It's all about terrible filmmaking.

Pathetic. I don't buy that the actors are acting robotic, because even if they are, it simply boils the film down to a stupidly simple "love makes everything okay, John" moral. I don't know if maybe a lot was lost in translation (Vinterberg had trouble writing a script in English, apparently), but it's just the worst possible follow-up to Festen ever. Sean Penn is more convincingly retarded in this than he was in I Am Sam, by the way.

WTF was about love?????

I'm very sorry I could not put any more points for this flick, because there's so much good in it. Symbolism was nice; their surviving lovestory out of divorce was a surviving story of the entire globe. The directing was marv and both actors did they job top-notch. The main plot complicated itself unnecessarily. The Hollywood snow ending spoiled a lot the mood, though it explained how everything ended. P.S. Sean Penn was an observing angle.

Poetic, symbolic and beautiful. I just don't understand why it tries to get so complicated with it's plot when the plot isn't even what the movie's about.

It had the intention to be considered a beautiful movie, but that's the wrong attitude. Beautiful movies are just beautiful. No intention and tend to be unforgettable.

"Impossibly glossy, the film claims to be all about love but its heart never makes a beat." - Ed Gonzalez

I think the title really confuses me into believing it's the greatest movie ever...

Corniest attempt at a grand plot ever! Corniest attempt at a grand ending ever! Good special effects, but special effects are a dime a dozen!

Overly ambitious and all over the place. But points to Vinterberg for trying - failure with full steam ahead is somewhat admirable

Strange movie, but not in a good way. Wasted actors in a sometimes interesting but most of the time awful story.

Absolutely awful. NEVER SEE IT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCE.