Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum And now for something c...
the Blog New Enhancement Film Typ...
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Manderlay (2005)
Post to Facebook
Posted to your Facebook profile
Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Manderlay is a plantation where a group of people are living as if slavery hadn't been abolished 70 years earlier. Upon leaving Dogville in 1933, Grace and her father head far south to the state of Alabama where they arrive upon the bizarre place.
Genre: Drama
Directed By: Lars von Trier
Written By: Lars von Trier
Additional Information & Actions
More information at IMDb
Trailer
Invalid Trailer
If you'd like, provide a new one!
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na hremanruss
65
T3
na KasperL
30
T2
na PassTheSalt
2
T1
na guclu
80
T8
na obtiosov
82
T8
na tusubasa
79
T5
na AlexanderMG
93
T9
na bussiebas
80
T7
na nilspels
70
T4
na pittaya
81
T7
na Clavius
76
T4
na Tavarezz
60
T4
na demonhatesme
80
T6
na shahness
68
T6
na GiaNT
91
T9
na Fetsch
76
T8
na cbennett
85
T10
na bailarinaeve
86
T8
na SaiSaiSai
80
T8
na Snazz
40
T2
na kafkalamak
87
T9
na firebirdekb
70
T6
na phibs
7
T6
na gunesko
75
T7
na cagri
79
T8
na RPGman
83
T8
na KristianGSA
75
T7
na Wulf
70
T7
na KristianV
75
T6
na thaysetakeut
80
T7
na ?ar
83
T9
na vwgregov
80
T9
na SickForay
50
T4
na Not Yuman
70
T8
na sudabalik
92
T9
na filimorbr
95
T7
na Mr.Cinema
68
T8
na Ruslandgaga
93
T8
I liked this one more than Dogville.
na dissidentdov
75
T5
na nekopaw
90
T10
na kurisu1974
80
T10
na gargara
4
T6
na Ali_V.
75
T4
na cwratliff
90
T7
na kokirijazz
3
T4
na la_lima
90
T8
na preisner
80
T7
na juanjo
60
T4
na mkellins
60
T6
na PeaceAnarchy
77
T5
na arturkon
96
T10
na zljk
72
T9
na envy
30
T1
na aminshn
80
T4
na mcalcia
75
T2
na striate
80
T8
na carlitaliano
84
T9
na Shemp
6
T4
na NPA
81
T9
na ozobozo
95
T10
na bolivar
76
T9
at one hand I kept feeling that whereas dogville was an amazing venture into a original way of story-telling with a subtle but extremely well-executed script, manderlay lacked the originality (for obvious reasons) and played in a different league with too obvious points being held high and not the same standards in terms of acting and overall quality to it. on the other hand I couldnt help but smiling at the brilliance of von trier while the ending credits were rolling.
na Ciro
88
T5
na neoleo
85
T7
na jerome
63
T7
na philopon
100
T9
na ninth
70
T7
na KenFox
50
T1
na mrmrulus
77
T6
na nihilanth
58
T2
na kkarsan
30
T2
na pliumbum
98
T9
na Kelm
95
T9
na sakaerka
91
T9
na mfl
58
T5
na lauratron
79
T7
na Chrizle
80
T5
na nestor
80
T9
na NRM02
43
T2
na marc01
84
T7
na gungik
85
T8
na Ariaz
88
T9
na SQB
90
T9
na Vaka
85
T9
na winds
4
T3
na yonof
30
T2
na nuka cola
80
T7
na Schumiye
80
T9
na BlueHeat
75
T8
na agrilledfish
64
T4
na pomattovich
85
T7
na spookyjon
73
T5
na woczek
56
T4
na TonyS.
80
T8
na peter_1888
42
T1
na PixilatedMe
84
T5
na vsls
80
T9
na Meta Critic
46
T3
na M.Robitussin
65
T2
von trier's shit-stirring goes a bit too far in this one, to the point where he really seems to lose sight of any thesis in exchange for "look how provocative i am!" on the plus side, bryce dallas howard is pretty good, if not as good as nicole kidman playing the same character
na jeantheoret
60
T3
na bokmok
80
T6
na sasutan
70
T8
na Hans_Lucas
55
T1
na Edson Abas
40
T3
na Berardinelli
38
T1
na EntertainMe
0
T1
This film is torture. Contemptuous and contemptible.
na dharma
67
T6
na Mzyxptlk
30
T1
na hacivat
91
T8
na FallFoliage
60
T5
na digitalmonk
74
T5
na adriennedawn
80
T3
na owen1218
90
T10
na cryptosicko
70
T5
na Rafaela
80
T8
na ARBK2
90
T9
Manderlay is one of the most dynamic films about race and change ever created.
na drmike
88
T8
na bmmello
70
T3
na alix
50
T1
na miller
61
T5
na tummidge
80
T6
na Kapka
85
T10
na tiagopassos
2
T6
na tengis45
85
T7
na OzGrenouille
92
T10
na Veterini
86
T9
na ForReal
65
T6
na joachimt
80
T9
na raipe
55
T6
na tsarstruck
70
T5
na tattoo
90
T10
na deadbill
95
T8
na dbt
85
T8
na The Goat
65
T5
na greggg
0
T1
na Ateisti
70
T6
na otavio42
75
T5
na marrie86
45
T7
na quirkyjunky
10
T1
na asyouwestley
100
T10
na onedayfly
61
T2
na bjornkoop
10
T1
na kralgiyinik
88
T8
na JJ1986
30
T1
na lippecesar
85
T9
na Jotalandim
80
T8
na akd
55
T2
na donquixotic
0
T6
na yasomite
88
T9
na Gody85
51
T6
na jim1234
94
T8
na Adam Voigt
75
T8
na TulipBlack
69
T3
na Flatlands
78
T7
Not a classic from von Trier, but not terrible either. Although not living up to the previous dogville, it has a certain charm. You certainly feel von Trier is trying to get a message across, but quite what that is, I'm not sure I know. It is thought provoking, and a lot easier to watch (in terms of turn-your-head-away violence) than some of his offerings, but doesn't pack the punch that I've come to expect.
na dfernandes
72
T6
na horatio5
82
T10
na zepra
76
T5
na anion
0
T2
na paperilunta
20
T1
na basquiat
80
T9
na zachheltzel
20
T2
na pixiedoll
70
T7
na dandaodown
82
T7
na BadCosmonaut
60
T7
na drh
80
T7
na brunobam
85
T9
na richiodo
93
T10
na Sanvean
95
T10
na imag7
80
T9
na emtilt
63
T6
na Ozgun
84
T5
na Deadmarsh
70
T7
na jam.m.
73
T5
na tetcyo
79
T10
na atreides
80
T4
na brosiv
70
T5
na danastevens
30
T1
Perhaps the saddest thing about Manderlay is how poorly von Trier treats his actors, who are so bludgeoned by the concept and the format they can scarcely breathe.
na gaddark
85
T9
na LordBeefJerk
80
T9
na Mike DAngelo
43
T2
na lolo
70
T4
na Neonman
60
T2
My reaction upon first hearing about this film turned out to be the same as my reaction to finally seeing the film -- why re-utilise Dogville's original style? This makes me wonder if I ever liked Dogville, since this played out like such an intellectual exercise, made all the more grating by the film's smooth, yet flat pacing, the very scripted dialogue, and John Hurt's snidely sarcastic narration (we got it the first time). This film doesn't have nothing to offer, but it's a chore.
na wokelstein
78
T7
na Henrik
65
T5
na mystery
83
T6
na try
80
T7
na sirnaber
94
T9
na salladeel
88
T8
na ricozy
75
T7
na Delaney
64
T2
na bassmanpdx
95
T7
na DCC
64
T2
na onuryilyang
80
T7
na daniel
40
T6
na DaeSanye
5
T4
na juacade
70
T6
na sussli
80
T6
na carolgesser
67
T7
na Franeh13
95
T7
na Grouchy
80
T5
na Mikkelsk
65
T4
na ramingb
85
T6
na darthfrede
80
T9
na kerolayn
77
T5
na IndyFilmFest
45
T2
na ozymandias.
80
T8
na barfly
78
T9
na masonic
70
T2
na umurtas
72
T6
na Benasdfghjkl
70
T5
na VegA
62
T4
na samira
78
T9
na sarah-assaf
93
T9
na viva hate
5
T3
na steelpotato
74
T8
na r.Din
68
T5
na tma1
70
T6
Felt like an episode of the Twilight Zone.
na Yiannos
58
T5
Like a retread of Dogville only it's far less effective and rarely transcends its simple provocation. The racial emphasis seems somewhat misguided, perhaps even misinformed, but there are a few memorable scenes that make it worth viewing, especially for Von Trier fans.
na Communicants
70
T6
na nicson
80
T10
na myso
82
T9
na gargantua
70
T4
na fabfunk
81
T8
A misstep coming down from "Dogville" but still potent and sprightly funny. Bryce Howard is no Nicole.
na sawe
75
T8
Too long
na JanDoggen
80
T6
na glm01
74
T4
74.000
na Rufam
75
T7
Although "Manderlay" never reaches the emotional highs of "Dogville", its carefully structured narrative, well-written dialogue, thematic intrigue and moral implications make it a highly compelling watch. Howard doesn't match Kidman's nuance, but she's a solid substitute. The overall product, however, is hampered by the underwhelming ending, which, unlike the monumental finale of "Dogville", is emotionally muted and marks an obvious attempt to underline the message clearly implied by that point.
na volver
60
T5
na kafkahigh
8
T7
brilliant comedys/satire similar to "starship troopers" or "showgirls"
na Thais
85
T6
na Carlos
89
T9
na RisingVenus
75
T8
na LouLumenick
25
T1
na felixm85
70
T5
na aurora
71
T7
na LToppman
75
T6
na MrBialas
9
T9
na gevher
87
T9
na endgame
0
T4
na erwit
80
T9
na emil
85
T8
na Barkinson
60
T7
na ryju
74
T3
na oalerabelo
90
T9
na misternose
70
T7
na filmaffinity
73
T9
na radiored
79
T9
na dcatcher
76
T9
na luc
40
T1
na crmassari
55
T5
na walkabout
50
T2
Displaying 1 to 250 of 825 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Tier 6.26 from 825 Rankings rss