Quite stupid and not funny.

I'm glad the description lists the genre as comedy, otherwise you'd have no way of knowing - at least if laughter is any indication. When the best part of a film is the presence of Johnny Cash's, "When the Man Comes Around" on the soundtrack, something is terribly wrong. Something so wrong that even a bit part for Alec Baldwin and a scantily-clad Kate Hudson can't come close to fixing. Yikes.

I actually liked this movie, and had to applaud Dane Cook's performance. He was terrible in everything else, but here, as an asshole, it felt genuine.

Amusing.

Real human beings do not behave like this.

"My Best Friend's Girl ultimately fails to measure up to its own standards." - Rob Humanick

Romatic comedy with two douchebags, its a common formula really.

This movie was a series of Dane Cook stand up routines patched together with the regular, same old romantic comedy formula. Guy meets girl, guy realises he's in love with girl against odds, guy almost loses girl in second to last act due to something that could have been cleared up easily had he opened his mouth, and then they get together to apparently live happily ever after.

fucking historical

Daily Star says it best: "Crude, lewd, rude and very very very very funny."

Proof that not only does Dane Cook lack clever joke making ability, but also acting talent. Interesting and enjoyable at points, but just...no.

Not a great movie, but not entirely dispensable. The end and the premise is silly as expected. But there are some very funny moments.

Marginally intesting in the beginning, but a totally lame ending. Kudos to Alec Baldwin though.

Just slightly better than I expected. It's sometimes funny, most of the time enjoyable to watch. Grade: B-

I score this one in the middle cause I'm not sure what to think of it. I thought it was hilarious. Dane Cook playing an asshole was one of the funnier things ive seen in his films. Kate Hudson is one of the hottest women ever. On the other half of the film... the plot sucked. It was all over the place. You flip flop about 6 times on who you think should get the girl. Jason Biggs who I personally thought was going to be the hero of the movie dissappears halfway through. It's just a mind wrencher.

There are few funny moments, for the rest of the time its a no-brainer. The movie is something you wouldnt miss if you didnt see.

This movie fails mainly due to a poorly constructed screenplay. Is Hudson supposed to be a giddy whore or a virtuous, high-class gal? Who knows, because the script has her tap-dancing everywhere! Don't get me wrong; there are some funny moments. But, these are overshadowed by the unbelievable premise that Hudson's character would look a second time at gross-out Tank (Dane Cook).

a whole bunch of bland, somewhat contrived romantic-comedy, sandwiched in between a good begining and end. but the begining and ending are both good enough to keep you engaged.

It's funny and that's ultimately what a comedy is supposed to be, but I just can't help but realize that this could have been much better. Kate Hudson's character is one of the most unintentionally unlikable characters ever.