"The problem is not the farfetched contrivance of Humpday, but how unmoored it seems from anything but self-satisfied cuteness." - Bill Weber

Humpday typifies the low-level indie film where characters talk out silly ideas they don't believe in anyway, just the pop confusion in their heads.

I couldn't believe how much I liked this movie. All I knew about it was that it was called Humpday and the cover featured two guys in their underwear. My expectations were at rock bottom. But it turned out to be a gripping and interesting story about male sexuality, held together with a naturalistic script and some great acting. Thoroughly entertaining all throughout.

Don't believe the hype. Not remotely "hilarious", this spends 90 mins trying to make an interesting, but absurdly unlikely, premise plausible, & succeeds - sort of. As a writer Lynn Shelton pulls off a decent impression of a hipster male, but never really captures true "guyness" as the 2 men here r a little 2 huggy, chatty & ok w/ sharing vulnerablity. Women might like 2 think straight guys could go this far, but they won't. Still, it holds ur attention in a will-they-or-won't-they kind of way.

This film is a talkie. But every single minute had me riveted. And the dialogue was so perfect it felt like a documentary, not a feature film.

Mumblecore meets bromance, arguably as part of a wave of new American realism. Even though it's heavily based on dialogue, the honest performances come off as wholly naturalistic. The casting is perfect. Action and character melt into one, and what initially seems a one-note high concept gains commendable depth. I was bemused throughout; Leonard (of BWP-"fame") is funny. Mostly, the humour derives from awkwardness - not disgust - so rather than gross-out nonsense, this becomes an engrossing gem.

avoided for a while heard an old review on filmspotting decided to give it a go and was quite surprised made me laugh more than once

Loved the realistic dialogue, but the story wasn't very entertaining or filled with human wisdom. Kind of a letdown.

It has some good dialogues, but it is way too weird for me.

Great. This movie really does take bromance to a totally different dimension. Its got a unique idea, with great performances all around, shot in a very personal manner, flawless execution. Considering the subject matter, it never gets too uncomfortable, kept me smiling throughout with a few LOL moments. Definitely worth a watch.

Entertaining mumblecore movie with great performances by both leads. An entertaining twist on the Apatow formula.

Gives you a few laughs but is too dubious to leave a mark.

Some funny moments, but not quite daring. Some scenes are boring and utterly forgettable. Would make a nice short movie. Watch Old Joy and Shortbus instead.

Great, mostly ad-libbed comedy-drama about male bonding and experiencing life to the fullest.

Old Joy sans aesthetics...

One of the best mumblecore movies I've seen. The awkwardness of some scenes had me alternately cringing while watching through my fingers and howling with laughter. The raw, emotionally unguarded performances actually manage to make the petty bullshit of sheltered middle-class suburbanites compelling.