Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Directors You Hate
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Les Carabiniers (1963)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: During a war in an imaginary country, unscrupulous soldiers recruit poor farmers with promises of an easy and happy life. Two of these farmers write to their wives of their exploits. (imdb)
Poster submitted by saintbernard
Genres: Drama, War
Country: France, Italy
Directed By: Jean-Luc Godard
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Trailer
Invalid Trailer
If you want, give us a new one!
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na IMDb-byvotes
69
T5
na silly-girl
95
T7
na Andrew Rusin
62
T3
na jef costello
85
T9
na vsls
90
T10
na macedo
50
T1
na NPA
80
T9
na ludymylla
90
T9
na JerryJ
80
T9
na macumbalove
50
T6
na thewire
83
T9
na batman25
30
T1
na arif
100
T10
na St. Gloede
78
T5
na Dr. Drew
3
T2
na ari
82
T9
na rottentomat
57
T5
na frg
10
T10
na TonyS.
72
T7
na Scottathon
58
T3
na Coredor
83
T9
na cinebaixar
77
T4
na Walterpoa
75
T8
na col. dax
80
T6
na vanderdoido
45
T1
na Mr. Mxyzptlk
62
T3
na onetwothree
50
T5
na Beau
65
T2
na Beaucine
3
T5
na RHalpain
25
T4
na jeff_v
60
T3
na GFD
50
T3
na hereslucas
83
T6
na kronstadtli
65
T4
na Ryanola
90
T10
na Tavarezz
77
T5
na Communicants
35
T4
na catfacer
69
T6
na ddaiane
75
T5
na Lone Wolf
60
T4
na Jake_R
87
T10
na guilhermetc
68
T5
na guvolefou
82
T8
na fact100
83
T9
na glm
66
T4
66.000
na luismomm
78
T6
na VALIS
70
T2
na micmac•
73
T7
na nrm4
84
T10
na coutinho
78
T8
na k.van.
6
T3
na fakesenator
89
T9
na avgcrtckr
56
T5
na scollection
63
T9
na salomaoroque
82
T4
na ten
82
T8
na trevitron
65
T5
na Carlospro
80
T7
na NightGoat72
40
T2
na li0li
65
T4
na NoSex
85
T9
na twill.wave
85
T6
na KGB
84
T9
Godard reminds me of how much I love cinema. The absolute opposite of propaganda; crude, half-boiled war statements and philosophies, looks awful on porpuse and absolutely nothing makes sense. As someone who loves surrealism and absurd humour, I love this, perhaps even more than I should. I can't help but wonder though if so many people would be praising it if Godard's name wasn't attached to it. The cinema scene is beautiful and should be seen by every film lover everywhere.
na Bacchanalian
75
T7
na Banana
40
T3
na lippecesar
60
T4
na Dally
70
T5
na Valenzetti
74
T5
The famous postcard scene and a few others are Godard at his best, but they only serve to underline how conceptually thin the rest of the movie is. It has those wonderfully ambiguous moments, but they aren't frequent enough to make it a complete success.
na ponton
34
T1
na gab
80
T6
na JakeAesthete
52
T5
na wig
64
T5
na rodion
82
T4
na cinema_hell
75
T5
na flowing
80
T9
na eli
50
T4
na Mango
2
T1
na purity
1
T4
na idyll
70
T2
na coltrane
2
T1
na Starecase
80
T6
na Padriag
91
T8
na taktaktaktak
80
T7
na goran
88
T9
na jtb
70
T8
na internet
25
T2
na allisoncm
73
T8
na roujin
20
T1
Godard has succeeded in making an anti-war film. He's also succeeded in making an incredibly dull and lifeless film. It's almost as bad as Tout va Bien.
na crmassari
62
T6
na jphnc
70
T5
na flaneur
70
T4
na Kerc
20
T6
na FitFortDanga
47
T1
I like the idea of what Godard is attempting here, but I think he fails at it. And it's so bad (deliberately) that it's impossible to enjoy on any level except the conceptual. If I didn't know it was Godard, and didn't know anything about it, I would have assumed it was just some horrid, pretentious student project.
na Christophilm
90
T9
na jimmynmu
56
T4
This whole film was a little lame. The filmmaking itself is below par, especially coming from a guy like Godard. The presentation certainly isn't memorable, it's a little sloppy which is understandable for a low budge film but some of it just seemed careless. The film itself didn't evoke much of an emotional response with me either. A great deal of this was obviously done purposefully but it didn't work for me at all, instead it just seemed really simple and almost contentless.
na Onela
71
T2
na sdfkt
75
T3
na welike
20
T5
na volver
70
T7
na alive75
84
T9
na lchaussard
90
T7
na Blaz
90
T9
na carolgesser
100
T10
na filmaffinity
71
T8
na paris1919
87
T8
na Kyeiro
76
T5
na ___
94
T10
na b4con
90
T9
na tonhocean
76
T5
na m4th3u5
70
T4
na rudolf55
70
T4
na coffee
70
T5
na ze_qualquer
40
T5
na negative
1
T1
na bernardobrum
70
T3
na akujin
64
T3
na ehrenkm
50
T2
na winds
5
T6
na InaFerrer
76
T8
na Voice Within
77
T4
na Veterini
64
T3
na kyle.loomis
6
T7
Not Godard's most engaging work, but I enjoyed the absurdity of it.
na DingDang
60
T2
na M__
76
T4
na BaalMan
80
T6
na bluesoul
74
T4
na excowboy
63
T5
na JesuisColin
90
T4
na miguel
96
T10
na comanchex
66
T4
na arianemq
85
T9
na aylaka
87
T7
na Haz567
75
T6
na anseiodviver
80
T8
na ShogunRua
87
T10
na imdb
69
T7
na Johnny Case
63
T5
na filmsnob
58
T5
Average Tier 5.64 from 138 Rankings rss