This is a very interesting serious film from Ernst Lubitsch. A totally serious Phillips Holmes does well as the soldier with the demons and few can play a warming old man like Lionel Barrymore can. Nancy Carroll is cute and together they make the town talk and the movie viewer feel good. Lubitsch escape the difficult situations with the story but there is still a lot of little moments of emotion and suspense of what is right and wrong with a predicament where a killer visits his victims family.