Watch
Elephant
Elephant
1989
TV Special
39m
A depiction of a series of violent killings in Northern Ireland with no clue as to exactly who is responsible. (imdb)
Directed by:
Written by:
Your probable score
?
Elephant
1989
TV Special
39m
Your probable score
Avg Percentile 61.17% from 207 total ratings
Ratings & Reviews
(206)
Compact view
Compact view
Show
Sort
Rated 06 Nov 2007
85
95th
One of the best pieces of decidedly conceptual cinema I've seen. Apparently this is just random people shooting random people dead for no apparent reason. But the fact that all of them (killers AND victims) are men, and the setting (Northern Ireland) are ample evidence of what the general background is. The technique - tracking shot, then static handheld shot - is brilliant. I just really recommend watching this - shouldn't analyze it although I'm tempted to. Just watch it and be affected.
Rated 06 Nov 2007
Rated 29 Sep 2013
1
4th
I watch this and I'm unaffected by its repetition. You get the picture after the 3rd murder. After the 4th or 5th killing I started laughing at how seriously it takes itself. After the 10th killing I got painfully bored. After the 15th or 16th killing I was angry at how it says very little and makes you feel nothing at all. It's like watching a man-child play murder with his dolls - amusing at first but mostly inane. I'm suspicious of people who are "moved" by this.
Rated 29 Sep 2013
Rated 24 Oct 2011
60
15th
Harrowing and cold, this is an obvious concept for a film, but one pulled off with an effective amount of cynicism and bleakness. However, it does stray too far into objective representation, and becomes repetitive and undermines the further killings through desensitisation. The other 'Elephant' says more about violence and murder.
Rated 24 Oct 2011
Rated 09 Nov 2021
60
62nd
If the title suggests that what's missing is understanding of the socioeconomic context, nevertheless the combination of: 1) tracking shot following perpetrator; 2) Bressonian focus on hand-firing-gun; 3) slain victim, suggests that the invention and availability of firearms itself opens the possibility for their deliberate and methodical use, forcefully pursued, as a "rationalised" means independent of any particular end. Look for the Commodore, Australia's first world-class car (says the ad).
Rated 09 Nov 2021
Rated 30 Aug 2011
80
81st
It's ridiculus and stupid - that's why it's brilliant.
Rated 30 Aug 2011
Rated 15 May 2013
8
78th
Confrontational and haunting, my kind of cinema.
Rated 15 May 2013
Rated 28 Sep 2010
79
57th
I get that the lack of context is intentional, a way to emphasize the film's point about how senseless acts of violence loom over mundane daily lives. Even so it takes away from the impact, and especially when the whole thing lasts 40 minutes a little more commentary would be a good thing.
Rated 28 Sep 2010
Rated 04 Apr 2009
80
67th
It's powerful. Without knowing a bit about the Troubles and the like, it seems like random acts of violence, but it gives us an unbiased glimpse at the problems, specifically the violence. It feels like a documentary, which helps but I don't know if you'd want to watch it more than once.
Rated 04 Apr 2009
Rated 30 Oct 2013
65
35th
18 killings, shown back to back for 40 minutes in an incredibly stark manner. For most of the run-time the effect is startling with a palpable sense of dread to the whole thing and a gut response that the killings have to stop (and with no context given to the killings they are allowed no sense of justification - they are merciless and utterly pointless). By the end I found my interest waining considerably due to the highly repetitive nature of it all, which for all I know could be the point.
Rated 30 Oct 2013
Rated 20 Jan 2014
4
91st
Chilling, engrossing, billiant.
Rated 20 Jan 2014
Rated 19 Feb 2024
75
76th
My immediate thought was, wow, might this be the most misanthropic movie I've seen? But discovering the context was illuminating. I can only imagine the feeling of turning on the television in '89 and this is on, and it's that situation which I believe lends this film it's shocking, raw power.
Rated 19 Feb 2024
Rated 05 Oct 2012
77
54th
The best 40 minutes of senseless and meaningless killings, but it takes more than that to make a strong statement. I still prefer Van Sant's version.
Rated 05 Oct 2012
Rated 18 Feb 2016
60
62nd
A series of executions set in and around my home city of Belfast.
I have a strong suspicion that these are actually re-enactments of murders that actually took place here.
Rated 18 Feb 2016
Rated 23 Aug 2012
44
43rd
I can see how some enjoy it, but if I'm watching a short, I want it to be a little less plodding. Just my preference
Rated 23 Aug 2012
Rated 11 Jul 2023
75
57th
This is a divisive piece, but I think it's an interesting use of the medium to make its point. It's not necessarily something I would recommend to anyone without knowing a ton about them, but I thought the nearly silent movie concept and complete lack of context did a lot to show what living in these times (not far gone) must have been like as far as paranoia and confusion. Interesting, though some will despise it.
Rated 11 Jul 2023
Cast & Info
Directed by:
Written by:
Collections
(11)
Compact view
Show
Sort
Moderated by Vandelay1
Last updated on with I Live in the Woods
Moderated by iconogassed
Last updated on with Citizen Kane
Moderated by PerryStroika
Last updated on with Boiling Point
Last updated on with Dangerous Secrets
Moderated by iceblox
Last updated on with Once Upon a Time in Northern Ireland
Moderated by saudade
Last updated on with A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night
Moderated by iconogassed
Last updated on with The Death of Stalin
Moderated by Ag0stoMesmer
Last updated on with La Zone
Moderated by babuba
Last updated on with La Promesse
Showing 1 - 11 of 11 results
Similar Titles
Loading ...
Statistics
Loading ...
Trailer
Loading ...
PSI
?