Hated this profoundly.

This film is a disgrace to the memory of the Canadian WWI soldiers of this battle. The worst soap opera style script imaginable. I could not finish watching this rubbish.

the gingered cousin of 'pearl harbor'

It's overblown and melodramatic in some scenes. Some character's are caricatures which make the flick somewhat simple. But other parts have beautiful cinematography and some actors give a good performance.

Quite a disappointing film about the First World War, focussing more on the personal story of the director's family. While I understand his desire to tell the story, he tragically failed in making it more than just a family history.

The war scenes are really well done in this movie. I think the movie looses something during the "at home" scenes of the film. It is nice to see a Canadian film made with a decent budget. Overall I can't quite recommend this film.

a drama first and a war movie second, people need to realize this is not trying to be a saving private ryan, so deal with it. the love story is good the war action is phenomenal, albeit scarce. so take it for what it is, a drama/war (emphasis on the drama), and you will not be disappointed.

If Brent Butt was given 20 million dollars and told to make a war movie. This would be it.

It's an overblown, melodramatic love story set in the midst of Canada's participation in World War 1, and while it could have been better, I'm glad it got made, because hopefully more and better stories can follow.

Yeah, a big part of this movie is the love story. And yeah, a lot of it is set in Canada and not in the war. At the same time, I don't see it as being "overblown", as others seem to feel. There is a very real story behind this flick, for those who are willing to do the research and find out about it. The battle of Passchendaele is a very important peice of Canadian military history, and hopefully will lead into more stories of the like being told through film.

I believe it could have been better, but as a landmark film, it did not disappoint.

Mediocre War Movie

Good one. Love that part with 'crucifixion'...

The kid in this movie is so incredibly unlikeable, I was glad when he died. He was basically asking for it.

Fighting scenes were great, but boy, they sure could have trimmed down the middle a bunch.