.
na bleary
95
T10
na imdb
76
T9
na shibbyo
5
T8
na Sunsplitter
54
T7
na KasperL
70
T7
na BoringRobots
1
T6
na LightningBob
60
T6
na andreuzeda
64
T3
na BlueHeat
72
T6
na KMcNeil
50
T5
na Puddleglum
88
T9
na nminichino
70
T7
na ivyy
65
T7
na Malcym
60
T6
na Cuculiza
40
T2
Considerably worse than the original, but still just ok. I'd recommend to see the original one though. This remake is absolutely unnecesary.
na madiso
55
T5
na Booster
50
T4
na DanseMacabre
80
T7
na hereslucas
64
T3
na ZakMcCracken
70
T6
na ntndeacon
70
T4
na Jellysauce
70
T6
na xaninof
82
T9
haven't seen the original but this one was terrific!
na datapress
7
T4
na TroyAnderson
58
T5
na mike615
69
T7
na Kate.Hopkins
80
T10
na LmanofMGS3
86
T7
na bmmello
70
T3
na Stain
90
T9
Not quite as good as the first version, but sometimes the material is so good that nobody could screw it up
na kellyboo
68
T5
na Audhumla
80
T4
An unnecessary remake, but by no means a terrible one.
na schnofel
74
T8
na charliebobo
70
T8
na Arreana
95
T10
na hayden18
72
T2
na cblur21
92
T10
na GonzaloGM
80
T3
na joey_deli
78
T7
na Carlo Paz
64
T4
na lostinlodos
42
T2
na PeterLeb
80
T8
na DLawrence
82
T8
na Marigold
60
T4
na AceC
92
T5
na Elekoise
52
T6
na chiphall72
88
T9
na Fetsch
70
T6
na nu3nn
80
T6
na acarolla
2
T7
na eques
65
T4
na Zoltan
65
T5
na IMDb-byvotes
76
T8
na KaioShin
84
T9
na AngelaC
80
T5
na Jan
75
T6
na marianacosta
70
T2
na buddymcl
91
T9
na The Comedian
76
T7
na salparadise
78
T7
na paniskalpel
82
T8
na kml
65
T4
na Ortman
25
T1
na Rocketlucco
75
T8
Overall Enjoyment: 30/40, Plot/Themes: 15/20, Cinematography/Direction: 15/20, Acting/Writing: 15/20
na the_tempter
70
T7
na ShogunRua
70
T8
Very worthy remake thanks to terrific performances by Jack Lemmon and George C. Scott, and an adherence to the original script. Still, it's been done better before, and to be great, one needs the full ensemble performance. Certain jurors, such as Tony Danza, simply don't pull their respective weight.
na alpinaburana
73
T6
na Holygrail2
89
T7
na filmaffinity
75
T9
na Charlie
60
T4
na abbas
92
T10
na misterpaul
100
T9
na Sonse
80
T7
na afail
85
T8
na jpb33
51
T7
na losingctrl
83
T7
na bernardobrum
80
T5
na Iwantham
77
T6
na dagda2
85
T7
na Gatt
95
T10
na jliebow
92
T9
na Mazros
78
T8
na r.e.t.
70
T5
It's a good movie, well directed, well played, but... the original movie from 1957 is perfect. So...it's a remake that nobody needs. Pity.
na dharmabum
42
T3
Average Tier 6.5 from 191 Rankings rss