Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum The state of sci-fi
the Blog Server Upgrade
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
All Quiet on the Western Front (1979)
Share Post to Facebook
Posted to your Facebook profile
Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: A young soldier faces profound disillusionment in the soul-destroying horror of World War I. (imdb)
Genres: Drama, War
Country: UK, USA
Directed By: Delbert Mann
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na stahwang
60
T8
na Tizzy
50
T4
na NaCE4JNWx
85
T6
na georgia sam
73
T5
na overrated
42
T4
na Dunstan-x
5
T5
na unohav_1
80
T5
Good, but not as great as the original.
na Coredor
71
T6
na lachyc
55
T4
na lilac
80
T5
na panzerwolf
74
T6
na luc
67
T5
na Travisbickle
95
T9
na AGMelv
84
T8
na martygrant
80
T5
na Luna6ix
82
T8
while the war action may be a bit on the light side, and simply not done very well, the source material is something that is simply impervious to tarnish. borgnine is a treat and all the other players are servicable at worst. it could have stayed a bit closer to the book, but other than that i have no complaints.
na digitalmonk
79
T8
na slackerish
55
T4
na ImJacksName
60
T5
na Qwipster.net
70
T8
na Bagger
60
T4
na Fetsch
70
T6
na Gideon
3
T10
na nunstrangler
57
T4
A big-budget TV remake of the 1930 masterpiece starring John Boy. Nowhere near the original's quality.
na Qwa
82
T8
na saucyjack
70
T5
Not nearly as good as the version from 1930, but still serviceable. Plus, it has The Borgnine.
na St. Gloede
60
T3
na Erminas
75
T5
na jonjj7
70
T7
na ZayanK
71
T5
na PirateKitty
78
T5
na PolegaR
80
T8
na JohnnyZombie
79
T4
na Zoltan
65
T6
na sengir
78
T5
na pilotpirx
75
T6
na IMDb-byvotes
70
T6
na RNG
61
T7
na cosmovitelli
62
T5
na TheAlliance
79
T7
na whitefang
80
T6
na iar80
82
T8
na Raabeyes
71
T8
na Llanirev
60
T4
na Braunsweig
75
T9
na TJ Ximenez
40
T3
na Booster
70
T7
na djfntstque
55
T3
na bigloser
69
T5
na Tds4a
65
T5
na Crazy Jack
75
T7
na fletch
85
T9
na Cronos
30
T2
na rollsroyce
25
T1
na BurstBubble
90
T6
na johnshaft
80
T8
na Blair
80
T5
na sweetsin0r
70
T3
na lebasi
3
T6
na filmcricket
61
T6
na oblakoff
83
T9
na teecee
45
T7
na kreid
75
T6
na LetsGoEatHuh
60
T8
na bolivar
67
T4
na Wieland
70
T6
na Waldheri
85
T9
na hoven
50
T4
na Sachaz
65
T6
na dbentien
60
T5
na agrilledfish
60
T4
na SNAKEFOOD89
65
T1
na Bevo52
88
T9
na gert
60
T5
na bussiebas
65
T3
na Wilio
85
T10
na Scottathon
70
T4
na CrazyJim9380
77
T5
na Megaharrison
67
T8
na SarahG1988
89
T7
na yrsinrevolt
70
T3
na coolitsember
75
T3
na froce
80
T9
na DePalma
67
T7
na graveyardtan
80
T6
na cloak
57
T5
na magikid
50
T4
na c0eus
87
T9
na Nilsbar
85
T6
na Widda_K
28
T5
na helfen419
93
T10
na bentien
53
T4
na crimsonking
58
T3
na redpatriot
85
T9
na no1oscar
89
T7
na jgolden
75
T5
na JackDurden
7
T5
na neggbird
72
T5
na thegrayghost
90
T10
na Mikado
66
T5
na renovatio
50
T6
na Whaleybab
70
T5
na scanoni
70
T6
na clayhog
70
T5
na benito
78
T8
na KasperL
50
T4
na sidehacker
44
T3
na Hamirubi
71
T6
na Sidney_Deane
75
T7
na Egregius
77
T4
The story is good, but having read the book first, I was sorely dissapointed. A lot of elements that were hard to translate to movie went missing, or were rendered incompletely. Besides this, for me it was weird to see British playing Germans fighting French. I enjoyed Borgnine, and the movie brought its message across without moralising, which I liked.
na TheDiceman
60
T7
Not as good as the original.
na MBBinger
70
T6
na Minjo
67
T4
na Robert-Jan
75
T8
na Bearded Dave
75
T6
na noiz
74
T8
na SydLennox
85
T6
na salty dog
70
T6
na Serigala
60
T2
na Ines Adriana
80
T7
na JerryJ
60
T6
na Roshambo
40
T2
na jjack229
72
T8
na LOTNorm
87
T7
na Mr.JJ
70
T3
na octanoid77
82
T3
na outsid3r
9
T4
na Melveis
5
T6
na tinythedogg
70
T7
na spacefloh
66
T7
ger; [Im Westen nichts Neues]; ein junge wird an die front berufen, dort erfährt er den krieg mit seinen zerstörerischen eigenschaften.
na dst7175
70
T6
IT WAS A GOOD MOVIE BUT THE ENDING WAS BAD...
na ozymandius10
81
T8
na sebfryer
60
T5
na unne
79
T7
na Marigold
58
T3
na NyNNyXX
82
T6
na Jorg
3
T10
na Cobber55
65
T6
na imdb
71
T8
na CaptainSteve
70
T7
na imag7
60
T5
na Sportfreunde
80
T6
na KillerXombie
60
T3
Average Tier 5.82 from 143 Rankings rss