like cinema paradiso, it's pretty much the definition of "academy award for best foreign film" but it's commendable enough as a manipulative (let's not kid ourselves) melodrama and doesn't show signs of mikhalkov's declining grasp of logic and reality (burnt by the sun 2)

#771

The combination of joyous pandemonium with political commentary (and a touch of magic realism) is very Kusturica, but toned down. The sense of joy gradually drains out of the film as Stalinist oppression looms heavier and heavier over the lives of this happy family. The politics and allegories are a little simplistic and Mikhalkov gives himself too plum a role: Colonel Kotov is just too likeable NOT to sympathize with. But overall I thought it was a good film, particularly during the first half.

# 842

Fascinating tale of Russian history. A little slow for the most part.

885