Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Jim Jarmusch's Dead Man...
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Fata Morgana (1971)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Footage shot in and around the Sahara Desert, accompanied only by a spoken creation myth and the songs of Leonard Cohen. (imdb)
Genre: Sci-fi
Country: West Germany
Directed By: Werner Herzog
Written By: Werner Herzog
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Buy
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na jodamico
74
T5
na Water
0
T5
na Evolution
72
T5
na olebole
6
T4
na m4th3u5
98
T10
na Walterpoa
65
T5
na caiman
70
T4
What is Herzog trying to say here? I really have no idea. I was left with a real sense of "what's the point?" But I did appreciate the beautiful scenery, as well as some of the utter weirdness. It's a flavor of weirdness I've seen only in Herzog movies. The boy with the fox, the guy talking about lizards, the goofy guy with the sea turtle, and of course the most peculiar musical duo I've ever witnessed. These things are purely Herzog, and they alone made watching this movie worthwhile.
na Seftref
60
T5
na IMDb-byvotes
70
T5
na maxmellman
80
T3
na Nroo
70
T5
na ponzan
97
T10
na graveyardtan
80
T7
The landscape is not an allegory. There is nothing beyond its beauty.
na O_o
88
T8
na Kunstable R.
80
T9
na mitchelly
80
T4
na clarkah
30
T1
na ze_qualquer
45
T5
na ?elkowo
99
T10
na LetsGoEatHuh
80
T10
na onetwothree
70
T9
na Gui
62
T6
na -BigEvil-
65
T4
A spectacle of images and music, but it's not quite enough to sustain feature length. I disliked the narration, and it seemed a little bit ambiguous and pointless. But damn is there some great footage.
na Doo
100
T10
na torontodog
65
T6
na cinema_hell
78
T6
na jgreenwood
30
T1
na djross
35
T2
Contains some remarkable imagery.
na JooJoo
6
T6
na pristinepain
90
T8
na vsls
80
T9
na wavymouth
19
T1
na dotCommunism
80
T6
na NightGoat72
20
T1
na bof
66
T6
Herzog turns a documentary about a trip to Cameroon into an exploration and deconstruction of the creation myth. Almost a science fiction movie about life on Earth, it drags a bit and tends towards the pathetic at one or two points, but then the final part (which is almost Meaning of Life-ishly satirical) ties it together very nicely. Herzog's starting to find his feet here.
na lippecesar
68
T5
na retsxlif
74
T7
na MrsEmmaPeel
77
T6
na avgcrtckr
59
T5
na thelastexit
1
T3
"Herzog fans drool over the challenge and come up with various personal impressions, but I think it's just an experiment that completely fell apart but was stitched together like a failed Frankenstein monster and released anyways."
na micmac•
77
T8
na dusticus
90
T7
na Hangarl
70
T7
na AJD612
75
T4
na Dreamfar
90
T8
na Magmadiver
95
T10
na ten
96
T10
na Lone Wolf
65
T5
na PubliusD
70
T3
Interesting to look at, but not great until it comes to the brothel band sequence.
na ericdupont
75
T6
na P. Lemgruber
82
T6
na Rumplesink
50
T3
na paperilunta
50
T9
na NRM01
77
T10
na NRM02
49
T4
na Bavafreak
75
T5
na Anomaly1
64
T4
Brilliant images and some great music, but the whole is less than the sum of its parts - it's boring and it drags for most of the run time. There are a few nice moments of Herzogian weirdness in here, though, so it's not a total waste.
na klanc11
100
T10
na SirRobbie
50
T2
na bernardobrum
83
T6
na katsuben
60
T6
na b4con
80
T6
na sdoles
8
T7
na zwyk
63
T4
na gurglebot20
90
T8
na pilotpirx
80
T8
na jeanlucgodot
75
T4
na mundy767
24
T2
na chesterfilms
85
T8
na Jos
60
T2
na kangadoodoo
60
T6
na Heer
75
T7
Part 1 is a bit dull but it gets better about halfway through. Would have been better if Herzog had narrated it himself.
na MatheusM
92
T7
na kyle.loomis
5
T6
na sidehacker
64
T5
na jewellrunner
87
T9
na JakeAesthete
48
T4
na nexus
70
T5
na Klauskaiser
95
T6
na losrasputin
74
T5
na flowing
51
T3
na JJJames
89
T9
na hekkon
75
T5
na welike
30
T7
na FitFortDanga
58
T2
There are some great images here, but they're few and far between. Most of it feels like leftover footage from better Herzog movies. The first part is the worst: all the Mayan creation myth bullshit read in Lotte Eisner's very grating voice and the endless pans of the same landscapes over and over again gets really fucking tedious. Parts 2 & 3 are a big improvement with more evocative narration, but still in need of a stricter hand at the editing machine.
na hereslucas
95
T9
na AFlickering
63
T8
Herzog makes time cease like no other film-maker, immersing the viewer in the eternal moment. The line between fact and fiction is blurred, and from that blur is extracted a visceral poetry, a soulful meditation on the relationship between living creatures and their natural environment, from creation to destruction. As the last, strange landscape fades away we awaken with a sense of having been outside ourselves; viewing our absurd world through naive, awe-struck eyes.
na pilgermann
59
T4
Very weird film shot around the same time as EVEN DWARFS STARTED SMALL. Lots of wonderful and mysterious moments. If you can make it past the opening scene with continuous footage of planes landing then you'll be okay, athough admit that I I haven't been able to watch this in its entirety in one sitting.
na weirdyoda
70
T3
A Bit boring, but still weird and cool
na jimmynmu
70
T6
Great photography and music (Cohen is incredible), although it lacks alot of what makes Herzog films so special.
na camilam02
87
T8
na chaw
75
T8
na vesupria
50
T9
na Carlospro
85
T9
na TedDedon
65
T4
Fata Morgana is undeniably dull and while it does have beautiful scenery and music, it takes more than that to keep the audience captivated. It's a film worth seeing to make your own mind up, but in particular, Fata Morgana is one of the lesser in Herzog's otherwise excellent catalog.
na Kerc
20
T6
na Huuliharppu
8
T8
na TroyAnderson
73
T7
na fabfunk
90
T9
Gorgeous hagiagraphy of a time that doesn't exist. Herzog the humanist.
na purity
2
T6
na Planeshifter
65
T4
na CHOICECOD
70
T3
na garbo
85
T8
na jef costello
45
T1
na chrisssslim
60
T3
na Johnny Case
65
T6
na imdb
70
T7
na Castroph
7
T8
na Le_Fou
100
na anime salve
87
T6
na mrsmuzi
0
T4
na winds
7
T10
na negative
3
T8
na PinkyRose
83
T5
na Diamorphoses
70
T6
The creation section was lame, but the other two parts were an improvement. The shots taken from a moving vehicle and the mirages were beautiful.
na NilbogSavant
90
T9
na snb
66
T6
na viniciusjn
90
T9
na digitalmonk
70
T4
na aurora
93
T10
na excowboy
70
T7
na CoinQuatro
63
T6
na coltrane
4
T5
na HobbsEnd
65
T6
na filmaffinity
70
T8
na joseywales
80
T9
Yes it's slow and captivating but it's like that to match the way of life seen through Herzog's lens. I could have done with less of the creation myth and more of Leonard Cohen.
na bananas
40
T3
na comanchex
86
T9
na Sebastian
34
T1
na RadioFreeLee
91
T9
na TJ Ximenez
90
T7
na velocipedist
80
T9
na schnofel
68
T7
Average Tier 6.03 from 133 Rankings rss