Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Jesus Camp
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Kumo no mukô, yakusoku no basho (2004)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: The story takes place in a alternate postwar period, in 1996, where Japan is divided. Hokkaido is ruled by the "Union" while Honshu and other southern islands are under US authority. A tall tower was built on Hokkaido, which could even be seen from Tokyo. In the summer of 1996, three middle-school students make a promise that they'll cross the border with a self-constructed plane and unravel the tower's secret... (imdb)
AKA: The Place Promised in Our Early Days
Country: Japan
Directed By: Makoto Shinkai
Written By: Makoto Shinkai
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na Gilly
80
T8
na Coredor
72
T7
na arirang
80
T4
na number
88
T9
na Wolfii
93
T7
na ctavares
70
T7
na vheujge
53
T4
na wavymouth
94
T8
na kevinjoseph
67
T7
na pliumbum
81
T5
na qtip
64
T7
na silentheaven
8
T9
na locutus266
90
T9
na dropdeadd
85
T9
na kosmoyagkoto
100
T7
na JooJoo
8
T9
Grand ideas are explored and heartfelt moments aplenty before the movie collapses beneath its purported sci-fi weight in the last chapter. Either too long or not enough time to grasp the full potential here - but what's here works very well regardless.
na Coheed
70
T7
na pietias231
91
T10
na Tweedale
9
T10
na FakeIdentity
70
T7
na woczek
62
T5
na darkman
62
T3
na StabWound
78
T8
na Prayermad
45
T2
na Mazros
72
T7
na escaflowne
90
T10
na SirRobbie
80
T8
na Raian-kun
95
T8
na Quajafrie
3
T4
na susij
74
T3
na kagamin
85
T6
na abdullah gul
55
T2
na Daisuki-chan
45
T2
na adrenaline
80
T9
na IMDb-byvotes
75
T7
na Luna6ix
80
T8
it's a really, really well animated movie. the plot is a bit confusing and unforgiving, but i give it some good marks for originality and story--even if it's a bit childish at times. if you're not a big fan of anime like me, then this should go on your list of to see anime movies.
na Grum
25
T3
na magikid
60
T7
na boobs
41
T4
na hadimbj
60
T9
na abcdefgh
69
T4
na Pigeon Army
70
T4
na FrankHowley
70
T5
na Audrius
100
T10
na gcat
97
T8
na muutanet
71
T7
Stunning visuals. The story was interesting as well, though painfully boring to follow. I have nothing against slow pacing, but this time the director challenge your limits.
na davesv
97
T10
na Atmosphere
1
T3
na avgcrtckr
65
T7
na Trooth
65
T5
Well... It's pretty. I'll give it that. But the story manages to be both bland and difficult, working in a way that makes me wonder if even the filmmakers knew what happened in the story.
na some_person
87
T9
na Jonno Vogt
75
T6
na FallFoliage
65
T7
na uzi_si
66
T6
na Aardwark
75
T6
na RNTLKN
70
T6
na Nandinho
80
T8
na chumlum
2
T1
na soadfiend07
88
T10
na jdalt1234
90
T10
na Xzlu
15
T2
na McMonty
88
T9
na machicodi
58
T3
na DrewTheDude
59
T6
na nylira
80
T10
na asirkia
82
T6
na Tourist
84
T8
na gaucho
5
T8
na smallmouth
60
T3
na Kiraen
100
T10
na Darko
57
T6
na kangadoodoo
65
T7
na internet
25
T2
na evrana
99
T10
I haven't been blown away like this for a long long time; I'm not sure the writer was fully aware of the possibilities of his idea but it made me to stop the movie and jump up and down for about 15 minutes. It is an above average animation qualitywise too. 1 mark goes down for the cheesiness of the love story; I would have taken more marks actually , because pacing was problematic too; but I'm enamored with the idea
na danielsamson
90
T9
na whatismyname
75
T9
na purity
2
T6
na jtb
70
T8
na SmooveJ
90
T9
The sunsets and skies in this film are amazing, maybe my favorite ever in a movie! You know it's beautifully drawn, but it's also a very enjoyable story. On first viewing I thought the story was all very muddled, but I really like it and should watch it again...
na bullet06
80
T8
na darkened
100
T10
na krunkster
86
T4
na Deniz
90
T9
na filmaffinity
69
T7
na barfly
80
T9
na silviox
85
T8
na partious
87
T7
na Jos
85
T8
na EvilShoe
40
T3
na balaam
60
T4
na Fortinbras
45
T1
na gokhanince
75
T6
na Spunkie
82
T10
na Enantoiel
80
T9
na ninjamonkey
74
T7
na Arafel
65
T4
na bsantos
65
T6
na RNG
68
T7
na never1and
62
T4
na Vesey
73
T5
na roujin
30
T2
na Hkit
90
T8
na ktappe
22
T1
What a self-indulgent piece of claptrap. This had great potential but never investigated any of the history of how the North and South separated, what the implications were for the characters, etc. What little science emerged from this "sci-fi" pic was hogwash; they actually try to link DNA to dreams at one point! The visuals are great, but that is the ONLY redeeming feature of this film, and it's not nearly enough.
na JyL
80
T10
na NathanDarko
70
T4
Brilliant optic and nice characters aren´t enough to make a good Movie...Kumo no muko uses nothing of it´s potencial and so the only thing that´s left is a boring anime which ends and the only question by watching the bracing is "what happened in that movie?!?" the answer : nothing... disapointing...
na bluberi
70
T5
na Kittonni
90
T7
na Excelsior
20
T3
na jewellrunner
75
T7
na Veterini
37
T1
na LiamObrien
70
T8
na naikou
60
T7
na aveletrian
79
T6
na b4con
75
T5
na chemical404
52
T5
Perfect example of the movie that runs on emotions rather than story. I wouldn't be able to tell what was it about, but it's filled with loneliness and nostalgia. Animation is stunning, Shinkai is the best when it comes to background design. But the writing never was his strong side, and by the last act of this film I was terribly bored because there was no story to follow.
na lisa77
80
T7
na Efrye
80
T8
na Cherish
90
T10
na queendork56
6
T6
na Pepsi-Man
2
T5
Shinkai's first studio outing, this film is visually astounding, but the plot is nearly incomprehensible. Check it out for the visuals.
na Louieman
70
T8
na Ixtiandur
75
T6
na mrwinkleman
70
T5
na horatio5
64
T8
na BuriedThrice
91
T10
Beautiful story about love and human emotion. At a certain point Sci-Fi elements are thrown in which make you wonder for a bit if this movie will still hold up, but it does. It's written, acted, and drawn very well. The music is fantastic. This is my favorite of Makoto Shinkai's films. It seems to be most personable and complete. Definitely check this out, but it can get slow so bare with it.
na Jyan
63
T2
na jimmyjazz
75
T7
na cxemu789
80
T7
na bsany
92
T9
na zeromind
85
T9
na DeathWolf
70
T9
na Siltem
60
T5
na Boggy
74
T5
na kutas67
89
T9
na imdb
75
T9
na Keitarou
84
T8
na xdino
85
T6
na FitFortDanga
73
T5
Breathtaking scenes are highlighted with beautiful lighting. But the plot is a drag. It starts out strong, but changes in the second act with the goofy sci-fi mysticism that's plagued anime since Akira. The human element is satisfying but the nutty story of the tower is barely comprehensible. Something involving the universe dreaming about parallel realities. Worth a look for the knockout visuals, likeable characters, and stirring emotional content, just don't expect a masterpiece.
Average Tier 6.57 from 138 Rankings rss