Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Top 5 Director Averages
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Carnage (2011)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Tells the story of two sets of parents who decide to have a cordial meeting after their sons are involved in a schoolyard brawl. (imdb)
Poster submitted by Cuculiza
AKA: God of Carnage
Genres: Comedy, Drama
Directed By: Roman Polanski
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na bluesman
65
T4
na PepeCamello
60
T5
na MSoprano
78
T8
na Derekstar
50
T3
DON'T WORRY GUYS, THE HAMSTER IS OKAY!!!
na AshenLight
90
T9
na IMDBpredict
74
T8
na Peter_Pain
79
T9
na cncnmovies
71
T6
na JimmyLeresky
65
T4
na domv
72
T7
na filmguy
45
T4
na corelist
79
T7
na lunarstyle
84
T8
na Silver
6
T6
na Ralegend
40
T3
na cranky
68
T6
na dairylee
77
T6
na x@nder
72
T8
na orkunersin
70
T6
na muutanet
80
T9
An interesting actor leading project. All clears good, though I was pleased to see Christopher Waltz in a different kind of role.
na IrishCassidy
67
T6
na lippecesar
83
T8
na MrsEmmaPeel
65
T2
na nickv
68
T6
na Replicant
2
T6
The transition to film from stage wasn't going to be seamless, but it went better than I expected. PS: the movie on Art is going to suck.
na Whiggles
8
T8
na Kusanagi
75
T5
Just about as interesting as it is annoying, the dialog and performances are great, but the whole thing grates on the nerves. Its not hard to watch this, even if it might cause a bit of a headache.
na noelus
80
T8
na whitelighter
70
T10
na Sweeper770
77
T4
na daniel
85
T10
na kastenm
61
T2
na nicson
75
T9
na damil
60
T5
The actors were all fantastic and were a lot of fun to watch. I enjoyed it, for the most part. I think it got a little silly and over the top in the second half, but it was still entertaining. The ending was pretty lacking too. It was far from perfectly executed, but it was a short, amusing film with a few nice little insights into married couples.
na lazysounds
91
T10
na Grouchy
82
T5
na NoSex
75
T6
na Jerky
55
T7
na Nelourir
80
T9
na wpp
80
T9
na cgdsn
90
T7
na namazu
80
T7
na arirang
87
T7
na VN1X
80
T6
na Darko
76
T8
Good movie
na FallenAnzel
89
T9
na calendula
95
T10
na KeanuGrieves
93
T9
Razor-sharp and insightful, even if it's a little on the brief/slight side.
na Jehan
85
T8
na noi
100
T10
na Mirdad
95
T8
na catfacer
78
T7
na Ezp
70
T5
na creck
75
T7
na Cinemafan91
92
T10
na daystron7
61
T7
na murtyrock
70
T6
na CHR1S
84
T10
High paced, very suspenseful and dynamic comedy. Hilarious.
na TalkShowH
70
T7
na hristos
70
T7
na fcherchi
8
T9
na zombieman
72
T6
na fabioleal
60
T4
na Ercan
6
T6
na DMCrimson
75
T4
na almanccc
65
T4
na Void
3
T8
na fahd
70
T3
na JeRxclusive
63
T2
na darthfrede
70
T6
na ColonelTigh
94
T8
na sellos
74
T7
na nandorizzi
85
T9
na itsirc
70
T8
na mchen
8
T7
na diabrura
80
T6
na AbortedHugs
46
T4
na mindzi
40
T2
na mawy
95
T2
na fartblaster
54
T3
pallid and unconvincing, and fizzles out at the end
na rock007
85
T7
na sid
70
T6
na zsoao
62
T8
na Daniboy
73
T9
na Roger_Ebert
6
T6
na SirRobbie
80
T8
A great little comedy with fantastic performances and good directing by Polański.
na Dylanc
72
T4
na OzGrenouille
89
T8
na Veterini
81
T8
na aaronwhat
80
T6
na FilmStar**
94
T8
na vwgregov
85
T10
na Octave
34
T2
na turgay
73
T6
na meandre
90
T9
na calinki
65
T3
na tranquillity
77
T5
na Onxapu
70
T8
na Lemmiwinks
85
T8
na nauru
65
T6
Well acted, with a couple of funny parts. Worth watching. I wish I'd seen this film when I was a kid, as it shows just how stupid grown-ups can be over something as trivial as a school yard fight.
na bharath
75
T8
A really good movie with very good dialogues and acting. The entire casts acting is really good and the movie is funny and charming in its own way. The movie portrays a true picture comedy of manners or the lack off in todays upper middle class. A must watch entertainer.
na captainjazz
60
T5
na bogdanstefan
65
T1
na Arianata
57
T2
na fzycow
90
T8
na mohan
85
T4
An achievement in direction and writing. I was held captive - with just 4 characters, and a single room. Good acting too. Enjoyed it very much.
na bolivar
73
T8
great comedy without much pretension. bet the actors had a ball filming this. though the dialogue is still really good, itd be interesting to see what some other director (most obviously: woody allen) would have done.
na Manfy
79
T8
na sagethekun
9
T9
na s1killer
8
T8
na DBibby
50
T2
na Aron Ericson
65
T6
na kroolu
51
T1
na b4con
80
T6
na arsonist
50
T2
na Langelund
60
T5
Decent, but not as sharp nor as funny as it pretends to be, and though well-acted especially Winslet and Foster seems to have no clue who their characters are. It's hard not to wonder, what an Ingmar Bergman or a Woody Allen could have made of this.
na Kavu
80
T8
Nice and compact dramedy driven by strong acting and directing. Too bad there's no ending.
na Halfang
90
T8
na babaracus
85
T8
na chemical404
66
T8
John C. Reilly seems to be in everything lately. Who still finds his always the same character interesting? Great cast, otherwise. Movies based on a play often lack cinematic qualities, but Polanski is a veteran who could do anything right. Carnage doesn't leave much after it ends, but I always enjoy a good battle of wits.
na fad
50
T7
na Charlie
70
T6
na WalkenRoll
73
T6
na JohnSandwich
85
T10
It is a little slight, but damn, it was highly enjoyable. Fantastic cast who all perform really well here. Really like the poster for it too.
na supergloo
8
T7
na JanDoggen
75
T6
na glm
71
T5
70.750
na Junior1919
87
T8
na Moribunny
60
T6
It's evident from the start that Carnage is intelligently written. There's realism in the dialogue, with a few hilarious moments. Its quest to gradually step up the carnage then grows more and more labored, ultimately overwrought. It seems to be a rehash of "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?", superior to the source but still not great. Despite the best efforts of the script, its strongest points are the performances and cinematography.
na DrinkMilk
69
T7
na Bondo
71
T4
na djaunb
62
T4
na dumanx
5
T6
na Alan_Laidlaw
76
T6
na danwest6
68
T5
na Szumski
77
T6
na julibu
80
T4
na domys
60
T7
na mmagdalena
70
T6
na OziiX
72
T5
na fordianz
95
T5
na Kubusk
64
T5
na MadMan
90
T8
na Soulmate
77
T7
na Elliott?
86
T3
na BadSmile
70
T8
na LongHaul
75
T6
na Mazros
61
T4
na Gladstone
7
T9
na bprosser10
70
T3
na Kojiless
80
T9
I suppose I could mention the expert direction, the crackling script, the stellar performances by high-caliber actors...but many movies have those. What many movies DON'T have is Kate Winslet blowing cobbler all over Foujita.
na tinysausage
67
T3
A bit too stagey for my liking, and the characters bordered on caricatures.
na rakara
91
T7
na pwhpma
80
T7
na twisp
85
T8
na Kathasle
83
T9
na manikoala
72
T4
na tocko
83
T7
na Cowman
74
T8
na Flo2233
83
T6
na manonwire
85
T9
na Ram0n
72
T6
na ibnisabbah
81
T4
na Mohko
85
T10
na lillin
72
T4
na nrm5
40
T2
na DonMata
69
T3
na mtorgay
80
T7
na hasamba
73
T3
na T86g
91
T10
na sant2264
80
T6
na sahhosseini
75
na ndg
70
T8
a tour de force by the ensemble cast, accompanied by a very smart and subtle script, woven intricately by Reza. and a extra tier for the 'the gatekeepers of the world' remark, nothing hit such close to home recently.
na mynameisdoug
80
T6
na Mordas
86
T9
na ze_qualquer
90
T10
na Mansbridge
78
T8
Let Woody Allen direct this next time.
na 24truths
90
T9
na Jurispathic
4
T5
I have no problem with films that lay their themes on the table, as a subtle script is not always synonymous with an intelligent one. When it comes to chamber dramas like this, which are quite verbose and claustrophobic, it helps to keep things more lowkey and realistic. Carnage opens well, but it quickly devolves into something that feels very stagey. By the end, the characters are shouting the film's themes at each other, and thereafter terminating what credibility remained to the proceedings.
na M.Robitussin
85
T5
"four people in one setting are shitty, and they tell each other how shitty they are in detail, all while being unable to see how they, themselves, are shitty." - a movie based on a play.
na profire
83
T3
na jeantheoret
70
T5
na madderroot
68
T7
na slain
88
T9
na Nek
7
T6
na Hadleyreis
78
T7
na Nichololas
80
T7
na Voodoo
80
T5
na Emma_Zunz
80
T5
na kevinjoseph
73
T9
na Gordon Cole
96
T10
na DeazMoviez
70
T6
na cdub12
82
T6
na Forilas
63
T5
na Princezz
80
T8
na eumaios
63
T3
na zae
80
T8
Very funny and engaging, and for the most part exceptionally well written. The last part of the film felt a bit rushed, though.
na norval_jones
50
T1
na Msoada
73
T5
na invictus
65
T5
na Baby Fish
8
T7
na burflok
70
T8
na zdlindemann
74
T3
na marsco
74
T8
na k-pax
88
T8
na saguara
70
T4
na veldenje
80
T6
na numbersix_99
52
T2
na cloque
6
T4
na Al Chambers
57
T1
na KungFuDolly
3
T3
na apataca
76
T8
na raboom
72
T3
na PurpleCow17
79
T8
na xav2nice
69
T5
na mariand
60
T6
na steakel
70
T5
na yaisog
60
T5
na Petit-poid
83
T6
na csomay
90
T10
na kkl
65
T4
na tibuka
80
T9
na soxfandoug
70
T6
na clayj41
78
T8
na drstrangeluv
70
T6
na Siltem
75
T9
na marco_n65
77
T6
na KristianGSA
62
T4
na saeed.hosein
89
T8
na Elisheva
88
T7
na ehsan_amid
89
T5
na brosiv
75
T7
na stoker
50
T4
na Diogoweb
78
T6
na luminais
70
T4
na bulentolcay
86
T8
na gtsnuggler
3
T6
na Invi
78
T6
na Cuculiza
70
T6
na ams_t
78
T7
na vencha
90
T9
na tsebben
55
T5
na koteo
45
T1
na bitap
55
T3
na mightysparks
60
T6
na KINGOFLIMBS
82
T5
na ahherdemc
78
T6
na bertonia
90
T9
na AviAwareness
64
T4
na pitkju2
75
T7
Civilized conversation turns into primitive fury between two couples trying to come in terms with a conflict between their sons. Polanski's film is splendidly acted and ridiculously funny in its revealing depiction of socially correct behavior. Still, thematically, it isn't anything utterly special.
Displaying 1 to 250 of 500 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Tier 6.42 from 500 Rankings rss