Scott's performance makes the film worth seeing. Ending not so strong.

Solid character study. Campbell Scott is very good.

Roger is fantastic. Nick sucks.

Worth seeing for Campbell Scott, he's good, the problem though is that his character is set up as an obvious straw man.

I think that Campbell Scott, the dude who plays Roger, talks in fake 1950s voice. Weird. But it might just be how he actually talks. I don't know. It doesn't really matter. Writing in this movie is off the hook. This Dylan Kidd fella, he needs to do some more stuff.

I think I enjoyed this film, but I know it left me feeling profoundly uncomfortable. I almost wanted to take a shower afterwards.

Starts off with promise but loses steam sometime before the third act.

Obnoxious and superficial, which is the point, but that doesn't make it any better. And that ending is definitely an eye-roller.

I can't help but enjoy these kind of movies. You know, the ones where the loquacious, philosophical man wanders the streets either on his own or with a naive, innocent companion. Think Naked, Collateral, etc. I was pretty captivated by Roger's musing. Solid character, writing, and premise. That ending, though. Holy shit did they fuck that up. Also Eisenberg's character has one too many unbelievable and irritating quirks.

Great performances from the cast, especially Scott, and a nice and thorough visuel style. It's a shame director Kidd chose an optimistic ending, which doesn't seem to fit the film's tone and mood. Had the last five minutes ended on the cutting room floor, Roger Dodger would have been an indie masterpiece.

"Think of Roger Dodger as a less mean-spirited version of Your Friends and Neighbors." - Ed Gonzalez

I like witty dialogue as much as the next guy, but it felt too scripted to be believable as a character's on the spot, slightly inebriated musings. It constantly took me out of the story, and while I like the characters and almost everything else I couldn't help but continually ask to myself, "Who talks like that?" Definitely worth a watch though.

Cambell Scott does a fantastic job running the gamut character wise. A funny and touching coming-of-age movie.

Watch it once and ejoy it's slick dialogue and Campbell's performance. Repeat viewings are not nearly as fun or insightful.