Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Rio 2
the Blog Order Filmmaker List by ...
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Manderlay (2005)
Share Post to Facebook
Posted to your Facebook profile
Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Manderlay is a plantation where a group of people are living as if slavery hadn't been abolished 70 years earlier. Upon leaving Dogville in 1933, Grace and her father head far south to the state of Alabama where they arrive upon the bizarre place.
Genre: Drama
Directed By: Lars von Trier
Written By: Lars von Trier
Additional Information & Actions
More information at IMDb
Trailer
Invalid Trailer
If you'd like, provide a new one!
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na darthfrede
80
T9
na VegA
62
T4
na digitalmonk
74
T5
na Albaz
87
T8
na zljk
72
T9
na xmoffx
4
T6
na Veterini
86
T9
na belgamo
80
T8
na miller
61
T5
na Aliboron
55
T1
na TizVanSant
63
T6
na benito
80
T9
na fabfunk
81
T8
A misstep coming down from "Dogville" but still potent and sprightly funny. Bryce Howard is no Nicole.
na bernardobrum
45
T1
na ricozy
75
T7
na ibodirector
74
T6
na eraserhead89
91
T9
na jeantheoret
60
T3
na robixsmash
70
T6
na Rey
80
T7
na cwratliff
90
T7
na jebus19
87
T10
na mathias
80
T9
na b4con
85
T8
na luanabp
85
T4
na karolcrist
90
T10
na suisunchien
90
T6
na filimorbr
95
T7
na voy
95
T10
na bussiebas
80
T7
na santana_evil
80
T8
na kokirijazz
3
T4
na pitn
90
T9
na danilosrc
82
T6
na salladeel
88
T8
na voolksorf
50
T7
na tengis45
85
T7
na dqnw
80
T9
na dead man
82
T6
na cat9man
24
T1
na sarah-assaf
93
T9
na Ani
80
T8
na ozobozo
95
T10
na dbentien
70
T7
na kerolayn
77
T5
na gimmefiction
70
T6
na bkam
70
T5
na kastenm
71
T6
na mendeljef
82
T10
na sg31873
75
T7
na Morty
65
T6
na kitezh
80
T5
na felixm85
70
T5
na FallFoliage
60
T5
na KenFox
50
T1
na Fetsch
76
T8
na augustobsf
40
T1
na tetcyo
79
T10
na cin
80
T6
na Meta Critic
46
T3
na BadSmile
70
T8
na nymetsman00
82
T4
na masonic
70
T2
na Kruspe
78
T9
na philopon
100
T9
na lagartazul
70
T3
na BadCosmonaut
60
T7
na MrsEmmaPeel
79
T7
na boxgod
61
T4
na winds
4
T3
na SaiSaiSai
80
T8
na idiot27000
3
T1
A film that set out to examine racism in America and ended up projecting racism towards the audience.
na kafkahigh
8
T7
brilliant comedys/satire similar to "starship troopers" or "showgirls"
na demonhatesme
80
T6
na BlueHeat
75
T8
na peepee
80
T8
na remeard
80
T1
na bentien
68
T7
na Johnny Case
73
T10
na Kunstable R.
80
T9
na gaddark
85
T9
na Snazz
40
T2
na kikolikali
93
T10
na lemot
78
T7
na M.Robitussin
65
T2
von trier's shit-stirring goes a bit too far in this one, to the point where he really seems to lose sight of any thesis in exchange for "look how provocative i am!" on the plus side, bryce dallas howard is pretty good, if not as good as nicole kidman playing the same character
na WaitingScene
69
T5
na kaiku991
90
T7
na lippecesar
85
T8
na burak38
81
T7
na TheDeek
73
T6
na nosre
48
T4
na elixir
47
T4
na Danilolopes
70
T4
na promy
21
T1
na Jen
85
T10
na henri-Q
86
T7
na madlucas
75
T8
na thegrayghost
80
T8
na vencha
60
T3
na Bullt
76
T7
na JJ1986
30
T1
na Sondergaard
70
T6
na oalerabelo
90
T9
na KristianGSA
75
T7
na karakoyun
65
T5
na kangadoodoo
65
T7
na ludymylla
94
T10
na The Goat
65
T5
na melisb
78
T6
na Adam Kadmon
77
T8
na Thais
85
T6
na kily316
93
T9
na Gsaelzbaerle
80
T10
na viva hate
5
T3
na jennica
70
T8
na zurrenarh
94
T10
na nickv
54
T3
na PassTheSalt
2
T1
na monaoganders
90
T7
na Gui
80
T8
na nestor
80
T9
na andymalafaya
55
T5
na alive75
51
T4
na symatak
75
T5
na redmdb
84
T3
na sakaerka
91
T9
na kuzu
75
T7
na kakivsjok
80
T7
na ksp
82
T9
na PeaceAnarchy
77
T5
na cryteno
70
T5
na Sebastian
73
T7
na AlleyLights2
73
T7
na otavio42
75
T5
na dfernandes
72
T6
na toc
84
T2
na The_Mxe
89
T10
na just_nobody
90
T8
na fact100
79
T9
na iolonea
79
T8
na willofgaia
75
T4
Unlike Dogville's slow build-up to chaos, Manderlay simmers for about two hours, and then von Trier goes straight for the jugular. Not as polished as Dogville, but the conclusion is just as uncomfortable as Dogville's, even if the events leading to it aren't as compelling here.
na dharma
67
T6
na OzGrenouille
92
T10
na NRM01
49
T3
na mussi
71
T6
na droid
67
T5
na NRM03
73
T8
na Ofterdingen
63
T6
na Carlos
89
T9
na henriquemsb
84
T9
na benrag
55
T4
na dissidentdov
75
T5
na shai.fisher
83
T7
na Ariaz
88
T9
na Morrisseyfan
90
T9
The often overlooked but in some respects superior sequel to Dogville. Whether it be Dafoe's smarmy gangster, or the sort of whiny liberal arts student Grace played by Howard this second part of the America Trilogy is an effective jab at the darker elements of white guilt and bourgeois liberalism. A film that maybe hit a bit too close to home for some critics is still wonderfully resonant in light of films like The Help.
na djross
92
T10
On race. And America. Don't believe what you read about this movie.
na imag7
80
T9
na filmaffinity
73
T9
na rodrigoppb
84
T8
na envy
30
T1
na mdruskin
75
T5
na Chrizle
80
T5
na OzyValens
90
T9
na rainmaker
90
T9
na jerome
63
T7
na olric
90
T9
na Darbicus
65
T6
na volver
60
T5
na themadelf66
70
T4
na evrenpozan
70
T5
na ckloss
90
T10
na Mikkelsk
65
T4
na drmike
88
T8
na non_curo
86
T7
na Mewn
75
T7
na martinhoh
65
T4
na Ercan
6
T6
na Deadmarsh
70
T7
na ForReal
65
T6
na zerosummer
80
T10
na tiagopassos
2
T6
na Varrick
0
T1
na dodesukadent
75
T4
na robedire
60
T3
na brigitte
40
T6
na crmassari
55
T5
na kevin.sheets
82
T5
na wokelstein
78
T7
na petan080
75
T7
na pekkasusi
7
T7
na lbk
74
T8
na aminshn
80
T4
na DougReese
65
T7
na queen
12
T1
na tattoo
90
T10
na Mingus
2
T6
na jacub82
67
T4
na frenzmag
65
T4
na Marcio_BR
70
T2
na JEMN
0
T1
na mcalcia
75
T2
na cryptosicko
70
T5
na Onxapu
60
T4
na kyle.loomis
6
T8
na olympia
69
T6
na SHolden
70
T5
na tatasonne
91
T9
na decathect
4
T7
na JasonKDarby
20
T2
na Jungle_Julia
45
T3
na nubiabe
94
T8
na billy shears
78
T8
na hristos
75
T8
na hoolie
88
T8
na sarah
85
T8
na morozig
40
T2
na myso
82
T9
na auteurist
60
T2
na finkly
80
T9
na danastevens
30
T1
Perhaps the saddest thing about Manderlay is how poorly von Trier treats his actors, who are so bludgeoned by the concept and the format they can scarcely breathe.
na Rufam
75
T7
Although "Manderlay" never reaches the emotional highs of "Dogville", its carefully structured narrative, well-written dialogue, thematic intrigue and moral implications make it a highly compelling watch. Howard doesn't match Kidman's nuance, but she's a solid substitute. The overall product, however, is hampered by the underwhelming ending, which, unlike the monumental finale of "Dogville", is emotionally muted and marks an obvious attempt to underline the message clearly implied by that point.
na emtilt
63
T6
na Ozgun
84
T5
na Bacchanalian
50
T3
na sunamiabe
77
T4
na negative
2
T6
na BrightonBear
90
T9
na Ralegend
70
T8
na raipe
55
T6
na lauratron
79
T7
na Rumplesink
80
T8
na Scarface
50
T3
na tsarstruck
70
T5
na MoaM
80
T8
na B-Side
80
T8
na Tjekhov
70
T7
na AutumnLily
79
T6
A fascinating look at racism, slavery (both political and psychological), freedom and (the potential flaws of) idealism. It's a provocative piece of filmmaking, but is so explicit about its message and tries to cover so much that it can feel muddled at times (also it lacks the stylistic mastery of its superior prequel, Dogville). Still it really got me thinking and like Dogville it is manipulative in the best way making you reflect on the reactions it prompts from you early on in the film.
na NadFree
75
T6
na juanjo
60
T4
na honeycuttwc
65
T7
na daniel
40
T6
na alkin_cagin
98
T9
na snb
84
T9
na gunesko
75
T7
na Kapka
85
T10
na Bialas
90
T7
na RisingVenus
75
T8
na andreapg
98
T7
na tiagobdonoso
80
T5
na lisagirl
70
T7
like dogville, but rougher around the edges. the cast isn't as good, the visual style doesn't feel as polished, the ending wasn't as powerful. but this treatise on race, and in particular white man's burden, is nearly as pointed as the amazing first entry into this 2-film trilogy. which is a shame - the ending is obvious in its hint about the previously planned finale on washington. ah well. every feature by von trier, greatest director ever, has now been seen. well except images of liberation.
Displaying 1 to 250 of 787 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Tier 6.24 from 787 Rankings rss