I hate his "pale guy voice" in between of the jokes but the jokes themselves are great.

Not my kind of humor and the whispers were beyond annoying

Pretty funny.

Gaffigan is a master of modern stand-up comedy.

It is truly astonishing how long Gaffigan can talk about food and keep it funny. I swear he does at least fifteen minutes alone on nothing but Hot Pockets. The high-pitched self-deprecating "outer-monologue" of Jim voicing the concerns of hypothetical audience members gets a bit tired at times, but he goes back to it so many times that it loops back around and becomes funny again. In terms of clean, cuss-free "family-friendly" material, there's no one better right now than Jim Gaffigan.

Gaffigan is really, really funny when he hits that special spot. I never realized how much his habit of meta audience-perspective complaints derails the flow of his material at times.

Do whisper joke, it's so funny! (clearly not for me).

Quite hilarious self-depreciating humour. You can pretty much determine whether or not you're going to like him within 10 minutes. If you don't get his humour and start laughing within that time you might as well just turn it off. That said, if you do get it it's certainly a laugh riot.

The first truly original style I've seen in quite some time, coupled with a great package of material, makes Gaffigan's special well worth a watch.

Stand-up is basically professionalized "that guy/girl you met on a party". This guy took off nice, but went his observations on and on about the same infinitely small kind of crap, I had to bail out after half an hour. He doesn't have a game plan, instead pulls out random American consumer stupidity. Moreso excuses himself for talking too much on a subject or being too boring every 5 minutes. Can't create illusion of sincerity.

very funny

Keeps coming back to the same joke - high-pitched 'stage whisper.' Not great, but passable once

Used a lot of bits from older stuff, just more focused and expanded upon. Good though.

Hilarious! Lots of food and eating material :-)

Jim Gaffigan is one of the funniest standup comics of the decade.