Story slow, unmoving, bad acting and directing. What do you want more?

Just didn't get me going. I got 10 minutes into the film and saw nothing of merit.

Lame, I didn't even finish it it was too boring.

holy shit, my psi for this one was zero. ZERO! and i mean, it was bad, but SMG is cool. how could you possibly believe alec baldwin as a love interest though? he's so plump. people complain about woody allen as a love interest but seriously, at least he's a jew

Not terrible, but not very good. Too many weird plot lines. There were some that were touched on but seemed kind of like filler. Like the bitchy boss--had no real impact on the story. Also, some things just seem very disconnected. The ending was unsatisfying. The old boyfriend (the one who was in Europe) thing seemed a little pointless too. These were things that the writers just didn't develop enough.

No this doesn't really work. It is a little too fluffy for me. I think they should have probably just stuck to the book. Wow Gellar's demand has really come down a bit since Cruel Intentions huh.

A romantic comedy with absolutely no comedy in it at all. The music is probably the worst I've ever heard in a film before and this is coming from someone who has seen Spice World. This is probably SMG's best performance but she was still soooooo incredibly bad. Baldwin earned all 10 points himself.