Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Top 5 Director Averages
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Red Cliff II (2009)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: In the early third century, the land of Wu is invaded by the warlord Cao Cao and his million soldiers. The ruler of Wu, Sun Quan, calls on the rival warlord Liu Bei for help, but their two armies are still badly outnumbered. However, the Wu strategist Zhou Yu sees that Cao Cao's army is unused to battling on the sea, which may just give them a chance if they can exploit this weakness properly. (imdb)
Poster submitted by Gauntlet
AKA: Chi bi xia: Jue zhan tian xia
AKA: Red Cliff: Part II
Genres: Drama, Action, War
Country: China
Directed By: John Woo
Written By: John Woo, Khan Chan
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na Adrien
3
T8
na nses
90
T9
na tanguero
76
T8
na noid
91
T7
na gsingal
81
T6
na hts13
85
T6
na Cheese
60
T6
na simplicio
70
T5
(continued from Part I) The listless pace means character identifiers get a little cloying through overexposure; Kaneshiro's smug weatherman is a little too flawless, all the romance is about as lifelike as the closing double rainbow, and Zhao's princess goes from compellingly viperous to goofy once she crosses the river. But through the excess we somehow arrive at a mythical tone and, more importantly, some of the most beautiful, glittering sprays of hyperchromatic blood ever committed to film.
na medium123
76
T7
na dustin
20
T2
na nateb
90
T10
na FrankHowley
90
T10
As a huge fan of the Dynasty Warriors game, I absolutely loved this. It totally validates the experience of those games, and as a result John Woo has unknowingly made the best video game movie ever. The cinematography, art direction, and action sequences are all fantastic. Even at 5 hours, it moved along quickly and was exciting all throughout. It's a great movie.
na Bigfox
73
T7
na DelToro
88
T10
na DriveShaft
85
T8
na benifex
72
T6
na trailblazers
8
T8
na Deskyet
82
T6
Zelo zabaven, domiselen film. %u0160koda za tipi%u010Dne kitajske nadrealisti%u010Dne fight sekvence. Tudi zelo dobri dialogi.
na nylira
58
T4
na tzb
89
T9
na WoozyB
75
T5
Less bombastic in the second half, the showdown at the cliffs kind of loses its momentum, and isn't nearly as interesting as say, watching a dude birth a horse. Oh, and watching Chinese kickball is p entertaining.
na Borgnine
7
T6
na Sadeceali
62
T4
na fi_chince
74
T6
na tummidge
80
T6
na rhinderman
89
T9
na Fran
60
T4
na Seftref
45
T3
na otekiadam
85
T8
na caocao
78
T10
na jihaus
95
T10
na jimmyjazz
77
T8
na AAAutin
41
T4
na unusuall
90
T10
na areels
65
T5
na Rozmarin
60
T3
na 14x
95
T10
na SirEvo
90
T9
na Chona
96
T10
na Vergere
81
T7
na podoqob
85
T9
na Discard
70
T5
na djomla
65
T6
na marjoline
90
T8
na mindheart
80
T9
na hoolie
80
T6
na salty dog
80
T8
na strangelime
80
T5
na AsherFord
6
T2
na BaardPiraat
79
T6
na jsopanen
60
T9
na kodl
40
T2
na RainDog
80
T5
na Peter_Pain
73
T7
na oscargoesto
85
T9
na rob79au
82
T9
na Asgarth
77
T8
na Sharyna
99
T10
na Xzlu
65
T7
na falsebinary
55
T2
na marco_n65
79
T8
na Magus2914
100
T10
na pinematr
70
T6
na LennyNero
50
T4
na nrm4
53
T4
na mammadcarlos
90
T10
na logueb
70
T4
na miiiiiles
73
T5
na Veterini
84
T9
na cr00mz
8
T10
na Mattam
67
T8
na Amember
11
T10
na tradingair
8
T9
na zeybek187
95
T9
na deadbill
100
T10
na Cook3777
80
T8
na PaRaNoYa7
84
T10
na ten
78
T7
na peekingpanda
70
T9
na DeRZuLyA
7
T6
na rockway
55
T5
na glm
81
T7
81.000
na nauru
70
T8
Reviewing both parts as one film. Very high production value and really nice emphasis on tactics. The plot is predictable by the tactics on the battlefield are not. Weak, hammy dialog and some overlong scenes drag the run time to a total way longer than it should have been, but the battles are so well done that it doesn't really matter that much. Far better than most Asian war movies, very glad they didn't give anyone the unexplained ability to fly.
na jdalt1234
60
T6
na winds
6
T8
na DX101
92
T10
na mostafah
84
T9
na avgcrtckr
70
T8
na jhsoby
80
T8
na KaioShin
80
T8
na akodobill
85
T9
na Maandysheera
95
T10
na Bacchanalian
80
T8
na Matthew
60
T6
na IMDb-byvotes
75
T7
na lostinlodos
99
T10
na Iwantham
78
T7
na oranbebas
20
T1
na Crazy Jack
78
T7
na Radres
75
T7
John Woo as a director for this movie was not an advantage and unfortunately a handicap. Both movies suffered from bad editing to a point where some cuts were just confusing. Watching the same scene in slow motion several times was annoying. Story-wise it was interesting with good characters but John Woo was not the right man to direct this epic which was unexpected because of the action nature of the genre and the hard boiled approach from John Woo seemed like a good mix.
na Tavington
91
T10
na nuotio
55
T5
na lethe
80
T8
na Possebon
83
T8
na Leila
80
T5
na Sunsplitter
53
T7
na Ours
90
T8
na ShogunRua
74
T9
About 10 good points and 6 bad ones. Certain battle sequences and exchanges are as good as any I've seen. The lush backgrounds, rolling rivers and fields are amazing. The opening is fast-paced and brilliant, and most of the last hour,up until the ending, is superb. Unfortunately, there are times where the film feels cliche and irritating,like the scenes between the Viceroy and his wife. The ending is one of the most bizarre things I have seen,throwing logic and earlier continuity out the window.
na Danny74
96
T10
na bobyang
70
T6
na aquasheep
100
T9
na kurek
35
T3
na unclejoe
80
T7
na Spunkie
55
T5
na lemuria
85
T9
na Shareefruck
62
T6
na Seachusters
85
T9
na dodosarac
85
T9
na gdib
75
T6
na zapotka
65
T5
na electriccafe
65
T5
na Scarface
80
T9
na filmaffinity
69
T7
na Dobermann
78
T10
na bluberi
50
T3
na styleito
80
T10
na kuzukardes
85
T7
na imdb
73
T8
na flowing
48
T2
na ManInBlack
8
T10
na Stim
72
T8
I haven't seen the edited Western version but both of the original movies are fantastic. The set design is spot on, the characters look great and an epic plot is conveyed within a short period of time. Some of the CGI is poor but it's still remarkable to watch. Zhuge Liang is cunning, Cao Cao is a great villain, and the Wu characters are certainly interesting. The battles speak for themselves. If I hadn't known much about Romance Of The Three Kingdoms then I'm not sure if I'd enjoy it as much.
na Grandmaster
61
T5
na TidusFFX
95
T10
I rate both parts as one, because it's really just one movie cut in two. This is one of the best war movies ever. The beginning is not exactly gripping and I felt disappointed, but this feeling didn't last long as the movie picked up and offered a brilliant experience. Extremely high production values and sooooo beautiful soundtrack make this one shine. And if you're a fan of the Three Kingdoms era, this is a must.
na td888
76
T7
na derphil
80
T7
na barbaros
84
T1
na Wereboar
87
T6
na jacobb1313
81
T8
Better battle sequences, but you absolutely HAVE to see the first film to understand/care about this one; it's really one film in two parts, not a first and a sequel. It is still really good, and is truly AWE inspiring in scope. The true meaning of E.P.I.C., for better or for worse.
na Mawazh
80
T7
na jacko
60
T6
na Kilathaar
80
T8
na OMGFridge
80
T8
Reviewing both parts as one movie. High production values pay off as this war epic looks fantastic. Choreographed fight/battle scenes were well done and not totally unbelievable like they are in a lot of other Asian films. Never dull and always entertaining. John Woo has made a return to form. Tortoise formation kicks ass.
na kennardjon
80
T8
na ntrik
86
T7
na cynick
55
T3
na ookamie
63
T8
na Znachor
8
T8
na jordanlige
100
T6
na corley
75
T8
na karchen
75
T6
na dmk
54
T2
na PigontheWing
8
T8
na Zoxxxon
95
T9
na mike.snyder
90
T9
na qtip
85
T9
na O_o
75
T6
na zombieman
79
T8
na hashus
63
T4
na daniel
65
T8
na micmac•
64
T5
na fortsigma
76
T8
na Inframan
83
T4
na LmanofMGS3
89
T9
na roland3791
75
T8
na Yasha
70
T4
na kbyeo87
72
T6
na lyyam2
75
T7
na ednorog
43
T1
na shtc10
95
T9
na Gilgamesh
94
T10
na osmanliemre
71
T6
na jpb33
57
T8
na Cinema_Asia
70
T6
na Jazzaloha
62
T4
na vixroar
90
T10
na graag
65
T7
na schnofel
30
T2
na DaeSanye
7
T8
na tilzonja
82
T9
na Architeutis
75
T9
na katsuben
3
T4
na aatx1228
67
T5
na Kaiserkomori
85
T10
na Winged
4
T7
na redmdb
87
T5
na the_wizard
80
T7
na dst7175
92
T10
na burflok
69
T8
na Siltem
41
T3
Average Tier 7.03 from 189 Rankings rss