Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum The Help 2011
the Blog New Enhancement Film Typ...
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
A Room with a View (1985)
Post to Facebook
Posted to your Facebook profile
Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: When Lucy Honeychurch and chaperone Charlotte Bartlett find themselves in Florence with rooms without views, fellow guests Mr Emerson and son George step in to remedy the situation. Meeting the Emersons could change Lucy's life forever but, once back in England, how will her experiences in Tuscany affect her marriage plans? (imdb)
Genre: Romance
Country: UK
Directed By: James Ivory
Additional Information & Actions
More information at IMDb
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na porcepic
90
T9
na verbals
78
T7
na demrahc13
86
T6
na jmnfisher
90
T8
na katsuben
3
T5
na marrie86
50
T8
na ImJacksName
60
T5
na Mirabell
40
T3
na Risselada
75
T6
na richard_1979
60
T1
na jorge
70
T6
na lena_c
3
T5
na vsls
70
T7
na Minjo
63
T4
na aapap
80
T7
na alinag
80
T8
na Scottathon
71
T4
na charliedaly
81
T8
na flubug
100
T10
na caffe
64
T4
na Emma24
90
T5
na KTP
40
T5
na BadmintonRed
87
T9
na parasol94
80
T8
na schiele_
85
T9
na mvsilva
75
T4
na pseudoelf
80
T8
na AndyDan
60
T1
na grannoid
65
T3
na barbarrett
72
T4
na Bunken
75
T9
na iownpurple
76
T6
na Darbicus
70
T7
na Greg K
67
T7
na sunamiabe
86
T8
na Dunstan-x
89
T10
na pl_
60
T2
na maddriver52
39
T1
na mfeldman9
71
T3
na Rufam
70
T6
This elegant and restrained James Ivory costume drama is just graceful enough to keep its audience constantly engaged and just as controlled to never let it be anything more than mildly fascinated. Splendidly made, well-filmed and blessed with a top-notch cast, "A Room With a View" is nevertheless rather unspectacular and its beautifully framed shots quickly evaporate from memory. It is undoubtedly good enough for what it is though and it fully succeeds on the terms it sets.
na Vegard
70
T6
na mike615
67
T6
na garbo
40
T3
na Margaux
84
T7
na Miss Marple
80
T8
na scanoni
60
T4
na lidi
83
T8
na kirbyk
40
T1
na GeneSiskel
100
T9
More than a great love story. It's both a lighthearted and deeply impassioned inspirational lesson about life.
na VegA
50
T3
na Georgija
73
T4
na ATLANTIS1
0
T6
na a4q96rm
80
T6
na Tds4a
76
T7
na Ofterdingen
53
T4
na Motorific
60
T8
na tinlizzy3k
85
T9
na Vasily
80
T8
na Spader
61
T8
na codpiece
80
T7
na LouisMazzini
74
T6
na auhasarderik
80
T9
na machanstyle
60
T4
na jayboy
80
T7
na cranky
76
T8
na finney28
70
T7
na Jos
75
T5
na catfacer
57
T5
na Cro$by
80
T6
na djross
75
T9
na screentime
86
T10
na DougReese
75
T8
na horatio5
76
T10
na iamackechnie
75
T5
na hsula23
99
T7
na jschoj
80
T6
na dr. radical
55
T3
na Fuentissimo
15
T1
na bharath
73
T7
na Ciro
98
T8
na CritickerAvg
66
T8
na Koru
50
T1
na ar656
70
T3
na aurora
42
T3
na kerridwen
70
T5
na jlh
68
T5
na IMDb-byvotes
75
T7
na Knicke
90
T9
na gregger
100
T10
One of the best adaptation scripts ever written is turned into a truly great film. Everything works in this movie from the opening strains of Verdi's music to the last scene when the lovers return to Florence. Not a wrong note is hit. Perfect casting, deft direction. Beautiful! A definite five star attraction.
na chinless
35
T2
na Marty
40
T3
na Jaguuu
85
T8
na ZujGag
1
T6
na wigwam_uk
80
T5
na bentien
77
T9
na sebageek
98
T9
na wolfe41
80
T6
na Plaza
5
T4
na plantedtrees
86
T9
na thaklos
82
T7
This is a placid romance, but I found the young Bonham Carter enrapturing despite the restrictions of her character. The setting and production is lovely, and I certainly love the period and the theme, but taken as a whole I find the film slightly uneventful. There is a lot of meaning in examining only the slow process of overturning social convention, but it isn't a particularly visceral experience, and I think the film could have made better use of its medium in conveying its message.
na mmorrow
95
T10
A well-acted, witty study of propriety versus desire. Every character is delightful.
na ecalder
37
T1
na avgcrtckr
65
T8
na redford
65
T5
na Va3H
84
T5
Scrumptious, enticing and perfectly orchestrated with all the clamor and superfluousness of the passionate but cold Victorian Age. The cast is depicted as a lovely family that nonetheless lives in a very sexually repressed period, coupled by the authoritarian values of obedience and discipline. In spite of the lush and pristine camera work mirroring the ethos of the age, it however, belabors far too much on the nature of emotional love without separating itself from prior films.
na jbull08
78
T6
na cussot
79
T5
na NathonGunn
75
T7
na juliomadiaga
92
T9
na Cloudynow
71
T8
na meester
5
T1
na mucion
85
T8
na walkabout
76
T9
na jgnikkila
90
T7
na sunhill
76
T6
na zurnzurn
70
T7
na bridggedale
85
T9
na ayban
90
T8
na zuleyka
75
T8
na citysqwirl
94
T10
na creck
75
T7
na avdibeg
92
T9
na orkunersin
40
T1
na knedlik
83
T5
na Ariana23
80
T8
na alya5030
86
T7
na spamhead80
96
T10
na bore
90
T8
na kirsty22
70
T7
na kangadoodoo
70
T8
na Forrester
50
T2
na yk_nomisugi
76
T10
na gnep
30
T1
na Barkinson
60
T7
na TnS
60
T4
na sobored
60
T4
na oalerabelo
75
T5
na BurstBubble
80
T4
na Dally
85
T8
na quirkyjunky
73
T6
na skittlez
97
T9
na smallmouth
75
T5
na Tjekhov
30
T2
na allisoncm
22
T1
na leeloo
70
T6
na PaulMorel
77
T5
na pjdevitt
83
T6
na mallamp
80
T8
na Clemmi
70
T7
na paulduncan
80
T9
na pitn
87
T6
na MVSCH
70
T5
na sthickett
80
T9
na gert
75
T9
na Meta Critic
80
T10
na Grinner
85
T8
na justinhilton
74
T7
na kiprijst
100
T10
na fradine
50
T1
na dialectical1
93
T10
na theloaf
3
T2
na grodrig1
97
T9
na donquixotic
62
T9
na imdb
75
T9
na ldpfilm
90
T10
na nrm4
63
T6
na biscuitgirl
90
T9
na Al Chambers
80
T3
na akjn
65
T4
na FutureCritic
55
T3
na penguinfreud
15
T2
na niksworth
70
T3
na kasator
85
T9
na Deadmarsh
60
T5
na mrs_zelda
90
T5
na dj001k
50
T5
na Denise
35
T1
na saud
90
T9
na Razorclock
40
T1
na Cherish
80
T9
na Blair
82
T6
na Sgabriel
65
T3
na Theyshootpic
10
T3
na jeff_v
60
T3
na android88
42
T1
na mrsfrenetico
70
T7
na Bailey74
82
T9
na hoolie
88
T8
na toanianaj
95
T10
na dqnw
70
T6
na by Devol
56
T2
na filmlover
82
T9
na borgeest
70
T6
A pretty but rather tedious adaptation, fatally undermined by poor casting of its principals. Saved somewhat by an early iteration of Maggie Smith playing the single delightful charicature she was to make her own, and Rupert Graves' fringe.
na HoneyHoxley
88
T10
na strangelime
85
T7
na penguin
80
T9
na SailorRipley
93
T9
na bigloser
74
T9
na welike
20
T5
na Stain
40
T3
Makes its point in the first quarter of an hour, then belabors it for the rest of the movie
na lynchian
65
T5
na JerryJ
50
T4
na closer_
73
T8
na Mochard
60
T6
na TroyAnderson
74
T8
na y3n0
87
T8
na alikocaali
75
T5
na andymalafaya
65
T8
na tanjav
89
T10
na Ariaz
79
T7
na bhoyo
89
T9
na 13ncuCuma
50
T2
na pfft
74
T6
na I'm prowler
70
T9
na PetrosTser
80
T8
na dkratzm
75
T1
na lotr-sam0711
90
T9
na Flatlands
78
T7
na keskin
63
T5
na bprosser10
6
T6
na Kristin
85
T10
na soraxtm
70
T6
na nosyparker
85
T10
na cryteno
80
T7
na dpanov
45
T2
na ombroph09
95
T8
na hazelhawks
80
T9
na sjostrand
65
T8
na oakwoodjoe
70
T8
na IndyFilmFest
95
T9
na Cuculiza
80
T8
Yes, we've all seen all these themes before, but Ivory narrates the film in such a delightful way you just can't help but enjoy it.
na glumpy_99
92
T8
na doctorbu
82
T6
na Melia
96
T7
na LetsGoEatHuh
55
T6
na cgm707
99
na flowing
64
T6
na glm
88
T9
88.125
na msalmonse
85
T6
na eveelun
58
T2
To be fair, this movie is a fine example of its genre (Victorian period piece), but personally all the repressed sexuality and romanticized acts of rebellion seem both silly and boring.
na epram33
75
T3
na CianM
88
T9
na demirtas
1
T2
na drealeed
70
T6
na Ronin21
87
T10
na Atticus987
70
T6
na kastenm
79
T8
na Crazy Jack
88
T10
na Litigator
60
T6
na sagitario
60
T3
Displaying 1 to 250 of 522 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Tier 6.47 from 522 Rankings rss