Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Most polarizing films?
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
If A Tree Falls: A Story of the E.L.F. (2011)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: A rare behind-the-curtain look at the Earth Liberation Front, the radical environmental group that the FBI calls America's 'number one domestic terrorist threat.'
Poster submitted by annie
Country: UK, USA
Starring: Marshall Curry
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na electriccafe
60
T4
na Coredor
78
T8
na ChaosReigns
64
T2
The good thing about this documentary is that it really tried to keep an objective point of view by showing both sides of story and presenting facts. The whole story of what these people did is respectable and agree with in preserving our Earth and not blindly destroying forests, but the way that they went about their so-called terrorism could've been done in a much more constructive and intelligent manner. It was youthful arrogance in my opinion, but terrorism is a strong word for it.
na Slvbarek
85
T9
A documentary that succeeds immensely thanks to its responsibility in striving for filmic truth. It's powerful because its scale remains small despite being about a bigger issue, and within its short running time it manages to bring a lot of perspectives to a divisive issue. In other words, it feels remarkably complete. Were these arsonists misguided? Certainly, but it's easy to see how they could rationalize their behavior when their voices meant nothing in a warped and corrupt political system
na jormungand
76
T7
na Squin
59
T3
na salty dog
85
T9
na hakanTenFour
76
T7
na Warren
74
T3
na SeanBerndorff
83
T8
na msprague
70
T6
A pretty good doc that tells the story of some "grubby hippies" who go a bit overboard in their zeal to stop the wholesale destruction of the environment. What they did was wrong, imo, but then branding them as terrorists is even more ridiculous.
na jonas01radio
80
T6
na jef costello
76
T6
na secil
77
T6
na aurora
69
T7
na pisser
70
T6
na psim
83
T9
na taskn
70
T8
na IMDb-byvotes
71
T6
na Lumine
62
T2
It's a shame that this documentary was so indecisive because there was some potential to explore the ideas here in greater depth rather than trying to present the story in an pseudo-objective light. Instead of having balance, we have a film that never accurately portrays the views of the subject, which makes this documentary a failure in principle. Fortunately there's a few interview portions that redeem the film from total failure.
na lemonhil
80
T5
na bprosser10
68
T2
na hellboy76
73
T9
Interesting documentary about the E.L.F arsons and some rat bastards. Snitches get stitches.
na okyanusta
93
T10
na Gody85
53
T6
na stoker
50
T4
na annie
75
T8
na RealMacgyver
70
T5
On the debate on whether it's terrorism or not, it's not really. Can't say I agree with their tactics, or that of the other side. Good enough doc that serves well to highlight some issues
na viva hate
7
T6
na Hkit
86
T6
na SlantMag
25
T7
"The doc manages to drive home the notion that, however much one might disagree with ELF's tactics, their point of view holds a lot of truth." - Lauren Wissot
na NoSex
75
T6
na Amember
10
T9
na frnk23
65
T6
na DaeSanye
7
T8
na imdb
78
T10
na nymetsman00
88
T7
na MCR
69
T7
na Meta Critic
65
T7
na krf7
65
T5
na klanc11
78
T8
na Obdurate
88
T8
It gives you both sides of the story to some degree. Ultimately it comes down to whether you agree with the tactics or not, but it does a beautiful job of at least presenting actual information and not misinformation. The debate of peaceful/non-peaceful protest and "terrorism" will rage on, but viewers should at least be able to see that the E.L.F. aren't just crazies. The ending was perfect and heart-breaking and says that same type of thing.
na schnofel
74
T8
Clearly maps out the steps in which a young man first becomes aware of the damage big industry is doing to our environment, then gets engaged and finally enraged. The E.L.F. has been branded the biggest national terror organization in the US while none of their property attacks have resulted in a single death. In addition to being a suspenseful story this complicated doc is also a timely reminder to Wall Street protestors that the state will strike down hard.
na Henrik
70
T6
na Kavu
80
T8
Pretty well made, informative and surprisingly objective look at the eco-retards.
na cloak
64
T6
na agathon
78
T7
na 2be
7
T5
na ZombieBuffet
60
T5
na chiphall72
83
T8
na Bojangles
50
T5
na kramertron
82
T6
na norval_jones
50
T1
na tocko
89
T10
na RetinaScan
65
T3
na filmcricket
73
T9
Average Tier 6.39 from 56 Rankings rss