Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum New Movie Pic Game
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
The Black Dahlia (2006)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: The Black Dahlia weaves a fictionalized tale of obsession, love, corruption, greed and depravity around the brutal murder of a fledgling Hollywood starlet that shocked and fascinated the nation in 1947 and remains unsolved today. (Universal Pictures)
Country: Germany, USA
Directed By: Brian De Palma
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na Gecko1337
40
T3
na Chrioas
40
T1
na Hakulei
70
T3
na shocking1981
70
T5
na DLawrence
48
T2
na JordanDcFc
65
T3
na elisa_viali
60
T4
na nechbet
80
T7
na trigger440
65
T3
na cryptosicko
46
T3
na billkerwin
65
T1
This film is a mess, but I liked individual sequences a lot. If nothing else, watch it for Fiona Shaw's very bizarre performance.
na BadmintonRed
74
T6
na MasterShake
41
T1
na Amakua
50
T4
na gorkemoge
60
T5
na snowgray
30
T2
29 of these points are for the costumes, the other point is for Hilary Swank being shot.
na Elekoise
30
T3
na LesterGroans
60
T3
na Cantankerous
45
T3
na MTT
93
T7
na kgbelliveau
79
T6
Better then one could hope for when knowing Hartnett is the star.
na LouisGoodman
67
T4
na salparadise
68
T4
na lvlr
6
T4
na fabioleal
50
T2
na HooterDear
70
T3
na coutinho
55
T3
na kneudorf
50
T6
na popelmon
89
T7
na peasleyj
75
T4
na siptar
51
T1
na djinn
2
T4
na shalev
72
T3
na ffiamma
45
T3
na jane-noir
90
T9
na Kopenhaver
40
T1
na Ezoterik
55
T3
na filipk
85
T6
na kastenm
45
T1
na Joelius
28
T4
It was depressing and the best part was the beginning by far that's never a good way to go.
na shebang
38
T3
na bkneale
56
T4
na braxtonolywa
68
T5
na onetwothree
50
T5
na Rollergirl
70
T5
na 1jesper1
57
T3
A Fascinating picture. Slow pacing, but with much to look at. Great cinematography, art direction and costume design. Full of details and haunting moments. BAD acting by Aaron Eckhart and Hilary Swank. GREAT acting by Fiona Shaw and Mia Kirshner. AVERAGE acting by everyone else.
na Riverbelle
68
T3
na gab
62
T2
na woofat
59
T2
na escano777
15
T2
na deadbill
70
T2
na gubl
42
T2
na Leila
60
T1
na kipkipkip
50
T3
na ping
73
T2
na crazy_mary
65
T2
na Ufkabakan
80
T4
na gleipnir
20
T1
na toneill
87
T3
na dzejson
65
T5
na bsting
67
T5
na Gideon
1
T2
na Pats_London
60
T2
na Air23
78
T4
na snb
40
T3
na MKLuvsMovees
60
T3
na smr5354
75
T6
na winds
1
T1
na Panerai
65
T3
na csomay
70
T5
na Patryk
78
T7
na matt2053
75
T2
na sarpierro
75
T6
na Cuzo
80
T5
na Jackson R
70
T3
na Kamil
75
T4
na Poseur117
55
T2
Terrible, terrible writing and worse acting.
na Birdman8732
40
T5
na danielldb
55
T3
na jammastrjess
56
T2
na zvika
75
T4
na ArTéMiSià
40
T2
na StarsKnight
74
T4
na markburdette
40
T1
na TheWhiteYeah
56
T4
na TGTE
50
T2
na monclaro
70
T8
na Doo
30
T1
na Gui
30
T3
na symatak
15
T1
na korbenPL
25
T2
na mokihana
90
T6
na sirphibes
60
T3
na bigowner
75
T6
na FlixR8r
48
T3
na mfeldman9
80
T6
na chgold81
83
T2
na rottentomat
34
T3
na neatmanatee
59
T3
na mattnawrocki
35
T2
na holiveira
80
T6
na Kaptajnen
47
T3
na Niels L
50
T3
na Cantstopdrew
48
T3
na masloprojekt
53
T3
Chyba jednak spodziewalem sie wiecej...
na JohnSandwich
20
T1
Horrible.
na mitchelly
54
T1
na tech2isobel
50
T4
na htcaetano
70
T6
na aignatiou
95
T9
na Mosina
34
T1
na wronguy
79
T4
na cloondog
37
T3
na AngelaC
75
T3
na piquet
60
T3
na aovii
75
T5
na postaci
79
T8
na ehsan_amid
90
T6
na RUIMJO
25
T1
na Solphemaco
79
T7
na tralala
60
T7
na DrewTheDude
53
T6
na zurrenarh
39
T3
na rnevesr
50
T2
na koruthaiolos
64
T4
na Psycore
50
T3
na Mawazh
60
T3
na SJMJ91
82
T4
na chriselliott
40
T2
na Telemecus
40
T1
na annaleepea
45
T2
na QVT
15
T3
Man i used to think Zooey Deschanel or Megan Fox, maybe Kristen Stewart, was the worst actress working. I see now quite clearly that it is Hillary Swank. Or whoever that weirdo who played Ramona was. This is a really bad movie. Don't watch it.
na lukey86
36
T1
I knew that this film had been smashed by critics, but i was bored and it was available. The critics were pretty much dead on. This film is an utter disaster. It is somewhat confusing, not so much in plot but in the characters motivations. Why the fuck are the two main characters doing what there doing? This film lacks focus. I read that De Palma cut about an hour of the film in post-production. Bad choice since I have a feeling that hour cut could have revealed the characters motivations.
na mcasella08
87
T6
na protectyanec
70
T4
na dresdres
65
T3
na kristna184
77
T9
na dkeel
67
T7
na Bunken
50
T5
na mjjcellis
80
T7
na wannabcritic
69
T5
na fabioallan
70
T4
na Roughneck123
70
T4
na sandinista
53
T2
na Walterpoa
45
T2
na rubysparkles
70
T4
na lebnof
24
T1
na jacobb1313
37
T2
The Black Dhalia has always been a kind of Lady Gaga of murder victims, more of a media statement than a person. I want to say this film is also hiding a dildo up its skirt, and I think it was trying to do so: some purposeful casting, (what I think is also purposeful) bad acting, too-convoluted mistaken identities, and neo-noir Hollywood plot are all trying to be Lynch's Mulholland Dr. Except this has no substance, so it blows.
na jeff_v
45
T2
na TobyTyler
66
T4
na ayset
30
T2
na mrdude122887
71
T2
na phxrabello
70
T4
na heapshake
40
T3
na GFD
40
T3
na Pernille
63
T3
na mboto
70
T5
na robotchicken
70
T7
na Ritz
70
T3
na bad_juice
65
T9
na apataca
67
T5
na zuleyka
60
T4
na jenya291182
60
T3
na frost90
68
T6
na bartreligion
55
T1
na Paulmuaddib
65
T6
na sdd2490
85
T4
na sucseven
55
T6
na keskin
55
T4
na rbrohman
75
T6
na Bowiephiles
89
T7
na Analu
55
T2
na burflok
65
T5
na jodigrrl
55
T1
na Jirzzy87
80
T7
na zaxer
44
T3
na mongo
65
T4
na Sphinkx
58
T1
na chris84p2
64
T5
na jayvie
37
T1
na Neoken
72
T5
na Vasco
75
T5
na ledfloyd
60
T3
na suzie ann
45
T1
na Sinister
38
T1
na burak38
100
T10
na Numberz
69
T6
na gunter
80
T5
na linz11251
70
T7
na Fred101
3
T5
na Karakand
5
T1
na slam_bradley
57
T2
na jontaylor85
40
T1
na CN7654
2
T2
na Veterini
72
T4
na shok
3
T8
na dirtyzen
20
T2
na sully32
27
T1
na infrared
60
T2
na harmoniak
60
T1
na OmegaDoom84
10
T2
na NickEntrekin
35
T1
na yes_sir1234
47
T2
na Behemoth666
40
T1
na jawneeb
43
T2
na mrlothos
45
T2
na swat
25
T1
na Evan Waters
85
T4
I enjoyed it when I saw it, despite some rough patches. I may have to give it a second look.
na SneakySneaks
34
T2
na kathleenriot
30
T2
na garbaniele
84
T8
na Milk-plus__
79
T7
na bharath
65
T5
Seems like De Palma tried to weave a complicated story, which turned out to be too complicated for him to handle. The plot wasnt really strong, well made movie. Towards the end the director tries to connect all the threads of the movie, but doesnt do it well. Could have been better made.
na music_dope
50
T2
na cranky
84
T10
na crizco
60
T2
na davidbisok
90
T3
na Nakt.
85
T7
na Princezz
40
T1
na chinansky
42
T1
na jef costello
73
T5
na olshitski
6
T4
na tielardurdin
70
T4
na s1killer
5
T2
na Jarmann
64
T3
The mood itself is great. Unortunately the movie never focuses on a story but keeps trying to tell too many stories at once. In the end everything feels half-chewed and pointless. Too bad, because it had great potential.
na Grouchy
53
T1
na Storchcom
68
T3
na naratemari
72
T6
na a_doomoot3
93
T7
na landsome
65
T3
na RTomatoes
34
T3
na shsetjatj
55
T2
na joaoggp
84
T6
na JacoIII
45
T1
One of the most boring films I've ever had the misfortune of seeing. It gets points for barely par acting (and one exceptional performance by Fiona Shaw that sadly lasts all of 5 minutes).
na Marcossilva
77
T7
na codedgrey
69
T3
na alsolikelife
1
T4
na resaski
40
T3
na SweetD
80
T7
na lmlsna
32
T2
na mattd124
38
T3
na sharpcool
50
T3
Has its moments but never puts together any momentum. By the end I was so detached from the story I was barely listening to the mystery being revealed.
na Novalis
60
T3
na AWyman24
43
T2
na agt
77
T3
na DHC
65
T1
na mikedubs
55
T5
na kerolayn
60
T2
na wwwickie
55
T3
na fabulous
78
T2
Displaying 1 to 250 of 1500 total rankings: Prev | Next
Average Tier 3.57 from 1500 Rankings rss