2 for Garcia + 2 For Hawke

These movies were made for people who would love to visit New York but never have. If you have you'd realize these short films have nothing to do with the character of the city.

New York, I bore you. Save the Yvan Attal and Shekar Kapur segments, the rest is so pointless

Some of the segments are cute, some are deeply unoriginal, but most are completely indifferent.

Some pieces are wonderful, the others are very good. You'll smile tenderly.

Innovative, and many of the sketches are excellent, but it lacks cohesiveness.

bok gibi afedersiniz

"If at first you partially succeed, repeat the formula." - Andrew Schenker

why waste several good directors and great actors to make a lousy movie when you can do it with just one bad director and a couple of average actors ??... complete lack of integrity... great acting from shia labeouf though...

A collection of short films by a talented cast; none are brilliant, but a couple are terrible.

Paris Je'Taime is one of my favorite movies and this didn't even come close.

So none of these have anything to do with New York, really. And what the hell happened in the Portman scene? Can someone explain why anyone thought that was a good idea?

Dreary and dull collage of stories which doesn't work on any level, in spite of an impressive array of talent on both sides of the camera. Each story is more painfully inane and tiresome than the last; the tales have no sense of cohesion or purpose - with the exception of Leachman and Wallach's which is watchable mainly due to the actors' effortless charisma.

No one broke any backs making this film, but, hey, it was cute.

really good all star cast 10 out of 10

Gotta see this film!

Wanted to love it but it pathetically tries to be artsy and the stories, for the most part, just aren't interesting whatsoever

Short films that tell nothing at all.

Good. This is a series of unconnected vignettes, slices of love in the Big Apple. Some are profound, a few drab but all constituting a very entertaining mosaic. One biggest strength of this film lies in the excellent performances by the all star cast. I expected the pros to be great but I would never have guessed Shia Labeouf was such a good actor. A very fun film. Recommended.

Lots of good work, stories slided nicely together, but anyway they stayed a bit lame. There was maybe three good and memorable stories. The rest were with mere funny twist in the end.

Interesting common stories in NY.

One of the poorest tributes to NYC ever conceived. How do you make a NY tribute film without Woody Allen and Martin Scorsese? The worst segment was Natalie Portman's part. With each film I see her in I grow more and more tired of her, a very boring actress with very little talent, and apparently not much to say. Ultimately the film is just pointless, aimless and stupid. You can get more insight on the city by just going there and walking around for 5 minutes. Waste of time.