Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum The Avengers
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Ashes and Diamonds (1958)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Maciek, a young Resistance fighter, is ordered to kill Szczuka, a Communist district leader, on the last day of World War II... (imdb)
Poster submitted by Gauntlet
AKA: Popiól i diament
Genres: Drama, War
Country: Poland
Directed By: Andrzej Wajda
Written By: Jerzy Andrzejewski
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na cactusman
90
T8
na JerryJ
60
T6
na catfacer
95
T10
na Ibn Salami
7
T6
na Throb Zombie
75
T3
na Rosomaqa
90
T4
na bentien
68
T6
na LRibeiro
79
T7
na clarkah
70
T6
na AtGiza
69
T7
na IMDb-byvotes
79
T9
na MMAlpha
65
T6
na kylie
81
T9
na Adam Voigt
87
T10
na Neveryan
82
T8
na Madeline
95
T7
na Leland
87
T8
na JustinM
100
T6
na macumbalove
50
T6
na maxmellman
87
T6
na St. Gloede
89
T8
na johnatanjj
90
T9
na bood
95
T10
na cat9man
91
T9
na Ruifelizardo
80
T6
na givethanks
65
T6
na kyle.loomis
6
T7
Visually, perhaps the best I've seen so far from Wadja (yeah sorry that includes Kanal, not much else though) but the story left me fairly uninterested.
na Deadmarsh
40
T1
na jeff_v
88
T10
na adrian
75
T9
na margot
97
T8
na kronstadtli
90
T10
na Beaucine
5
T9
na Dally
85
T8
na LetsGoEatHuh
60
T8
na kris2222
20
T1
na theyshoot10
94
T9
126
na vanderdoido
90
T8
na onetwothree
70
T9
na ffiamma
60
T7
na Tds4a
88
T9
I've got to admit I expected something even better, but it's still excellent. It's an interesting setup, a political film about a young man charged with killing a Communist leader. We sympathise with this man, who is introduced to us in the first scene when he guns down two innocent people by mistake. It's a fascinatingly amoral movie that investigates the political struggles going on in Poland aside from World War II itself, and whether such loyalty is useful when the conflict ends.
na RHalpain
85
T9
na Risselada
65
T4
na mitchelly
88
T9
na calendula
80
T6
na jorge
90
T10
na TonyS.
90
T10
na aethling
77
T9
na pristinepain
90
T8
na kasator
90
T10
na LEAVES
63
T8
na cinebaixar
94
T10
na frg
9
T9
na lucas M.
96
T8
na Scottathon
73
T6
na syvyys
87
T8
na theyshoot11
94
T9
#126
na rbf451
85
T9
na Lone Wolf
84
T8
na Sience
89
T10
na Devyn
50
T4
na andreyrublev
79
T4
na nt_
90
T8
na Barry Lyndon
75
T7
na etherealtard
45
T2
na gyanrosling
7
T5
na elmakebabi
83
T10
na lethias
83
T8
na svenerik
95
T10
na WuGambino
75
T5
na nrm4
66
T7
na dbentien
70
T7
na Ibetolis1
88
T9
na fallinghouse
75
T7
na cougardash
65
T8
na monstro
96
T10
na ajbuh
85
T8
na Exidor
80
T8
na Dunstan-x
9
T10
na guvolefou
85
T10
na twisp
90
T10
na Princezz
90
T10
na avgcrtckr
78
T10
na gaucho
6
T9
na zamanzaman
76
T8
na NRM02
60
T7
na Rumplesink
75
T7
na Icarus
91
T10
The film's strength is definitely in its look--the framing, the lighting, the crispness of the shots, the fluid use of the camera, and the jarring cuts. The sequence in the crypt is the real stand out, with the dangling crucifix offering one of the most striking and meaningful shots in this--or any--film. The story is also compelling--particularly the central character Maciek, who vacillates between love and murder. He knows that choosing one will effectively eliminate the other from his life.
na rpowell
27
T7
na Fire
4
T10
na wolfstar
70
T4
na VivaLuis
90
T7
na ColonelTigh
93
T7
na hacivat
98
T10
na Janne
85
T9
na gemtea
92
T9
na rant1229
50
T10
na nicson
70
T8
na Enygma
85
T9
na Duval Spit
92
T10
na ProtectMeYou
10
T10
na ten
92
T9
na vwgregov
80
T9
na nuked
5
T2
na JooJoo
8
T9
na differenxe
81
T4
na simajudas
95
T8
na Neatly
81
T7
na LordofDance
45
T5
na kastenm
75
T6
na JJJames
90
T9
na Patryk
65
T4
na Jonis
53
T5
na Razuna
78
T6
na purity
3
T9
na flowing
86
T9
na pmj
90
T10
na dabinich
78
T8
na bmmello
85
T8
na chesterfilms
90
T9
na PimpPanda
65
T2
na Mango
4
T5
na paulofilmo
63
T3
Not at all what I was expecting. There was some nice cinematography in places, and a few touches of heart, but the rest seemed either inexcusably contrived or unnecessary. A few scenes were on the verge of embarrassing.
na rafalko6
9
T6
na j. b. goode
89
T6
na bluesoul
88
T9
na drillakiller
70
T7
na BlueHeat
90
T10
na happyfluke
92
T7
na digitalmonk
77
T7
na cinema_hell
88
T8
na Tizzy
95
T10
na Hellward
100
T10
na Chelman
85
T8
na filmaffinity
75
T9
na coltrane
6
T9
na penguinbob31
60
T2
na Teorema
97
T9
na turin
80
T10
na yrsinrevolt
90
T8
na Theyshootpic
87
T9
na HANDERS
92
T9
na michuk
88
T10
na eveelun
79
T8
na Mike_V
95
T10
na FitFortDanga
62
T3
This is supposed to be one of the great Wajda films, but it's one of my least favorites. Too political for my tastes, and most of it is dull as dirt. Nice lighting and framing, though.
na dissidentdov
90
T9
na stillfuchsia
85
T8
na Madstone
97
T9
na tigrre
82
T8
na mcf1989
80
T9
na metropical
85
T5
na theyshoot07
93
T9
# 135
na watanabe
70
T8
na caffe
64
T4
na spicebrain
72
T6
na aurora
89
T10
na j_bur
67
T4
na kangadoodoo
80
T10
na Darbicus
85
T9
na svan81
85
T9
na AntoniusB
65
T9
na Antoine
97
T10
na jbissell
100
T10
na ormz
7
T9
na coffee
79
T7
na winds
7
T10
na ehrenkm
100
T10
na sengir
80
T7
na ddj
100
T10
na Voice Within
84
T6
na dirtyzen
87
T10
na Spoon!
53
T5
na bloodsome
89
T9
na DougReese
100
T10
na negative
3
T8
na cloak
84
T10
na SirRobbie
100
T10
The best POLISH FILM EVER MADE !!! with a spectacular role played by Zbigniew Cybulski
na Sebastian
73
T7
na mucion
85
T8
na danielldb
90
T10
na Coheed
80
T9
na timoA
88
T7
A really stylish film about the last days of war and the Polish resistance. The opening scene is fantastic and the rest of the film is downright classic.
na kennardjon
75
T6
na jastrup
80
T8
na Jazzaloha
45
T1
na alexcucu
95
T6
na dumbjaw
64
T5
na bernardobrum
95
T10
na pilotpirx
80
T8
na Hopscotch
65
T3
na lotr-sam0711
80
T7
na BaalMan
90
T9
na suleyman
95
T9
na CaptMal
94
T8
na dmk
92
T10
na snb
73
T7
na IHateMovies
90
T8
na andagh
85
T7
na theyshoot08
94
T9
118
na Mike DAngelo
60
T7
na Ortman
98
T10
na TJ Ximenez
100
T9
na lyrradsemaj
93
T10
na yiyi
21
T8
na imdb
80
T10
na b4con
95
T10
na cranky
78
T9
na ronmel
89
T7
na s1killer
9
T9
na Turio
93
T8
na Bugsy89
70
T4
na a_doomoot3
90
T5
na rudolf55
94
T10
na ShogunRua
80
T10
na Warren
88
T9
na Veterini
73
T5
na PeaceAnarchy
89
T9
Average Tier 7.78 from 218 Rankings rss