Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum New Movie Pic Game
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Fat Girl (2001)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: A Ma Soeur! is a provocative and shocking drama about sibling rivalry, family discord and relationships. Elena is 15, beautiful and flirtatious. Her less confident sister, Anais, is 12, and constantly eats. On holiday, Elena meets a young Italian student who is determined to seduce her. Anais is forced to watch in silence, conspiring with the lovers, but harbouring jealousy and similar desires. Their actions, however, have unforeseen tragic consequences for the whole family. (imdb)
Poster submitted by hristos
Genre: Drama
Country: France, Italy
Directed By: Catherine Breillat
Written By: Catherine Breillat
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Trailer
Invalid Trailer
If you want, give us a new one!
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na frg
68
T5
na guppy
70
T7
na nuked
8
T9
na taskn
45
T5
na JooJoo
7
T7
fuck
na shrodes
80
T5
na anime salve
87
T6
na IMDb-byvotes
64
T4
na marrie86
45
T7
na ProtectMeYou
3
T3
na Deadmarsh
50
T2
na Water
0
T5
na Voice Within
77
T4
na wearhats
91
T10
na shaltmira
91
T7
na e_p_o
80
T6
I ... honestly think I liked this, and usually I find Breillat dull and obvious. Here we have a slow-moving, subtle portrait of adolescent sexual discovery, and frustration. The long sexual negotiation in bed between the older sister and her adult boyfriend is magnificently handled. Cruel, believable and hypnotic to watch. Could have done with less shots of highway traffic. Oh, and THAT ENDING ... it sealed the deal for me, but it really does divide people. See for yourself.
na Ani
85
T9
na jesstoombs
85
T4
na MrE2Me
80
T7
na nanasf
80
T6
na aignatiou
80
T6
na screentime
64
T5
na caguta
65
T3
na overseas
95
T9
na SlantMag
40
T10
"Catherine Breillat's vision is so deceptively tranquil that love becomes indistinguishable from rape." - Ed Gonzalez
na fink
80
T6
na johnfgillson
80
T8
na kalim
85
T3
na catfacer
85
T8
na bood
65
T4
na cbennett
65
T5
na dhildeb1
80
T8
na DMCrimson
70
T3
na orion_black
75
T7
na NedMeier
81
T6
na flowing
66
T5
na travelin_man
60
T3
na benito
75
T7
na Elekoise
49
T6
na AICHEG
89
T10
This was dope. My brain melted. After, I passed this off to every boring, stuck-up friend I have, and told them it was 'a beautiful french film about young love.'
na lyrradsemaj
82
T8
na differenxe
83
T6
na hetsdot
89
T9
na Crazy Jack
72
T6
na brtkrbzhnv
2
T1
na winds
4
T3
na micko
44
T4
na georgia sam
90
T10
na thatgreatwar
67
T5
na buffyactsing
65
T1
na lucashxc
85
T6
na joshuatree
74
T6
na ThiagoH
87
T6
na Fetsch
78
T9
na rottentomat
72
T6
na carlwarnick
100
T10
na MMAlpha
55
T4
na kangadoodoo
65
T7
na ExileinArden
92
T6
na metz
70
T9
na drone
22
T3
na buser333
60
T6
na piquet
70
T6
na KMcNeil
65
T7
Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus and Catherine Breillat is from Hell. Love the guy in the start, who spends 10 min. trying to convince the younger girl to have sex with him and ends up going at it anal. It reminded me of a High Fidelity quote: "Sometimes I got so bored of trying to touch her breast that I would try to touch her between her legs. It was like trying to borrow a dollar, getting turned down, and asking for 50 grand instead." Only here it worked. French girls are sluts.
na toro913
79
T8
na Fleshballoon
92
T10
na kwazar
72
T7
na margot
90
T7
na NoSex
95
T10
na lostintravis
80
T5
na Jurispathic
7
T9
A deeply unsettling film that's unflinching in its honest depiction of budding sexuality. Breillat presents painful and cynical truths about how the need to be wanted, to be selected can distance us from a place of security and affection while simultaneously drawing us into a predatory world of exploitation and terror. It's a terrible world where love is synonymous with rape and rejection is a death sentence.
na edkrak
65
T6
At first I wasn't impressed at all, but then it punched me in the face with one of the greatest happy endings I've ever seen.
na pustota
75
T7
na NRM02
63
T7
na GodlessNoble
95
T10
na jbissell
40
T1
na Valenzetti
84
T7
na Bandy
82
T8
na Meta Critic
77
T9
na fakeplastik
91
T8
na paperilunta
55
T9
na rant1229
90
T10
na gemtea
55
T1
na Lord Moe
85
T5
Sometimes shocking yet always intriguing, "Fat Girl" gives us a, perhaps exaggerated. look at how the desire to be loved can be so strong in some people. Often graphic and totally unafraid.
na Sweet Leaf
65
T4
na Scottathon
79
T7
na PeaceAnarchy
85
T8
Very interesting character piece that uses long lingering scenes to explore burgeoning sexuality and related pressures. How I feel about what it's actually saying is another matter, especially with the ending that seems to come out of nowhere. Some parts are a culmination of what precedes it, but others seem to simply be there to shock.
na authorial
65
T2
na Enygma
65
T2
na adrian
65
T6
na AshenLight
68
T2
na lippecesar
78
T7
na theguest
51
T4
na jaque_line
100
T9
na Magmadiver
63
T3
na pzingg
88
T6
na themadelf66
78
T7
na diabrura
55
T2
na AceySaid10%
85
T9
craaaazy movie
na acephale
65
T7
na CMQuinn
40
T2
na dsjoerdsma
75
T8
na NRM03
79
T9
na Judo Koala
75
T7
na avgcrtckr
59
T5
na henriquemsb
72
T6
na itsirc
63
T6
na depers
63
T4
na Pizzi
70
T4
na jormungand
89
T10
na Darbicus
60
T5
na kdawg
10
T6
na NatassaFl
50
T3
na dwight
70
T1
na tsaponi
65
T5
na Dogubomb
80
T10
na Derrick X
75
T8
needs a better ending
na Henrik
70
T6
na Hysteria
70
T7
na Coredor
84
T9
na woofat
73
T5
na akjn
65
T4
na mightysparks
70
T8
na amaz
100
T6
na Replicant
1
T2
Like, seriously, whatever
na sharp_e-
50
T4
na Seftref
65
T6
na vheujge
60
T6
na deckard0
89
T6
na Warren
84
T7
na The Goat
71
T6
na Baby Fish
9
T9
na FallFoliage
70
T8
na NRM01
64
T7
na LLawliet
70
T3
na zevel6
60
T6
na danielldb
65
T5
na endersakinci
100
T6
na anhonestmess
90
T10
na trevitron
65
T5
na nesriny
73
T2
na Rumplesink
80
T8
na dpanov
45
T2
na dirtyzen
80
T9
na unclejoe
65
T1
na bestmilk
79
na dabinich
20
T1
na allisoncm
22
T1
na shush
74
T3
na hoolie
70
T4
na sidehacker
74
T7
na lonelypanda
50
T5
na RNG
73
T8
na cambelboy
72
T6
na oenginsu
35
T3
na Spunkie
65
T8
na daffodil907
74
T6
na welike
30
T7
na TSP250
52
T8
na cgcore
62
T5
na borges
5
T9
na LRibeiro
14
T1
na madlucas
85
T10
na LordofDance
60
T9
na bullet06
68
T5
na Chelman
85
T8
na tonioferah
88
T9
na TJ_Camber
77
T9
na goran
57
T5
na Nitku
60
T4
na SaiSaiSai
74
T6
na Tizzy
36
T2
na iceblox
71
T7
na wig
88
T8
na JakeAesthete
55
T5
na icromaholicx
60
T3
na purity
3
T9
na electriccafe
80
T8
na burhenn
90
T7
na RPMcMurphy
35
T2
na jeesa
35
T2
na boxgod
66
T6
na IndyFilmFest
91
T8
na emtilt
75
T8
na dj001k
50
T5
na Filipe
90
T9
na zozan65
80
T8
na Stain
50
T4
OK OK it's frank and sexually provocative, but I just don't care
na donofthedead
94
T10
na mita
90
T9
na akathebob
65
T3
na waitsup
55
T3
na raksi
22
T1
na mathias
75
T8
na Bemis
70
T4
na filmlover
81
T9
na engin
60
T5
na Dally
30
T1
na spookyjon
82
T7
na CaptainSteve
50
T4
na Raiders
60
T4
na sixpence
83
T4
na moeta2
80
T4
na laika
62
T4
na hayami
75
T6
na jinxyte
95
T10
na android
60
T4
na megladon8
80
T8
A sad and ultiamtely shocking film. Wonderfully acted and directed, but not for the squeamish or people uncomfortable with sex and the human body.
na hremanruss
95
T9
na schnofel
68
T7
na Antoine
59
T2
na Spinal
96
T10
na dissent
60
T6
na jenniferever
85
T8
na luridedith
90
T9
na efrasiyab
55
T3
na CHOICECOD
38
T1
na pompousass
40
T8
The sexual initiation of two adolescent sisters, one kittenish, the other bearish ("No one would think we're sisters"), on a holiday. Very candid and detailed, with extended negotiations required of an older seducer. (Breillat doesn't strive to outdo her hardcore Romance, however; and the rudeness of the title was imposed for export: the original French translates as To My Sister.) Very steady-handed up until the off-key finish. Careful attention to color; excellent shots of freeway traffic.
na givethanks
73
T8
na mandarkzilla
70
T6
na nath
73
T5
na salty dog
72
T6
na Danilolopes
30
T1
na Veterini
78
T7
na gryffindyke
90
T9
na laertes
71
T8
na empiremag
2
T2
"The adolescent misery is wrily captured and the depiction of juvenile sex as a battle between lust and hesitant longing is shrewd and sad. But that ending..."
na snb
45
T3
na lizzle
90
T8
na alsolikelife
2
T6
na chrisssslim
92
T9
na aethling
78
T10
na sellis
79
T7
na hristos
70
T7
na bmmello
80
T7
na Octave
78
T9
na atreides
84
T5
na popolinka
53
T5
na Cherish
55
T3
na cloak
73
T8
na DougReese
100
T10
na stagemadness
80
T7
na filmcricket
64
T7
na punks
75
T7
na postmodifier
80
T7
na AFlickering
75
T9
god i hate women
na derpington
65
T5
na synthono
0
T1
na filmgirl79
90
T10
na ablaze
67
T4
Displaying 1 to 250 of 287 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Tier 5.92 from 287 Rankings rss