It is not perfect, but it is a good comedy, without great pretensions, just for fun.

Movie makes me swoon for Ryan Reynolds, and I'm as straight as they come. Also Isla Fisher is a babe, and her acting in this cements her place in my mind as a fairly talented actress.

I presume that the flaws with overwhelm the whole for many, but I really loved this. Rachel Weisz, Isla Fisher and Elizabeth Banks are all unbelievably beautiful and it works unexpectedly and unbelievably emotionally. Great movie.

While it still holds many of the stereotypes that most romantic comedies share, it also maintained an intricate plot that left you wondering until the end.

Possibly the best romance of all time. One of the few romances with a twist. And for the girls, this is probably the romance you would be most likely to get your boyfriend to see/enjoy.

I'm not the biggest fan of romantic comedies but feel this is a pretty solid movie. Ryan Reynolds, the male lead, carries the story pretty well with the ensemble cast of women. And for an ensemble, each girl gets an involved enough story to flesh out their own interesting characters. Good characters and relationships, and the ensemble storyline contribute to a fresher plot than what you get with formulaic 1-on-1 romances. A complete movie for a romance.

A very smart love story that uses an intuitive story telling platform to turn what could have become a cliche love tale into a surprisingly deep film about the importance of analyzing one's past in order to decide how to best approach one's future.

Pretty well done rom/com that was honestly surprising, it looked so shitty. It suffers from the trademarked sappiness of the genre but I can't help but like Ryan Reynolds - I don't know why. Also, Abigail Breslin, please go away.

I'm beginning to think that avoiding any movie with Ryan Reynolds in it might be a good idea.

Witty, funny, and cynically romantic, it's hard not to find yourself getting swept up in the story. The frame narrative initially seems a little forced, but it's not difficult to get used to it, and the whole thing soon flows along without seeming the least bit gimmicky. Incredible performances from all concerned, both comedic and dramatic, and a fascinating plot that (while it might not keep you entirely guessing) will certainly entertain.

It's a nice enough story and all but an unfortunately worthless movie.

as high as it gets on the boring scale, but some beautiful women brought it some points and still 25 points are for the nirvana soundtrack

Ryan Reynolds has a massive head.

Cute love story with a twist. Great cast and an interesting background.