Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum New Movie Pic Game
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Miracolo a Milano (1951)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Once upon a time an old woman discovers a baby in her cabbage patch. She brings up the child and, when she dies, the boy, Toto, enters an orphanage. Toto leaves the orphanage a happy young man, and looks for work in post-war Milan. He ends up with the homeless and organizes them to build a shanty town in a vacant lot. The squatters discover oil in the land and Toto sees a vision of the old woman who gives him a magic dove that will grant him anything he wishes. (imdb)
AKA: Miracle in Milan
Genres: Comedy, Drama, Fantasy
Country: Italy
Directed By: Vittorio De Sica
Written By: Cesare Zavattini
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na anime salve
89
T9
na Eden
55
T5
na Al Chambers
90
T8
na Andrew Rusin
86
T9
na lauratron
78
T7
na JooJoo
5
T4
If Capra ever had the interest to put his antics in the guise of Italian neorealism, it would come out exactly like this. That's one weird mix. Some of is charming, but nowhere near enough.
na Dr. Drew
7
T5
na Guilherme R.
80
T5
na elephantman
80
T8
na Bulldoggen
80
T9
na Suldrup
85
T9
na earthlydel
65
T3
na keskin
81
T9
na IMDb-byvotes
77
T8
na Ercan
8
T9
na margot
91
T7
na phxrabello
80
T8
na kastenm
65
T3
na kyle.loomis
9
T10
na erwit
50
T2
na Tjekhov
75
T8
na kylie
76
T9
na davesv
75
T5
na gppp
90
T10
na Kaptajnen
78
T8
na hekkon
70
T4
na Mr.Cinema
66
T6
na Blindfolk
74
T7
na Liverpo__ole
72
T7
na KasperL
30
T2
Sorry to hate on a movie that many seem to enjoy but I liked absolutely nothing about this film - and was frustrated with plenty. One really silly movie.
na BaalMan
85
T8
na ProtectMeYou
9
T9
na nicson
50
T3
na gert
40
T2
na jeff_v
75
T8
na capote12883
100
T7
na pzingg
93
T9
na nt_
99
T10
na Polorrow
94
T4
na theyshoot11
85
T7
#301
na avgcrtckr
74
T9
na cherrorist
88
T9
Uplifting, moving and insane, but good sort of insane.
na EmeraldGuard
70
T4
na RubAndDug
73
T6
This world is both overwhelming and fantastical - Naturally! What did you expect when leaving a semi-retarded, semi-dwarf infant with an insane woman? Miracles? Most definitely. Once he's all (sort of) grown up he spreads "La Vita é Bella" around like a free bootleg while this movie turns into a (silly) blunt political film, still managing to be more entertaining than De Sica's low key productions.. Thoroughly charming with minor drawbacks - both garnered through its utter retarded-ness-ish-o..
na beat
80
T9
na gaucho
6
T9
na ti_rosso
75
T5
na Domini
75
T9
na borabaskan
90
T9
na JangoB
71
T5
na daffodil907
78
T7
na paperilunta
20
T4
na piquet
80
T9
na onetwothree
70
T9
na theyshoot10
86
T8
280
na running
79
T5
quite good, but too socialistic for my taste
na Padriag
93
T8
na ppinocchio
90
T10
na flowing
23
T1
na FitFortDanga
85
T9
A young man leaves the orphanage and ends up in a shantytown the same day. His charm and ability to unite people brings new life to the place... until the capitalist fatcats step in. Part Capra, part Chaplin, part absurdist magic realism. But is it funny? Yeah it is, for the most part. Some of it is a little on the stupid side, and the one-dimensional social commentary is hardly biting satire, but it has a pack of delightful tricks up its sleeve.
na goldenbeetle
88
T6
na schnofel
44
T3
na Vertigood
85
T10
na digitalmonk
83
T9
na deadstick
85
T9
na electriccafe
80
T8
na filmaffinity
79
T10
na VivaLuis
100
T10
na allisoncm
63
T5
na walkabout
90
T10
a magical film...
na kangadoodoo
75
T9
na cambelboy
81
T8
na Theyshootpic
70
T8
na IlPara
90
T9
na Darbicus
80
T9
na owen1218
80
T8
na hehejaja
70
T6
A joyous, frank and charming film. Not as impressive or caustic as Ladri de biciclette or Umberto D, but well-shaped and interesting in its unsubtle attack on capitalism and the inhumanity it can bring forth. The (unlikely) warm-hearted hero seems to become a symbol rather than a human in flesh and blood - still it works.
na RNG
78
T8
na caffe
87
T9
na theyshoot07
86
T8
# 271
na theyshoot08
87
T8
251
na andreapg
95
T5
na LouisMazzini
81
T9
na negative
3
T8
na Ali_V.
83
T8
na rudolf55
94
T10
na Veterini
78
T7
na winds
6
T8
na kafka1325
92
T10
na viniciusjn
90
T9
na Hage89
80
T7
na danielldb
80
T9
na cinebaixar
88
T9
na Walterpoa
51
T3
na anseiodviver
50
T4
na Rey
70
T3
na Persona
84
T8
na bob
82
T8
na viva hate
7
T6
na experimental
81
T8
na ormz
7
T9
na PeaceAnarchy
87
T9
A disarming pseudo fairy tale that worms its way into your heart with light humour and a good dose of social commentary. The first half is just a warm up for the second, which manages to continuously one up itself right up to the fantastic finale. The humour is at times ridiculously stupid, but it's still somehow charming because the film doesn't linger on any joke too long and uses them to say things of substance.
na demonhatesme
94
T9
na DrPhilOssify
80
T8
na aethling
76
T9
na Johnny Case
70
T9
na imdb
79
T10
na RPGman
83
T8
Average Tier 7.35 from 108 Rankings rss