Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum PTA
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
A Dirty Carnival (2006)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: In Seoul, Byung-Doo is a twenty-nine year old gangster that works under the command of Sang-Shui in the mobster organization of the boss Hwang. Byung-Doo is also the patriarch of his family and is having financial problems to support his old mother that is very ill and his younger siblings... (imdb)
Poster submitted by Mawazh
AKA: Biyeolhan geori
Country: South Korea
Directed By: Ha Yu
Written By: Ha Yu
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na adidawha
82
T8
na Bandy
75
T6
na lostinlodos
50
T2
Very slow drama; no action and no real hint of suspense either. Just a slow, disrupted plot and a letdown of an ending.
na piquet
65
T5
na kyussj
60
T4
na FrankHowley
70
T5
A little unfocused with its multiple subplots, the it's still solid and enjoyable.
na frnk23
70
T7
the boss singing at the end got it a 70 not the best of the genre but a solid effort
na PaRaNoYa7
20
T5
na thewire
98
T10
na stefro
92
T9
na Discard
77
T7
na RoXoN
80
T6
na crazymoronx
70
T5
na Dreamtime
80
T8
na Alpagu
75
T4
na esayar
85
T8
na FancyClown
72
T5
na ari
75
T8
na ustadegilim
89
T10
na ugur7
85
T9
na laedri
70
T8
na nateb
75
T6
A good Korean gangster movie with intensity, violence, and heart. The ending is great.
na ricozy
80
T8
gordugum en iyi dovus sahnelerine sahip mafya filmi. sonunu bu kadar uzatmasaydilar keske.
na periboku
85
T9
na rev.elation
60
T6
na kyle.loomis
6
T7
It doesn't exceed what you might expect from a South Korean modern day gangster film (engaging with great camerawork, but a little overlong), but it is a solid piece, and recommendable to someone who is in to that kind of thing.
na Blowtorch
85
T7
na Renoir
84
T7
na aaronwhat
100
T10
na bedirhankara
73
T6
na peekingpanda
85
T10
na Kel
80
T8
na BadSmile
80
T10
na Murderface
65
T5
na I0000days
78
T9
na syratr
80
T6
na Mawazh
70
T5
na gaddark
75
T7
na gyanrosling
6
T3
na snipertaz
88
T6
na pascally
89
T10
na zae
60
T4
na Onxapu
70
T8
na Piglet
77
T9
na avgcrtckr
69
T8
na Anti-Met
93
T7
na kangadoodoo
60
T6
na winds
4
T3
na imdb
76
T9
na hungrybear
7
T7
na filmaffinity
70
T8
na xTraP
75
T8
na muku25
79
T9
na GEARSX
100
T10
na cloak
83
T10
na Falooza
80
T10
na TeamShadow
100
T10
na Matthew
80
T8
na kalim
96
T9
na Fill
80
T9
na isaacristich
75
T5
na barfly
73
T7
na 1strong
68
T7
na schnofel
47
T4
na Tostadora
77
T7
na whatismyname
65
T7
Lots of fighting with an alright storyline.
na ramco1905
85
T7
na Passero
90
T9
na chemical404
68
T8
na zapotka
74
T8
na lyrradsemaj
86
T9
na Asgarth
76
T7
na salty dog
55
T3
na sengir
80
T7
na katsuben
4
T6
na Winged
5
T10
na de_niro
75
T7
na IMDb-byvotes
75
T7
na kvaka65
4
T6
na Praguer
85
T8
na st_fly
34
T4
Average. A Korean gangster film that starts off pretty good but turns very conventional midway through and ends in a cliché laden disappointing mess. Although it does feature some very unique and brutal fight sequences, it's still too derivative to warrant a viewing. Not Recommended.
na cemcan1245
88
T8
na newsunrize
65
T4
na kataruna
77
T4
na PaulMorel
77
T4
na dharma
80
T10
na Barthalen
78
T7
It's a bit longer than it needed to be, but the end result is pretty satisfying. Seems to borrow a lot of elements from a wide range of gangster films/series, but mixes them fairly well into something that stands on its own.
na gonzalo
7
T6
na Cinema_Asia
75
T7
The main flaw with the film is that the whole subplot with the director friend seemed to be shoehorned in. It's not a bad premise but it's forced and the events just aren't believable in what is a somewhat realistic contemporary gangster film. Not a bad effort from Ha Yu but there's just much better examples of the genre out there. The acting is pretty good though and the violence is gut wrenching realistic.
na cat9man
64
T4
na hyunwoo8521
84
T5
na InsaneGamer
94
T10
na JooJoo
3
T3
na bigpgo
70
T4
na Licio
89
T9
Average Tier 6.99 from 95 Rankings rss