Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum What is your most HATED...
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Picnic at Hanging Rock (1975)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: "Picnic at Hanging Rock" is a story about the disappearance of several Appleyard College students, and a teacher, from Hanging Rock. (imdb)
Poster submitted by toro913
Genres: Drama, Mystery
Country: Australia
Directed By: Peter Weir
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na sellis
52
T3
na adrian
75
T9
na charley
60
T6
na drone
32
T3
na jorge
100
T10
na bengar
93
T8
na ravensdeath
90
T9
na bleu
91
T10
na Third Man
90
T9
na AlleyLights2
83
T9
na IMDb-byvotes
77
T8
na Noxville
91
T10
na willt
5
T10
na lucas M.
99
T9
na zsanford44
80
T6
na top-shape
80
T6
na torontodog
90
T10
na manonwire
60
T4
na crackerjack
84
T8
na carpuzz
82
T9
na oceanwards
50
T9
na rottentomat
94
T9
na RobbieH
92
T10
na katsuben
65
T8
na Tortable
76
T7
na Dally
90
T9
na norval_jones
94
T10
na noparticular
70
T8
na Seftref
65
T6
na Gurrkin
98
T10
na LLawliet
75
T5
na Lagavulin
74
T7
na postmodifier
90
T9
na dotCommunism
80
T6
na whitelighter
60
T3
na Jurispathic
6
T8
Speaking as someone who has spent the past eight months reading lengthy case law on corporate liability and incomprehensible legislation dealing with the subdivision of real property, I can safely say that this film is fucking boring.
na FlixR8r
69
T6
na anime salve
89
T9
na hannabelle88
60
T5
na AlexdLarge
7
T5
na nuked
7
T6
na magnani
80
T6
na St. Gloede
99
T10
na mrwinkleman
80
T8
na Minjo
73
T7
na kjfellows
3
T4
na baniclips
90
T9
na lazynick
80
T3
na mgrisnik
87
T9
na Thomassejer
50
T3
na dutchman
100
T10
na Henrik
100
T10
na valeneyre
88
T9
na stailea
92
T9
na Azamat
8
T8
na mohan
85
T4
Cinematographer shows mastery over his craft. Costume design is also done pretty well. The girls look .. well young and beautiful. Acting is good. Music except for some parts is good. Overall well made cinema that along with the subject matter will grab your attention. I dont expect this to stay in my memory for a long time - but some images & symbolism surely will. Subliminal & almost repressive eroticism. It gets you thinking things without actually showing much. Just with camera and dialogs.
na MrE2Me
90
T10
na KMcNeil
80
T9
Aesthetically speaking I personally don't respond as much to soft, hazy and somewhat lush tones as I do to harsh (often monochromatic) ones. Such quibbles aside "Picnic at Hanging Rock" manages to hit an uncomfortable discord despite - or perhaps because of - the harmony inscribed in every lyrical scene. It's unsettling in all of its curious harmony. It's quite unlike anylike anything perhaps barring Coppola's "Virgin Suicides". An obvious idiosyncratic Aussie double with Roeg's "Walkabout".
na tinysausage
88
T10
Even better than I remembered, and it haunted me for 25 years. Keeps you in a delicious paradox of wanting to know the answer but also never wanting the mystery to end.
na aab661
100
T10
na magnoliakid
91
T5
na colonel32
80
na stobetex
90
T9
na bood
40
T2
na palimpsest
70
T5
na onetwothree
50
T5
na x@nder
74
T8
na Mire
84
T8
na aikhe
80
T6
na catfacer
88
T8
na njbinc
61
T5
na SeanBerndorff
96
T10
na Valenzetti
93
T10
If Terrence Malick made an X-files episode... Weir makes a minimalist film feel rich with his delicate, haunting touch. Perfect use of music. I just can't get over how much that one girl looked like a young, female Stephen Fry, though.
na LongHaul
80
T7
na bajoa
75
T6
na CMQuinn
50
T3
na drstrangeluv
90
T10
Absolutely spellbinding, and effortlessly so at that. Definitely reminded me a lot of Roeg's Walkabout and Antonioni's L'avventura, albeit with less overt symbolism than the former, and more sympathetic figures than the latter. I loved the way it handled its central theme of sexual repression. It's hard to believe that Weir went on to direct drivel like The Truman Show and Master and Commander.
na erwit
75
T9
na Mattsdmf
90
T10
na MMAlpha
75
T8
na Dery
65
T6
na mateusz889
82
T6
na cinebaixar
80
T6
na danielldb
90
T10
na Raian-kun
99
T10
na korbenPL
51
T6
na johnnthomson
60
T7
na sirphibes
94
T10
na Amakua
75
T7
na Psypher
82
T10
na salparadise
80
T9
na ribtin
85
T9
na spabz
87
T7
na ToeAndno
60
T3
na RRiis
90
T7
na Dean Franz
30
T4
Not unlike Roeg did in Walkabout, Weir succumbs to lensing the Aussie nature and wildlife like a tourist would. This distracts from an otherwise eerie, if dramatically limp, Proustian chiller. A film like this is hard to rate objectively since it either speaks to you or it doesn't (and also because I care fuck all for objectivity), so rather than saying it's a poor movie, I'll just say it wasn't my particular cup of beer.
na Jeb
95
T9
A bizarre film with exceptionally outstanding cinematography and a anomalously aberrant score that redolently compliments the ambiguity of the Rock's undisclosed secrets. Even when these are finally revealed, the setting's refinement outweights the horrifyingly malign impressions this film leaves.
na td888
60
T1
It didn't do anything for me. There's no real focus, either stick with one of the boys, the orphan girl or the head-teacher. Its' all too fragmented.
na Jazzaloha
73
T9
na lyrradsemaj
86
T9
na gglogowski
75
T5
na svenerik
95
T10
na ehrenkm
85
T8
na mtm
90
T8
na donofthedead
82
T8
na winds
6
T8
na bullet06
62
T3
na purgatos
91
T10
This film may have had a perfect score, utterly perfect. Wonderful cinematography as well, lots of incredibly creative shots are to be found. These combine to make this a really mysterious film where it feels like there's always something sinister just beneath the surface, well, maybe not by the end.
na SirRobbie
90
T10
na poltergeist
94
T10
na LEAVES
44
T5
na benito
75
T7
na BadmintonRed
74
T6
na jeanlucgodot
100
T10
na jjack229
72
T8
na Malebrok
90
T9
na Fran
80
T8
na Virginia S
95
T6
na jeff_v
95
T10
na Coheed
70
T7
na vsls
70
T7
na dmk
100
T10
na rod
70
T5
na AndrewD
65
T8
na Fetsch
79
T9
na sselthur
60
T6
na Ani
75
T6
na JBryson3
80
T7
na Blevo
80
T8
na keskin
90
T10
na ledfloyd
75
T6
na Sinister
90
T9
na margot
100
T10
na oakwoodjoe
50
T2
na VivaLuis
85
T6
na Mechatigger
86
T8
Mystical, dreamlike horror film which poses no easy answers. A rewarding entry for those who like their thrillers done with a subtle hand.
na buah
92
T9
na zuleyka
75
T8
na kneudorf
60
T8
na bsantos
67
T6
na ?elkowo
12
T1
na pristinepain
85
T6
na theyshoot10
72
T5
553
na kennardjon
90
T10
na caiman
70
T4
na jdb361
90
T8
na ffiamma
50
T5
na plutocrat
47
T3
na filmgirl79
85
T9
na ptjan
80
T6
na ransmovies
40
T1
na rocketfuel
68
T3
na calcufaust
65
T4
The movie has an absolutely amazing first act that does a great job of building to the "big" moment of the film, but after it hits its high note the movie becomes much less engaging. The problem is not the lack of a resolution, I think the issue is that the story follows threads that I don't think are so engaging while not paying more time to the things that would be. Ultimately, much like the characters in the film, once Miranda goes, you kind of wish she'd come back.
na LetsGoEatHuh
57
T7
na NoSex
80
T8
na alexandrsaar
82
T9
na elephantman
82
T8
na JangoB
72
T5
na nicson
60
T5
na Duval Spit
76
T3
na OzGrenouille
88
T7
na nickv
75
T8
na pomattovich
79
T6
na Darko
77
T8
Good movie
na Enygma
85
T9
na gtrshow
88
T8
na fenixdown
74
T5
na Barry Lyndon
50
T3
na BaalMan
80
T6
na henriquemsb
74
T7
na Bacchanalian
84
T9
na vmboudreau
80
T10
na avgcrtckr
72
T9
na mightysparks
70
T8
na DigiDan
85
T6
na clarkah
80
T9
na sanguinary
90
T10
na CloseFriend
74
T6
Peter Weir's eye for Australia and his lush cinematography combined with frequent low-angle shots of the perilous Hanging Rock area do an excellent job of propelling the movie and making one forget how simple and bare-bones the story is. It's a gorgeous movie to look at with an amazing score. I found the uneven volume (with whispering and the loud score almost alternating) very annoying, but that's really a personal pet peeve.
na ptsnob
73
T6
na Jackson R
93
T9
na redmdb
89
T7
na batui
80
T8
na sagethekun
9
T9
na QREX
4
T2
na Neveryan
82
T8
na unrecorded
74
T8
na lightningBug
85
T6
na tsebben
50
T4
na vwgregov
80
T9
na M.Robitussin
95
T9
awesomely creepyambiguous
na sjostrand
69
T9
na pustota
70
T5
na Antares
78
T8
na auhasarderik
60
T7
na anonconmatt
60
T7
na kenlahen
67
T3
na RacerX74
91
T7
na ugur
8
T7
na Frejs
85
T7
na themadelf66
63
T3
na debaser1985
79
T10
na JohnnyHarker
10
T10
na flyingcoati
87
T9
na Tomhet
81
T8
Possesses an inexplicably angelic quality and maintains it throughout the film's entire running time. Certainly one of the most entrancing pieces of cinema I've ever beheld.
na panchovilla
80
T5
na killersmalls
90
T10
na Magmadiver
19
T1
na filmcricket
79
T10
na pzingg
90
T7
na pizdin_dim
70
T3
na Edmundo
85
T8
na capote12883
90
T5
na damil
80
T9
na JordanDcFc
82
T8
The cinematography and score are so ethereal. A haunting tale of longing and isolation. The lack of clarity as to what actually happened really makes this a creepy, unsettling film.
na Lemonball
64
T4
na ten
87
T8
na Lone Wolf
88
T9
na IowaFilm
80
T7
na scorvol
58
T2
na Devyn
25
T2
na TartanLlama
80
T8
na bizarre_eye
95
T10
na lilac
100
T10
na AviAwareness
80
T8
na Prismatic
80
T6
na soybomb42
78
T4
na theyshoot11
70
T5
#608
na Calabria
83
T7
na Myszatek
86
T8
na xacviant
85
T7
A fascinating, unsolvable mystery which is, in a way, about its very unsolvability. Set in a remote time and place (rural Australia, 1900), the feeling of lostness, combined with the deep, often unspoken love between characters, creates a unique and haunting atmosphere. Fine acting all around; Peter Weir's direction is patient and subtly imaginative; Cliff Green's script balances dreamy mystery and the structures of Victorian society skillfully. Some heavy-handed symbolism; otherwise a winner.
na Sonrisa
77
T6
na getshort78
97
T4
The students at private girls school Appleyard College are dressing on the morning of St. Valentine's Day, 1900. Several of the girls, including Miranda (Anne-Louise Lambert), Irma (Karen Robson), Marion (Jane Vallis), Rosamund (Ingrid Mason), waifish Sara (Margaret Nelson) and outsider Edith (Christine Schuler) read poetry and Valentine's Day cards. The group prepare for a picnic to Hanging Rock, accompanied by the remote mathematics mistress Miss Greta McCraw (Vivean Gray) and the young and
na Vergere
87
T9
na retsxlif
83
T9
na krf7
50
T4
na Kapplin
80
T9
na jef costello
75
T6
na ponzan
90
T8
na Carlos
81
T8
na NightGoat72
20
T1
na alyshiamay
84
T8
na coutinho
76
T8
na green man
80
T7
na Cuculiza
85
T9
na Eignarom
38
T1
na by Devol
81
T8
na Nathan
91
T9
na joshuastone
10
T10
na grzzsd
84
T9
na DavidBlast
50
T5
A distant grandfather to Trier's 'Antichrist', 'Picnic at Hanging Rock' is from back when Weir had a 'd' at the end of his name. If it does at times have dreamy images and eerie atmosphere, it also suffers from being quite drawn out. Its 'The Virgin Suicides' meets 'The Last Wave', and - to top off this cronologically ignorant and thus totally unfair review - the music reminded me of 'The Karate Kid'.
Displaying 1 to 250 of 627 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Tier 7.22 from 627 Rankings rss