Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Music
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
After the Thin Man (1936)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Selma asks Nick to find her missing husband. He had been seeing a bit on the side, and blackmailing a local criminal. David Graham claims he paid the missing husband to get rid of a former girlfriend. Will Nick locate him ? (imdb)
Poster submitted by Gauntlet
Country: USA
Directed By: W.S. Van Dyke
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na notsothinman
90
T7
na IMDb-byvotes
75
T7
na agape23
65
T7
na wmelton
90
T10
na strangelime
90
T8
na empire434
72
T7
na frg
5
T5
na tyoda
90
T10
na jorge
75
T8
na screentime
75
T8
na sceptre_777
75
T8
na OfTheAllies
90
T10
na texasdragon
100
T10
na roger1
83
T4
na CMQuinn
70
T6
na hazelhawks
70
T7
na 5thHobbit
87
T7
na ledfloyd
90
T9
na Tibicina4JMJ
79
T8
na gloryhornet
60
T6
na caffe
71
T5
na winds
6
T8
na kyle.loomis
5
T6
na negative
2
T6
na okidude
4
T8
This installment of the Thin Man series fleshes out some of the staple characters a bit more. I find it a touch more enjoyable, believe it or not. Definitely lighter than the first in the series
na buddymcl
91
T9
na JJJames
78
T7
na hardcourters
93
T9
just as funny as the original with a better whodunit....five bones on the astameter! highly recommended.
na billkerwin
76
T4
Not as good as the first one. Still, an amusing way to pass the time. And it's worth it for Jimmy Stewart's surprising performance.
na jeff_v
71
T7
More comedy-mystery adventures of the screen's greatest married couple, Nick and Nora Charles. I wish I were that witty when I'm drunk. Asta should have won an Oscar, his subplot was hilarious.
na kastenm
74
T6
na fivecats
82
T5
na aevitatis
70
T5
na sirphibes
76
T7
na Ununnilium
87
T9
na cactusman
88
T6
na Gurrkin
70
T7
na jen11x
70
T6
na GodlessNoble
80
T8
na Devyn
100
T9
na MMAlpha
56
T4
na Rumplesink
75
T7
na avgcrtckr
71
T9
na KasperL
60
T5
Doesn't measure up to the delightful original. Of the five sequels, I'd say it's the one to check out. For more Powell-Loy banter, and for James Stewart as one of the suspects.
na pecnj
83
T7
na optional
1
T6
na LongHaul
75
T6
na skeller
85
T6
na bnilsen23
80
T6
na Gordon Cole
91
T10
na martin_meeks
90
T6
na olebole
7
T6
na Hangarl
80
T9
na oakwoodjoe
65
T6
na wetwillies
90
T7
An excellent sequel! Myrna Loy and William Powell still have the greatest chemistry, but you have a new actor thrown into the mix: James fuckin Stewart! It's an early role and it's one Hitchcock probably should've seen. Asta is also hysterical in this one and I felt really bad for him. It's hard to say, but I think I might prefer this one.
na Sunsplitter
52
T6
na fletch
75
T7
na cori1312
90
T9
na kaanbalci
0
T6
na JacquelynB
8
T4
Love seeing Jimmy Stewart in this one. Asta plays a fine leading dog and wins my heart again. Polly made me cringe every time she spoke. Myrna Loy and William Powell still had it and were a delight.
na themadelf66
76
T6
na SonofaGunn1
70
T8
na Icarus
88
T9
This series of films is all about the privilege of watching Myrna Loy and William Powell offer witticisms and happily married chemistry as some nefarious plot unfolds before them. The detective angle drives the plot, and Jimmy Stewart definitely raises the level of the cast in this, the second installment of the series. The fact that I am not sure whether I prefer the first or the second says a great deal about the success of this one. Fun film.
na filmcricket
78
T9
na Enygma
75
T6
na brianrobot
4
T7
na LouisMazzini
79
T8
na gdog13cavs
70
T10
na FlixR8r
75
T8
na Cherish
60
T4
na dagda2
80
T5
na Mango
4
T5
na Theodora
80
T8
na MrsEmmaPeel
85
T8
na Esmerodo
85
T9
na soliloquist
83
T8
na RNG
65
T7
na OldSwede
77
T8
na TonythePony
73
T7
na chesterfilms
75
T6
na tdawson48
75
T7
na purity
3
T9
na Gauntlet
90
T10
na coolerking
75
T7
na wig
88
T8
na Gecq
60
T4
na Nicolle
74
T3
na StephenWolfe
70
T9
na welike
20
T5
na filmsnob
77
T9
na filmlover
75
T6
na InfiniteZero
70
T4
na turin
70
T7
na bigloser
73
T8
na PeaceAnarchy
77
T5
This sequel doesn't quite have the involving plot of the original but it has the great characters and those are really the most important part.
na dissidentdov
80
T7
na RisingVenus
75
T8
na EvilShoe
75
T7
na stepsideways
92
T9
na yesnid
100
T10
na dr. radical
88
T10
na darkman
82
T9
na tonydal
85
T9
Whoa--Jimmy Stewart as Norman Bates (or something like that). Pretty surreal stuff. A couple of the women overact fairly mercilessly, but on the whole it's quite a big batch of fun (even if Asta does get cuckolded somewhere in the mix).
na DTI
78
T4
na mikej99a
92
T5
na sandri
90
T9
na TJ_Camber
65
T6
na paghat
77
T6
na kyvetti
70
T7
na allisoncm
77
T9
na Sam Lowry
3
T6
na massesRasses
75
T7
na Freder
70
T6
The usual straight-up shot of breezy, light wonderfulness.
na CaptMal
86
T7
na jolson
65
T2
na Luna6ix
72
T3
once again i fail to see any real value in powell or loy, and this one isnt even as good as the first, which was fairly lackluster it's self. what it does have is jimmy stewart in an early role and a damn fine one at that. the payoff is the best part in this one, just like the first.
na Crazy Jack
75
T7
na comanchex
94
T9
na wildweasel
100
T10
na Laura2812
85
T9
na queendork56
7
T8
na Jgirl2688
97
T9
na iceblox
77
T8
na Dirk33
80
T6
na imdb
75
T9
na redmdb
93
T9
na CRB9000
99
T10
na rb42083
80
T6
na maddriver52
32
T2
na silniet
65
T2
na Maxx2029
85
T7
Not as strong as the original. But again Powell and Loy are the reason to watch Thin Man movies, not the plots.
na chiphall72
97
T10
na filmaffinity
67
T6
na jonbowy
80
T8
na gleeb
74
T6
na cblur21
75
T8
na schnofel
65
T6
na nilty3000
90
T8
na PhantomZone
92
T9
Great follow up, keeping all the coolness of the first. The overall acting group is better this time around.
na Dancon7
74
T7
na RPMcMurphy
74
T8
Average Tier 7.1 from 141 Rankings rss