Fairly typical, believable synergy between the leads on the bright side.

"The film is on far less ground when it eventually becomes yet another wartime domestic tale, with Maybury's semi-kicky style draining out slowly until mediocrity settles in." - Jason Clark

Something is simply not executed well when the prospect of watching my cat barf on the carpet is far more appealing than this piss-poor excuse of a motion picture. It requires great depth of skill to make the scene of arm amputation as painfully humdrum and bland as this one was.

A very pretty film full of beautiful scenes and interesting relationships.

I would have preferred if the film had concentrated a bit more on Dylan Thomas. Here we have this great poet; a complex, fiery character, yet we spend most of the film focusing on his mistress and her dreary love affair with her husband. It feels like a soap opera whenever Knightley and Murphy are on screen together and it's compounded by the fact that they have absolutely no chemistry. Rhys does a great job of playing Dylan Thomas, but I just don't understand why he's in the background so much.

If you want to say something good about this flick, they were leading ladies, though even they were not on their best. Sienna more than Keira. The latter half made the story a better with burst of emotions, but the very ending was again lame.

Tediously self obsessed, like an overlong magazine shoot.

The only reason why i watched this was the 2 beautiful ladies.

BOOOOOORRING!

good to see Cillian Murphy in a role as what he is, a man!

Neh, it wasn't the most memorable of movies, but it was enjoyable. Even Sienna Miller didn't completely ruin this movie for me.

thats 5 for knightley and 5 for miller ... that was live being julia 2

You Can Watch