This is a mostly great film. The plot flows very smoothly and naturally, there's some interesting scenarios and careful use of light humor, and the photography is fantastic. The two leads are generally good, but occasionally go over the top. The main issue is the overly melodramatic ending. It didn't bother me that much, but it wasn't necessary and could have been something much more resonant. The music was also a little much at times. But in general, I thought this was one of De Sica's finest.

Though it leans towards melodrama in the end, the overall film was pretty effective. The amateur actors really make the best of this 'Oliver Twist meets the Shawshank Redemption'.

744

#782

Another fine accomplishment by the Italian Neorealists. Sometimes less is more

# 637

Impressive acting, especially considering they're all amateurs. However, the falling out between the two main characters seemed exaggerated, and I found the end to be unrealistic and emotionally manipulative.

Starts off great but De Sica can't resist toying with the audience's emotions and by the end it becomes a really hamfisted film. It's a shame because the same message and emotional impact could have been delivered honestly with a little more care and trust in the audience.

694

Some great scenes, but it doesn't have the same emotional impact as Bicycle Thieves.