The film disappoints at the end, when feeling the need to hammer home a message that was obvious enough throughout. Still very funny in parts though, and Mandy is great in the hypocrite role.

A high school comedy that does the rare thing and actually handles religion well in a movie. I probably like Mandy Moore better here than anything else I've ever seen her in (ironic since she plays the villain).

A highly enjoyable film that greats a fresh spin on teen pregnancy. It's at least on par with the overrate Juno. Jena Malone and Mary Louise Parker are both great.

Funny as HELL, a strange take on criticism of over-religious people

Certainly has it's moments, but feels too flat overall.

A funny movie with some biting commentary

Great look at how religion can hurt in large doses

Not as funny or intelligent as it thinks it is--apparently the only two options are being a judgmental hypocrite or deciding to cast off all authority and make religion in our own image. Neither of these is that difficult to portray, and I would have been much more interested in a portrayal of some kind of middle option between these two. That said, it did have its moments--especially liked Fugit's character and pastor Skip.

Hysterical and bitting.