Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum → help naming an old b mo...
the Blog → Two New Genres: History ...
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Some Came Running (1958)
Share Post to Facebook
Posted to your Facebook profile
Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Dave Hirsch, a writer and army veteran, returns to 1948 Parkman, Indiana, his hometown. His prosperous brother introduces him to Gwen French, a local teacher. But the more flamboyant Ginny has followed him to Parkton, where he also meets gambler Bama Dillert. Dave must come to terms with his roots and with his future. (imdb)
Genre: Drama
Country: USA
Directed By: Vincente Minnelli
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na jocimarjr
85
 T7
na TCosta
92
 T9
na roujin
80
 T10
na mariestdenis
89
 T9
na alexandrsaar
88
 T10
na Al Chambers
69
 T2
na JJJames
95
 T10
na filmaffinity
74
 T9
na imdb
74
 T9
na HarryLangdon
88
 T10
na mCihhh
50
 T3
na aurora
61
 T5
na CMQuinn
7
 T6
na SirRobbie
60
 T3
na LongHaul
95
 T10
na FallFoliage
45
 T2
na JerryJ
100
 T10
na kastenm
66
 T4
na PabloWeston
91
 T7
na isabellacn
81
 T8
na NRM01
67
 T8
na BaalMan
70
 T3
na IMDb-byvotes
74
 T7
na theyshoot08
79
 T6
414
na Mr. Mxyzptlk
95
 T10
na aneves
100
 T10
na purity
3
 T9
na edaz
96
 T10
na avgcrtckr
65
 T8
na ecalder
70
 T8
na goran
41
 T3
na winds
8
 T10
na MartinTeller
61
 T3
Rather long and artless melodrama, watchable but uninspiring. Minnelli gets in some decent commentary about small-town, middle-class hypocrisy but doesn't do it with the grace of Sirk. Sinatra and Martin are dull, but the screen lights up whenever Shirley Maclaine shows up. The relationship between Sinatra and Hyer is incredibly forced, basically nothing about it works. The carnival climax is nicely shot, everything else is pretty flat. Also didn't care much for the in-your-face score.
na Magmadiver
81
 T6
na scollection
58
 T7
na debaser1985
68
 T5
na AsherFord
81
 T10
na lynchian
78
 T8
na KarenKrist89
97
 T4
na loose_bowels
95
 T9
na Simon M.
83
 T7
na electriccafe
60
 T4
na cinebaixar
80
 T6
na cosmovitelli
79
 T9
na penguinbob31
80
 T6
na gimmefiction
80
 T9
na Veterini
27
 T1
na theyshoot07
76
 T7
# 484
na pjdevitt
81
 T4
na CFoxtrot
85
 T10
na PeaceAnarchy
89
 T10
Excellent work from Sinatra and MacLaine especially. Part character and part study of small town 50's US, it balances the two nicely creating a very compelling narrative whose weight hinges on the emotional reactions of its characters.
na filmcricket
70
 T8
na cnoir
80
 T4
na rudolf55
85
 T6
na Ivanhoe
80
 T7
na chiphall72
68
 T5
na MrsEmmaPeel
74
 T5
na RetinaScan
40
 T1
na M I
87
 T10
na The Goat
81
 T8
na kangadoodoo
55
 T5
na laika
50
 T2
na theyshoot11
79
 T6
#412
na onetwothree
80
 T10
na Theyshootpic
54
 T7
na Antares
45
 T1
A schizophrenic film which can't make up its mind whether or not it wants to be a third rate Peyton Place or Ocean's Eleven. Minnelli may have been a great musical director, but drama was not his forte. The only redeeming feature of this film is Shirley MacLaine's performance as the barroom floozy.
na Ronin21
75
 T6
na vsls
80
 T9
na welike
50
 T10
na Scottathon
75
 T6
na Fetsch
73
 T7
na Aliboron
94
 T9
na Zoltan
85
 T10
na Mango
3
 T3
na Maps
91
 T10
na margot
97
 T8
na frbrown
60
 T3
na trevitron
100
 T10
na vt.medeiros
87
 T7
na screentime
73
 T7
na katsuben
4
 T6
na dr. radical
57
 T6
na theyshoot10
79
 T6
430
na Limdebois
60
 T5
na JohnnyGray
90
 T9
na Darbicus
35
 T3
na dsjoerdsma
90
 T10
na beckers1021
60
 T9
na allisoncm
33
 T2
na Kiddo
77
 T6
na negative
3
 T8
na spicebrain
45
 T3
na jeff_v
86
 T10
Average Tier 6.81 from 93 Rankings rss