Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum New Movie Pic Game
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Harlan County, USA (1976)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: A filmed account of a bitterly violent miner strike.
Poster submitted by Svengali
Country: USA
Directed By: Barbara Kopple
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Trailer
Invalid Trailer
If you want, give us a new one!
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na murdemotion
89
T9
na CMQuinn
80
T8
na sixx
40
T4
Bunch of pissed off hillbilly's who I couldn't understand 3/4 of the time. Some cool shots though.
na jodamico
77
T7
na bood
80
T7
na beavarino
88
T7
na krf7
85
T8
na magnoliakid
100
T10
na alexw07
80
T7
na St. Gloede
76
T5
na DeusTetsuo
65
T4
na thewire
80
T8
na dotCommunism
80
T6
na norval_jones
90
T9
na doughbaron
80
T9
na deckard0
90
T8
na I.L.
73
T7
na j.minor
86
T8
na Valenzetti
87
T8
na clarkah
90
T10
na ehrenkm
90
T9
na Icarus
90
T9
An excellent documentary that takes the side of human beings over and against institutions like labor unions and the government. I love the way Kopple brings in the music of these people, showing how they carry on an oral tradition from decades of miners through song.
na DavidKahane
93
T9
na Derrick X
75
T8
na jeff_v
80
T9
na Bojangles
70
T8
na Cantstopdrew
96
T10
na gtown1479
80
T8
The fact that they seemed to have their cameras everywhere and little editing was done made this better, and more "real". This factor especially came into play during the standoffs and whenever they approached that guys truck. The whole movie was very informative in shedding some light on coal mining which I really have never paid attention to even though it probably affects my life more than i realize. They could have cut down on the crooning a little bit, just got annoying after awhile.
na IMDb-byvotes
84
T10
na RadioFreeLee
96
T10
na Kirschwasser
9
T9
na alecec24
90
T9
na NathanChinn
90
T9
na Gladstone
8
T10
na sdoles
8
T7
na anime salve
90
T10
na Dancon7
84
T9
na Ibn Salami
5
T2
dull and shamelessy biased. i missed the first half hour.
na NRM03
87
T10
na avgcrtckr
79
T10
na dedalive
100
T10
na sebby
90
T10
At turns shocking and infuriating. About as effective as a biased documentary can be, as it's pretty clear that the bias is justified.
na understamp
80
T9
na moviemanwill
80
T8
na filmcricket
83
T10
na Kojiless
82
T10
What I learned from this movie: coal dust does not cause disease. Wait...wha? Capitalism at its finest.
na nuked
6
T4
na toro913
75
T7
na Jake_R
95
T10
na capote12883
100
T7
na Coredor
87
T9
na TJinAustin
100
T10
na filmaffinity
77
T10
na dairylee
82
T8
na Meta Critic
80
T10
na lineuphere
90
T9
na dominoparker
100
T10
na trevitron
75
T7
na NRM01
59
T6
na Borgnine
6
T4
na anhonestmess
90
T10
na tankut
80
T6
na Risselada
85
T8
na woodke1235
80
T8
na Redundant1
74
T8
na sambafish
80
T8
na TheAlliance
81
T8
na corpsepose
92
T10
na Bandy
75
T6
na rant1229
80
T8
na Guernica
68
T8
na JacoIII
85
T8
Fantastic documentary. One-sided for sure but it shows that one side very, very well. The method of presentation, no narration, very few statistics shown onscreen, keeps the viewer in the moment and on the edge of their seat. When I first saw the guns I felt more scared than I ever had in any horror movie.
na Pingy
100
T10
na Sprinklins
91
T6
Fuck the bourgeoisie.
na Cerebrus
80
T8
na anonconmatt
40
T5
na LOTNorm
89
T9
na Mango
2
T1
na Theodora
76
T7
na kangadoodoo
70
T8
na RNG
53
T6
na dr. radical
86
T10
na goran
93
T10
na sgaber
75
T5
na chiphall72
69
T5
na coltrane
4
T5
na hellsditch
93
T10
I don't look like or speak like these people. I don't live in a town like theirs. But this is the America I'm proud to live in. Perhaps my favorite aspect of the movie was that it treated the strikers with respect. It didn't make them caricatures or "yokels". There was a kind of folksy empathy at work here that drew me in, and made me relate to these people. The, virtually unedited, standoff between the strikers and the union busters ("mediated" by the reluctant Sheriff) was incredible.
na bluesoul
93
T10
na doctor7
88
T9
Yes it's biased and sides with the miners but it's open and honest about it. Plus you'd need to be pretty retarded to not be sympathetic to entire families who have, for generations, been exploited. It's heart breaking to see these people fight an uphill battle so hard and for so long over something that is such an obvious moral outrage.
na Hailey
92
T9
I live in Kentucky, where this movie was filmed, very good documentry about the state.
na FitFortDanga
82
T8
A one-sided view to be sure, but really, how can you be AGAINST unionizing? The story is riveting and makes a good companion piece to Matewan. The film does get a bit confusing at the end, after the main strike ends and then there's apparently some additional strikes and some sort of disagreement with another organization. But that's just the last 10 minutes, the other 90 are very engrossing. I particularly enjoyed all those great union songs.
na Jarmann
80
T7
Heart-breaking and provocative.
na theyshoot07
57
T4
# 870
na Darbicus
90
T10
na erikdean
100
T10
na magpie
75
T5
na schnofel
94
T10
na winbran
95
T10
na Theyshootpic
17
T4
na evanfrrll
83
T7
na IndyFilmFest
95
T9
na moeta2
85
T6
na Warren
83
T6
na eveelun
80
T8
na dumbjaw
72
T8
na volver
75
T8
na welike
30
T7
na jcdracula
3
T9
na Merc
80
T8
na jstry
85
T8
na jbissell
85
T7
na cloak
66
T7
na winds
6
T8
na burnmp3s
82
T8
na negative
3
T8
na Crazy Jack
83
T9
na givethanks
65
T6
na high_valley
85
T9
na kyle.loomis
8
T9
na NoSex
100
T10
na JJJames
82
T7
na okyanusta
80
T6
na empire434
85
T9
na hekkon
80
T7
na graveyardtan
80
T7
na mattybgame
89
T10
na InaFerrer
78
T9
na misterpaul
93
T6
na milopalmer
87
T7
na hopalong
65
T6
na Gody85
70
T9
na Landstander
8
T9
na sengir
83
T9
na imdb
83
T10
na jesperjack
80
T7
na Sam Lowry
4
T9
na ancjr
87
T9
na PeaceAnarchy
81
T7
Really good documentary about the struggles of unionization, even in 70's fighting for basic rights. The documentary may seem one sided but that's only because it's pretty damn hard to side with oil companies who run company towns, use violent tactics, and have no regard for their workers' safety. It still presents both sides of the conflict and while clearly supporting the workers doesn't hide that some of their actions are wrong or misguided.
na EmeraldGuard
90
T7
na Optimus_mike
100
T10
Workers of the World Unite
na CHOICECOD
82
T7
na INDYATMN
93
T9
Following striking miners 4 over a year in'73, this reveals a corruption that now almost borders on caricature (unless ur in an outsource country), as well as humanizing the workers' unending struggle against coporate greed 4 every 1 of the slightest benefits most of us now take 4 granted. Corporate think-tanks have completely tarnished the image of unions since73, but this is a loud reminder that any present-day distance we now enjoy from cruel & inhumane conditions would not exist w/out them
na Kevrock666
85
T6
na experimental
81
T8
na allisoncm
73
T8
na Magb
80
T7
Very good documentary. It never tries to hide the fact that it's siding with the miners, and as a result it paints an extremely one-sided picture. But that's okay, because the situation it's depicting is an extremely one-sided issue. Of course, the effectiveness of unions is a debatable question, but I don't see how anyone could come out of this movie not feeling that the miners were doing the right thing.
Average Tier 7.94 from 146 Rankings rss