Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum The state of sci-fi
the Blog Server Upgrade
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Burma VJ: Reporting from a Closed Country (2008)
Share Post to Facebook
Posted to your Facebook profile
Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Using smuggled footage, this documentary tells the story of the 2007 protests in Burma by thousands of monks.
AKA: Burma VJ: Reporter i et lukket land
Country: Denmark
Directed By: Anders Østergaard
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Trailer
Invalid Trailer
If you'd like, provide a new one!
Buy
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na djw263
84
T10
na 1stNigerian
95
T9
na tradingair
9
T10
na castadrift
75
T5
My only complaint is they did not indicate which scenes were re-constructed and which were genuine. Some of the scenes were incredibly moving in particular because I thought they were real footage, but I would feel deceived if they turned out to be re-constructed scenes. Apparently they re-enacted some of the street protest scenes in Chiang Mai, and one of the last scenes of the DVB headquarters being ransacked is also a re-enactment - but you wouldn't know it.
na luc
72
T8
na CHOICECOD
85
T8
na cambelboy
81
T8
na csidle
80
T8
na ericdupont
85
T8
na imdb
81
T10
na Budhisattva
84
T6
na DavidBlast
80
T8
I intensely dislike stylization in documentaries, and although I see how it has been necessary here, it's still irritating. The story is 'Hotel Rwanda' all over again. You might watch it and feel truly appalled, but at the end of that day, the sad state of affairs is that the world just doesn't give a shit. This documentary shames me - and I love it for it.
na raiders2000
87
T8
na Eglaia
75
T9
11.06.2010: Awww! My eyes still hurt.. Outstanding piece of work. Their bravery is outstanding.. The country's going to have an election in a few months, which after the devastating ending, made me smile a little.
na Gody85
54
T7
na Kristianvo
85
T7
na purup
80
T8
na bones_r
80
T8
na tankut
85
T8
na anakyle
10
T10
na Julius
80
T6
na MCR
84
T9
na Langelund
80
T9
na itvdigital
83
T9
A brave, political film making which humanises the struggle of the repressed and acts as a crucial reminder of the human rights abuses that often go unreported or ignored. Truly breath taking. [Full Review]
na IMDb-byvotes
80
T10
na Fran
70
T6
na KristianV
75
T6
na filmcricket
79
T10
na littlepanda
95
T7
na schnofel
75
T9
na Joe Bonham
65
T2
na Coheed
80
T9
na roland3791
74
T8
na noi
90
T10
na Suldrup
80
T9
na talila21
84
T4
na Bagger
75
T7
na graveyardtan
95
T10
Astonishing. Raw and vital journalism that matters.
na lostinlodos
30
T1
Very one-sided film about the former country known as burma and the transition to the current country Myanmar. While it is accepted that the current Myanmar ruling government is harsh, Burma wasn't much better. There is a lot of focus on Buddhists however most of Myanmar's Buddhist population do not practice actual Buddhism; rather a twisted theocratical version of deist worship, like Tibet. The replacing religious enslavement with militant repression is not truly documented here.
na krf7
95
T10
Required viewing.
na okyanusta
99
T10
na Actionberg
80
T8
na Frejs
70
T4
na avgcrtckr
80
T10
na Henrik
80
T8
na Positive Jon
85
T7
na comanchex
72
T5
na mitchelly
88
T9
na SeanBerndorff
80
T8
na Achk
7
T8
na Void
2
T6
na eumaios
83
T8
na Barthalen
89
T10
Will enrage you while at the same time breaking your heart. Everyone involved in filming and joining the protests themselves is so incredibly brave that it makes me feel ashamed of being such a lazy pussy, living in comfort and without any true fear.
na balseiros
75
T7
na dr. radical
76
T10
na teepo
80
T7
na Chr. Bach
70
T6
na lidi
83
T7
na sengir
80
T7
na Meta Critic
82
T10
na CoinQuatro
57
T5
na Ross
89
T9
Disturbing. Østergaard handles the intense material to perfection with suddlety and a plain score.
na Kavu
80
T8
A hard movie to rate. The footage is quite poorly put together but the message is very important and everyone should see this.
na Piglet
85
T10
Everyone should see this!
na davidysteph
38
T6
na jeff_v
69
T6
na Ludvig
75
T8
na AndreasThau
85
T9
Been a while since PSI was this correct (86), but it's well deserved. Also, it's been a while since I saw a doc that was SO well organised (opposite, say, AFR). The clear-cut choices work ever so well: as a viewer you're so well engaged with everyone, from the stranger in the street to the main characters that you never meet. Impressive that you feel so involved, so quickly. And then, most importantly, this is indeed a story that needs to be told. It's potent and - beyond imagination - shocking.
na filmaffinity
73
T9
na I.L.
78
T8
na Magb
90
T9
na ARUCARD
90
T9
na Empire
5
T10
na TheAlliance
87
T10
na MartinTeller
90
T10
It's a nightmarish situation, and stories of true heroism are intertwined with stories of utter horror and outrage. Director Anders Ostergaard wisely takes an extremely "hands off" approach, letting the reporter "Joshua" speak for himself with his footage and narration. He does add a score, but it's very subdued and appropriate. This is a powerful and memorable film about people's ability to rise up and speak out, and an oppressive government's ability to crush them.
na Toke Za
70
T7
na Adam Voigt
80
T9
na PeaceAnarchy
83
T7
Suffers a bit from the lack of any truly memorable images and underdeveloped context, but the content is important enough and the film easy enough to watch that it has to be recommended.
na NRM02
66
T8
na dharmabum
90
T9
na KasperL
55
T5
The demonstrations became repetitive. Couldn't get into it and, as always, what I rate is my experience, not importance, skill or anything else.
na DaeSanye
8
T10
na RealMacgyver
90
T9
Powerful stuff. the big question is, why the hell hasn't the rest of the worlds countries sorted it?
na Nordvig
75
T7
na Tjekhov
60
T6
na tocko
86
T9
Average Tier 7.92 from 86 Rankings rss