Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum What is your most HATED...
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut (2006)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: In Richard Donner's original vision of Superman II, the Man of Steel faces his greatest challenge yet! Three villainous outcasts, Non, Ursa, and their leader, General Zod, are freed from the Phantom Zone only to wreak havoc, devastation, and chaos unto Earth... (imdb)
Poster submitted by bedirhankara
Country: UK, USA
Directed By: Richard Donner
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na Revolutiono
6
T4
na LargoDominus
90
T9
na cdallacosta
0
T1
na rottentomat
83
T8
na helfen419
70
T5
"Of course he's Jewish."
na wavymouth
100
T10
na Aubs_Blom
0
T6
na mikedemo
70
T6
na Corganist
85
T10
na Cantstopdrew
88
T9
na buddymcl
90
T8
na IMDb-byvotes
80
T9
na Joan Of Arc
56
T2
na hellboy76
75
T9
Kneel!
na tyoda
81
T9
na INDYATMN
83
T6
Little seems different here other than an ending that parallels the 1st film, but improves the Lester ending only a little since it insures the postscript makes no sense at all. The best parts are early on where Lois' attempts 2 force Clark into outing himself, r both giddily thrilling & do a much better job of showcasing the characters' smarts. Unfortunately, the constantly jokey tone taken whenever any1 other than Zod & Co. r in the picture detracts from the tension here as well.
na tef
85
T8
na Pinny
87
T9
na admiralmpj
83
T9
na zsanford44
90
T9
na givethanks
73
T8
na rober469
65
T5
na sweatymonkey
86
T8
na Crazy Jack
88
T10
na ahmed413
55
T2
A little bit better than the regular II.
na coffee
81
T8
na calbff
80
T5
na marsnoir
80
T7
na MasterKENOBI
75
T6
na snyder_rb
85
T7
na kyle.loomis
5
T6
na lvlr
13
T7
na mlpgaffney
88
T8
na teecee
34
T5
Den bedste af de utroligt svage superman film
na Gecko1337
20
T2
na CRB9000
45
T3
na salparadise
87
T10
na Indy
91
T10
na Glugz
40
T3
na Pflyvholm
80
T7
na wolfstar
70
T4
na benito
70
T4
na deadbill
98
T9
na glumpy_99
82
T5
na Jestmen
90
T10
na lonetraceur
77
T9
na Bacchanalian
83
T9
na Armoredrah
70
T2
na El Guapo
50
T5
na darksoul500
95
T8
na RandallODim
83
T7
na safir
80
T6
na feedmyleg
75
T3
na Frosty
70
T7
na avgcrtckr
67
T7
na movieman21
88
T3
na verbals
75
T5
na zanetano
93
T10
na lupa81
65
T3
na abunfk
88
T9
na ksboyd
70
T6
na Jorg
2
T6
na bedirhankara
70
T5
na devastus
45
T4
na x-human
86
T9
Strangely feels like maybe lightening can't strike twice; even with the same crew shooting with the same cast all at the same time. Scenes are edited with different takes and just don't have that spark like the original '78 film. Still, even with all its faults, I'd take this over the theatrical version any day.
na ColonelTigh
91
T6
na Zeno
75
T6
na andersonnery
80
T5
na Paulywauly
87
T8
na LordBeefJerk
80
T9
na Daffy6964
85
T8
na mpollux_ork
92
T7
na jodamico
77
T7
na screentime
72
T7
na Zenmidnight
87
T8
na El Pedro
79
T8
na KMurray
90
T9
na roger1
97
T10
na PeaceAnarchy
74
T4
Don't remember the theatrical release. This version is ok, though predictably uneven, in both tone and quality. At times it really works but at others it feels disjointed and silly, especially the dated special effects. And that ending is a terrible, and unnecessary, copout.
na babaracus
80
T6
na irrelephant
79
T7
na Zoltan
75
T8
na DougCollins
95
T8
na rorybhoy1888
100
T9
na yawkcorb
90
T9
Pure awesome
na glm
80
T7
79.750
na epillepsy
85
T9
na Cloudynow
64
T4
na arcadia
92
T6
na Elfflame
82
T7
na Janne
85
T9
na safseven
25
T2
na hawque
78
T8
na jonjj7
60
T4
na PeterDK
85
T7
na ICJ3K
89
T9
na RNG
41
T5
na JooJoo
7
T7
na silviox
80
T6
na Aquaphoenix
90
T8
na jet0425
80
T5
na lydia69
90
T8
na ozymandius10
82
T9
na LOTNorm
87
T7
na Scarface
85
T10
na Rufflesack
25
T3
I've not seen the original Superman II (decided to go with watching this one instead). Wish I hadn't really, as this feels unfinished. Parts are as good as you'd expect, other parts are subpar. Christopher Reeve is great, of course, and Marlon Brando is excellent. The villains are pretty bland though. I never cared for villains that seemed to have no motivation other than being evil. Also never cared for the whole superhero-having-an-internal-struggle business.
na Floodseeker
70
T7
na volver
65
T6
na Ross
75
T8
na froce
70
T8
na HankTheTurtl
89
T10
na Eagle-X
78
T9
na thebat356
100
T10
na djw263
60
T5
na DanseMacabre
85
T9
na tommyt
73
T2
na Bos
86
T10
na ephedrin
35
T3
na mosesismoses
80
T6
na TroyAnderson
74
T8
na evanfrrll
83
T7
na mike615
73
T8
na MaxQ
90
T8
na frogman777
80
T7
na Bunyas
80
T8
na onegin3000
81
T7
na joshk84
80
T8
This was definitely an interesting redone version of the original movie, but it only proved to be marginally better than the first one.
na aarona1c
95
T9
na Alquimista
60
T4
na Reyvn2k1
90
T6
na thetramp
80
T7
na purgatos
74
T6
Fixes up a bunch of the scenes I didn't like originally and the ending makes a lot more sense. However, it's often very obvious that you're watching a re-edited film. It's more interesting for "what could have been" than it is on its own.
na Stradivarius
80
T7
na Madeleine066
80
T4
na 1338
65
T1
na Sam Lowry
4
T9
na Holygrail2
72
T2
na metehan13
50
T1
na TJ Ximenez
90
T7
na tumi
75
T2
na cthululaw
85
T8
mixed feelings; not confident of rating
na matchbook
1
T4
na imdb
80
T10
na himchamion
72
T6
na canadianor
85
T9
na Jgirl2688
80
T6
na CinematicESP
88
T8
Definitely better than the theatrical release. It's obvious some plot pieces are missing, though that's to be expected given the circumstances. Almost as good as the first film.
na thaklos
64
T2
This movie is ridiculously dated, with a style of comic relief that made me cringe. There are some interesting performances, but they are interesting because of how terribly campy they are rather than any artistic or emotional weight. I don't vividly recall the original cut, but I don't expect that it would be significantly different, and this was, in my mind, disastrously disappointing fair. I wonder what Gene Hackman thinks looking back at this outing?
na tielardurdin
80
T8
na ManInBlack
8
T10
na Evan Waters
91
T8
na alpinaburana
71
T6
na cankanbay
65
T4
na Elysium
1
T6
na ECB
90
T7
na tinlids
56
T4
na Hailey
87
T8
na darkened
70
T5
na SarahG1988
88
T7
na recklessmess
79
T7
Why won't the Son of Jor-El just kneel before Zod and get it over with already?
na CrazyJim9380
85
T9
na ccameron
90
T8
na Maxx2029
80
T6
na strangelime
80
T5
na Charlie
70
T6
na EgbertSouse
80
T6
na drslacker
85
T10
na PhantomZone
90
T8
That's more like it! A few problems here and there, but such an improvement on the Lester Version. Love the Brando scenes.
na 80sfraud
85
T6
na experimental
75
T4
na Garlonuss
73
T4
It's great to see this alternate take on a story that is essentially the same as the one released to theaters. The quality is a bit low because they had to simply put this together from footage already shot 25 years before (some footage even coming from screen tests) rather than shoot necessary footage to fill out the necessary scenes.
na Optimus_mike
90
T10
Yeah, this is how it should have been.
na 8colors
20
T3
na Kusandra
60
T4
Average Tier 6.66 from 174 Rankings rss