Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Top 5 Director Averages
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Another Thin Man (1939)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: In this adaptation of Dashiell Hammett's "The Farewell Murder", Nick and Nora (and their dog Asta) visit the estate of Col. MacFay, who is being threatened by a mysterious man wanting revenge for a past injustice. When MacFay is murdered, that man is the obvious suspect- maybe too obvious... (imdb)
Poster submitted by Gauntlet
Country: USA
Directed By: W.S. Van Dyke
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na frg
4
T4
na themadelf66
80
T8
na empire434
80
T8
na caffe
71
T5
na torontodog
75
T8
na tyoda
40
T3
na hazelhawks
63
T6
na IMDb-byvotes
73
T7
na Crazy Jack
72
T6
na kastenm
65
T3
na StephenWolfe
60
T8
na gloryhornet
60
T6
na Tibicina4JMJ
56
T4
na buddymcl
91
T9
na aevitatis
70
T5
na Luna6ix
76
T5
the thin man series takes some getting used to, so by the third one i began to get accustomed to it, the chemistry between powell and loy is impressive, and this time the story actually interested me.
na fivecats
80
T5
na CMQuinn
70
T6
na roger1
74
T1
na avgcrtckr
64
T7
na avb
84
T6
na Rumplesink
70
T6
na sirphibes
78
T8
na KasperL
55
T5
Enjoyable enough.
na Gordon Cole
88
T9
na pecnj
84
T8
na jkwall
7
T7
na filmcricket
66
T7
na Hangarl
70
T7
na Ununnilium
83
T8
na OfTheAllies
80
T9
na texasdragon
90
T8
na Sunsplitter
49
T5
na fletch
75
T7
na Qwiglee
84
T6
na Icarus
75
T6
Enjoyable, but a clear step down from the delightful antics of the first two films. There's still a great deal to love here, as the two leads are so much fun. However, there are a number of places where the film lags, particularly in the early going as the plot takes its time unfolding. The real stand out sequence here takes place in the dance club, which has it all--comedy, mystery, dancing, and Powell & Loy at their most flirtatious.
na lch37
99
T10
na kyle.loomis
4
T4
na Mango
4
T5
na Theodora
75
T6
na Esmerodo
80
T8
na allisoncm
70
T7
na MrsEmmaPeel
78
T6
na Gauntlet
80
T9
na RoundMyWay
60
T6
na TonythePony
68
T5
na RNG
58
T6
na dr. radical
76
T10
na turin
62
T5
na PeaceAnarchy
76
T5
na dissidentdov
75
T5
na Freder
70
T6
You get what you pay for with any of the Thin Man movies -- a light little mystery with just a touch of noir and a big, BIG helping of flirtatious charm doled out in experly measured doses by Powell, Loy and a plethora of familiar faces in the supporting casts. None of the thin man movies rank as my favorites, but all are good for a quick, light romantic meal.
na mikej99a
97
T8
na yesnid
90
T10
na darkman
80
T8
na sandri
90
T9
na silniet
68
T2
na iceblox
72
T7
na gleeb
72
T5
na kyvetti
60
T4
na queendork56
8
T10
na Monika
79
T2
na okidude
3
T6
A slight retreat from the first two movies in terms of comedy and theatrics.
na Laura2812
75
T5
na wbi
86
T8
na imdb
73
T8
na chiphall72
96
T10
na tonydal
80
T8
Rather routine first half is made up for by the fun of the second, which features an absolutely hilarious encounter between Nora and a Latin lover on the dance floor, as well as Nick's interaction with Ma Kettle, during which Myrna is seen wearing an amazing coat. Then there's the rather silly kiddie party, which Shemp drops in on. Did that hugely labyrinthine wrap-up really make sense? Well, as always with these things, that takes second fiddle to all the drollery, double takes and one-liners.
na PhantomZone
85
T7
The third one keeps the flame alive as the series continues to work well.
na CRB9000
80
T9
na nilty3000
90
T8
na schnofel
40
T3
na cblur21
75
T8
na filmaffinity
66
T6
na bigloser
75
T9
Average Tier 6.52 from 75 Rankings rss