Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
login | register
0 films ranked
profile
Manderlay (2005)
Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Your Rating
500 characters left
Summary: Manderlay is a plantation where a group of people are living as if slavery hadn't been abolished 70 years earlier. Upon leaving Dogville in 1933, Grace and her father head far south to the state of Alabama where they arrive upon the bizarre place.
Genre: Drama
Directed By: Lars von Trier
Written By: Lars von Trier
Additional Information & Actions
More information at IMDb
Trailer
Invalid Trailer
If you'd like, provide a new one!
Ratings
loading Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
loading
Loading...
loading
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na kakivsjok kakivsjok
80
T7
na Frejs
80
T6
na igorette
50
T1
na Evelyn Waugh
73
T4
na Chr. Bach
70
T6
na marrie86 marrie86
45
T7
na Julia18
60
T6
na Cozta
99
T10
na boxgod boxgod
61
T4
na Wulf
70
T7
na firebirdekb
70
T6
na rhutton
7
T4
na MikiRurk_STG
71
T7
na Not_Yuman Not Yuman
70
T8
na ugur ugur
9
T9
na cambel cambel
70
T6
na Spinal
94
T9
na Vaka
85
T9
na patrickped patrickped
80
T8
na ragle_gumm ragle gumm
20
T1
na Bacchanalian Bacchanalian
50
T3
na raipe
55
T6
na j_bur
50
T2
na Derekstar Derekstar
60
T4
It doesn't pack the emotional punch that Dogville does. We go into it with a certain expectation. This diminishes the power of the turn near the end of the film, which was already pretty weak to begin with.
na TalkShowH finkly
80
T10
na electriccafe electriccafe
35
T1
na osmanliemre Hamido
80
T9
na pascally
78
T10
na DePalma
55
T5
na danielkojak_ii daniel.kojak
85
T9
na FlorVdE
3
T7
na RetinaScan RetinaScan
95
T9
na glumpy99 glumpy_99
81
T5
na JanDoggen JanDoggen
80
T6
na Kaptajnen Kaptajnen
77
T8
na comanchex
65
T4
na olympia olympia
69
T7
na dangerity
64
T2
na melisb
78
T6
na -Vahid-
80
T6
na atreides atreides
80
T4
na gevher gevher
87
T9
na troptard troptard
90
T10
na srtck
90
T10
na NPA
81
T9
na bsantos bsantos
69
T7
na FatihC
75
T7
na Tootpadu
75
T8
na contrapunct
1
T5
na toc
84
T2
na SRobot
78
T9
na ceyhun_mr
72
T7
na landpwner
85
T10
na b4con b4con
85
T8
na panchovilla
80
T6
na mrmrulus
77
T7
na lisa_ii lisa-
68
T7
like dogville, but rougher around the edges. the cast isn't as good, the visual style doesn't feel as polished, the ending wasn't as powerful. but this treatise on race, and in particular white man's burden, is nearly as pointed as the amazing first entry into this 2-film trilogy. which is a shame - the ending is obvious in its hint about the previously planned finale on washington. ah well. every feature by von trier, greatest director ever, has now been seen. well except images of liberation.
na Janka
95
T9
na heidavey
85
T9
na mkellins
60
T6
na rant1229 rant1229
1
T1
na kakki kakki
90
T9
Freedom is relative.
na jacub82 jacub82
67
T4
na CoinQuatro CoinQuatro
69
T7
na ARBK2 ARBK2
90
T9
Manderlay is one of the most dynamic films about race and change ever created.
na TheDeek TheDeek
73
T6
na ElefantEars
89
T9
na vandenio vandenio
90
T9
na eraserhead89
91
T9
na ArtoriusRex ArtoriusRex
70
T5
na normalchaos
80
T7
na postmodifier postmodifier
35
T2
na volver
60
T5
na oalerabelo oalerabelo
90
T9
na OzyValens
90
T9
na jgreenwood jgreenwood
95
T10
na velosoph velosoph
90
T9
na waddayanuts
77
T8
na ricozy ricozy
75
T7
na ScottBarnard
51
T1
na Clavius
76
T4
na fuser
80
T10
na barisius barisius
82
T8
na vandercolomb
87
T10
na evrana evrana
51
T2
I generally admire Von Trier's courage, but making a movie about your prejudices about any other country than your own is pure bravado. The movie could not even come near to its predecessor from the acting/setting point of view. Actually the continuity between the movies is problematic, as Grace is a caricature of a liberal intellectual, which is not in line with her resolution to her ordeal in Dogville. Sometimes von Trier just tries too hard to be politically incorrect, it brings him down.
na filimorbr filimorbr
95
T7
na never1and never1and
72
T8
na IndyFilmFest IndyFilmFest
45
T2
na Jen Jen
85
T10
na hremanruss
65
T3
na Mikkelsk
65
T4
na Ozgun Ozgun
84
T5
na carlitaliano carlitaliano
84
T9
na preisner preisner
80
T7
na bmmello
70
T3
na Kunstable R.
80
T9
na cibran cibran
82
T9
na pliumbum pliumbum
98
T9
na DocBrowne
70
T4
na Lactose
100
T10
na Ildjarn
0
T1
na Barkinson
60
T7
na drh
80
T7
na shaifisher shai.fisher
83
T7
na oturan_adam onuryilyang
80
T7
na hypnodick
95
T9
na daniel daniel
40
T6
na nexus6
70
T7
na geminorum geminorum
25
T1
na Henrik Henrik
65
T5
na bokmok bokmok
80
T6
na dharmabum dharmabum
27
T2
na mitsu
80
T6
na nina
80
T6
na rDin r.Din
68
T5
na carolgesser carolgesser
67
T7
na saishu saishu
85
T9
na RedBarry
80
T7
na marc01
84
T7
na bolivar bolivar
76
T9
at one hand I kept feeling that whereas dogville was an amazing venture into a original way of story-telling with a subtle but extremely well-executed script, manderlay lacked the originality (for obvious reasons) and played in a different league with too obvious points being held high and not the same standards in terms of acting and overall quality to it. on the other hand I couldnt help but smiling at the brilliance of von trier while the ending credits were rolling.
na sussli
80
T6
na Christophilm
35
T3
na hsncomert hsncomert
35
T1
na jazzer jazzer
84
T7
na hoolie
88
T8
na erwit
80
T9
na Cloudynow Cloudynow
85
T10
na TFruth
64
T5
na ozobozo ozobozo
95
T10
na Ralegend Ralegend
70
T8
na hacivat hacivat
91
T8
na ?ar
83
T9
na theripper
90
T8
na Pecota Pecota
85
T8
na rottentomat rottentomat
51
T4
na aurora aurora
71
T7
na Canguro Canguro
79
T9
na zerosummer zerosummer
80
T10
na ugur1980
70
T8
na NymSaeveL NymSaeveL
64
T2
na dustin dustin
70
T6
na oyesilbag oyesilbag
100
T6
na EntertainMe
0
T1
This film is torture. Contemptuous and contemptible.
na TJ Ximenez
65
T5
na tomatometer
50
T4
na Sane
71
T6
na NickGlass
71
T7
na Trombob
97
T9
na SPiN73
38
T1
na Coredor Coredor
59
T4
na Ludvig
60
T4
na lolo
70
T4
na TonyKB
70
T5
na Schumiye
80
T9
na lchaussard
75
T3
na coldesser
80
T7
na bussiebas
80
T7
na Dragon77
69
T5
na Adam Voigt
75
T8
na guvolefou guvolefou
77
T6
na numan numan
91
T10
na simajudas simajudas
91
T6
na blackthorn blackthorn
30
T1
na TonyS.
80
T8
na The_Mxe
89
T10
na pixiedoll
70
T7
na AYLE
40
T2
na MentalCritic MentalCritic
61
T4
na robixsmash
70
T6
na dissidentdov
75
T5
na Raf Raf
55
T6
na monaoganders
90
T7
na dqnw dqnw
80
T9
na tattoo
90
T10
na dariawrazen daria.wrazen
60
T4
na thmertens th_mertens
71
T6
Just not as good as Dogville
na Hadzibegovic Hadzibegovic
65
T3
na NonServiam Non_Serviam
63
T6
na ehk2 ehk2
60
T8
na Winternight Winternight
55
T5
na Veterini Veterini
86
T9
na Nepeta
70
T5
A fascinating look at racism, slavery (both political and psychological), freedom and (the potential flaws of) idealism. It's a provocative piece of film-making, but is so explicit about its message and tries to cover so much that it can feel muddled at times (also it lacks the stylistic mastery of its superior prequel, Dogville). Still it really got me thinking and like Dogville it is manipulative in the best way making you reflect on the reactions it prompts from you early on in the film.
na blahzor blahzor
80
T8
na Tavarezz Tavarezz
60
T4
na JakeAesthete JakeAesthete
30
T3
na djross djross
92
T10
On race. And America. Don't believe what you read about this movie.
na ears550 elixir
47
T4
na jim1234
94
T8
na KristianV KristianV
75
T6
na Watashi Watashi
70
T6
na RisingVenus RisingVenus
75
T8
na haal haal
91
T9
na damil
75
T8
na auhasarderik auhasarderik
50
T4
na HansLucas Hans_Lucas
55
T1
na dandaodown
82
T7
na tatasonne tatasonne
91
T9
na Dr. Drew
1
T1
na hristos hristos
75
T8
na AlexanderMG AlexanderMG
93
T9
na Onxapu Onxapu
60
T4
na emrah emrah
78
T8
na Gsaelzbaerle
80
T10
na FallFoliage
60
T5
na nosre nosre
48
T4
na mattnawrocki
80
T8
na Carlos Carlos
89
T9
na gargantua gargantua
67
T4
na ksp ksp
82
T9
na greggg
0
T1
na ar656
89
T9
na green_man Edson Abas
40
T3
na SQB
90
T9
na matara matara
69
T6
na pitn
90
T9
na NRM01
49
T3
na Jazzaloha
65
T5
na sirnaber sirnaber
94
T9
na madeleine gungik
85
T8
na xacviant
85
T8
Widely damned, MANDERLAY is nearly as good as DOGVILLE--a bit less sprightly as cinema, but with a more challenging subject: the racial divide in American society. Von Trier satirizes white guilt, as the well-meaning Grace does not quite find her idealism rewarded. Bryce Dallas Howard, taking over the character, is right for this story; earnest, sympathetic, but just a bit overbearing. The rest of the cast is strong, and Von Trier's work--especially the powerful ending--is just as good as ever.
na riquemiura riquemiura
10
T2
na yasemin yaa
94
T10
na saguara saguara
48
T1
The style and acting are good, but it is totally fascistic.
na orkunersin orkunersin
80
T9
na Ofterdingen
63
T6
na honeycuttwc
65
T7
na hermitek hermitek
80
T7
na gumnova
78
T5
na omeraksy omeraksy
80
T7
na eyazar
73
T7
na auteurist
60
T2
na idiot27000
3
T1
A film that set out to examine racism in America and ended up projecting racism towards the audience.
na borabaskan borabaskan
79
T6
na otavio42 otavio42
75
T5
na sakaerka sakaerka
91
T9
na Varrick
0
T1
na cryme cryme
90
T9
na richiodo richiodo
93
T10
na shhandlisten storyoftheye
75
T6
na Armilio Armilio
75
T8
na KasperL KasperL
30
T2
na promy
21
T1
na Mewn Mewn
75
T7
na Mzyxptlk
30
T1
na deadbill
95
T8
na Uri.s
80
T4
na russtifer20 russtifer20
55
T2
na sidefix
82
T10
na cendos cendos
70
T7
na romaciel
69
T4
Displaying 1 to 250 of 847 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Tier 6.26 from 847 Rankings rss