Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Please justify the endi...
the Blog Collections Watch - AFI 100
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Starred Reviews Wishlist
Random Film
The Enigma of Kaspar Hauser (1974)
Last modified by Jorg Submitted by jimmynmu,
Score
0-100
Signup to generate PSIs for thousands of movies!
AKA: Jeder für sich und Gott gegen alle
Summary: Herzog's film is based upon the true and mysterious story of Kaspar Hauser, a young man who suddenly appeared in Nuremberg in 1828... (imdb)
Genre: Drama
Country: West Germany
Directed By: Werner Herzog
Written By: Werner Herzog
More information at the Internet Movie Database

Invalid Trailer
If you want, give us a new one!
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
if you know about a product that could be sold here
When you sign up for free to Criticker, you'll be able to send recommendations about your favorite films to friends and family.

Signup takes just a couple of seconds, and will allow you to use all the great features at Criticker, so why don't you do it now?
The Enigma of Kaspar Hauser belongs to 21 collections
1. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2008 revision) (public: moderated by Scottathon - 29 stars)
2. Roger Ebert: Great Movies (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 12 stars)
3. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2010 revision) (public: moderated by MMAlpha - 10 stars)
4. Netflix Instant (public: moderated by somnivore - 8 stars)
5. FIPRESCI Prize (public: moderated by paulofilmo - 7 stars)
6. Humanity and the Natural World (public: moderated by paulofilmo - 5 stars)
7. International Dictionary of Films and Filmmakers (public: moderated by PeaceAnarchy - 5 stars)
8. New German Cinema (public: moderated by hereslucas - 3 stars)
9. Color Photography (public: moderated by Criminal5 - 2 stars)
10. Cannes 1975 Official Selection (public: moderated by djross - 1 star)
11. Empire's five star movies (public: moderated by KasperL - 1 star)
12. Cinemag's Best 200 films Ever Created! (public: moderated by hristos - 1 star)
13. They Shoot Pictures 1,000 Greatest Films (2007 revision) (public: moderated by Scottathon - 1 star)
14. Canne Film Festival's Grand Prix (public: moderated by hristos)
15. Cannes - Prize of the Ecumenical Jury (public: moderated by popolinka)
16. Empire's 500 Greatest Movies Of All Time (private: Ross - 17 stars)
17. Cinema Discusso Yearly Consensus (2008) (private: PeaceAnarchy - 7 stars)
18. To See (private: caffe - 2 stars)
19. KAH's movies of the year.. (private: KAH - 1 star)
20. 3 - Watch List: Important (private: KasperL - 1 star)
21. Hells Zargon`s Intended Viewings (private: Hells Zargon)


Browse the full list of collections
What other users thought -- ordered by your TCI
TCI User Score Tier
na Lone wolf
10
T10
na Futuere
98
T10
na Gim
85
T7
na Weafdog
36
T5
na Darbicus
75
T8
na leerudman
74
T4
na Spunkie
86
T10
To be honest I was underimpressed by the first half of the movie. After the freak show is over Hauser becomes intelligable and speaks from the most basic human level. Then on is everything I like about Herzog. A case of the end that justifies the means. Kaspar the Dispossessed.
na boxgod
66
T6
na jliebow
88
T8
na lizzle
100
T10
na DBibby
77
T6
na dead man
86
T9
na joseywales
88
T10
In my review I'm just going to parrot what some other users had to say: "contemplative", "haunting" and "zen-like" are all dead-on in my mind. The true story is even stranger than what Herzog presents here. Was Kaspar the product of royal inbreeding? We will never know...
na NathanDarko
92
T9
na jerome
71
T8
na Suldrup
88
T8
na mystery_man
40
T2
na purgatos
87
T9
Very strange, but in a fascinating way. Bruno S. does a perfect job in his role of being a very foreign man. It's at times sad, at times uplifting but knows it doesn't always have to feel serious.
na cosmovitelli
80
T9
na cute_axolotl
92
T10
na sdoles
9
T9
na Jorg
80
T9
na Badering
87
T9
na kneudorf
85
T10
na bernardobrum
88
T7
na Mr. Mxyzptlk
84
T7
na Ani
90
T10
na dfernandes
80
T8
na cloak
79
T9
na Jos
93
T10
na Coheed
80
T9
na flowing
92
T9
na empire434
83
T9
na szumi
85
T9
na Thoughtgraff
95
T10
Unusual and thought provoking. Herzog has a real talent for finding fantastic true tales.
na nocebo
100
T10
na borges
5
T9
na ArmZ
100
T9
na Zeno
82
T9
na dumbjaw
72
T8
na VivaLuis
90
T8
na MrJones
85
T8
na Shonak
45
T5
na kuzu
85
T8
na E-Pallazzo
77
T4
na JimmyLeresky
90
T10
na captainqwert
80
T7
na jpot16
75
T5
na Bugsy89
80
T6
na oaic
100
T9
na tk32
85
T5
na MLafer
83
T7
na IlPara
80
T8
na KMcNeil
80
T9
na Kortirion
71
T9
na goran
76
T8
na tigre1981
80
T9
na -BigEvil-
98
T10
Per usual Werner Herzog, civilization vies with the untamed. As Kaspar is integrated into society you can't help but feel he is being mechanized and corrupted. But he resists and questions social conventions, and it becomes clear he is actually the most thoughtful, sympathetic, and humane character in the entire film. True to the title, Herzog poses questions but doesn't presume to have all the answers. Highlighted by beautiful period visuals and an amazing performance from Bruno S.
na gork
78
T7
na 8raz
85
T9
na coot
86
T9
na NilbogSavant
89
T9
na soitgoes
95
T9
na laika
82
T9
na jef
88
T10
na Sebastian
68
T6
na mellini
98
T10
na tomas_dfz
98
T10
na IMPERIALIST
90
T6
na filmsnob
69
T7
na Castroph
8
T9
na fabio ramos
91
T8
na Void
2
T5
na graag
80
T10
na ptkw
87
T8
na SirRocko711
88
T8
na nubiabe
97
T10
na popolinka
80
T10
na Scrutinizer
100
T10
na qmzpqmzp
98
T10
na chaw
88
T9
na KAH
95
T10
na Risselada
100
T10
na Matthew
80
T8
na guimnon
100
T10
na flaneur
85
T8
na Starecase
80
T6
na Luna6ix
82
T8
great story and some awesome acting, it's facinating to watch a person in their "teens" (played by a middle-aged man) develop intellectually from an infant to an adult, but i cant help feel that this could have been done better, especially the ending.
na hereslucas
100
T10
na eveelun
89
T10
A quiet and enigmatic study that I found very intriguing and haunting. Bruno S's eccentricities work very well for the character.
na las
90
T10
na cendos
40
T2
na TonythePony
87
T9
na Gui
97
T10
na notchicago
76
T7
na bloodsome
92
T10
na jcdracula
3
T9
na anime salve
89
T9
na wig
100
T10
na Dourado1412
85
T10
na LordofDance
55
T7
na ematitan
85
T9
na somms
75
T8
na Diamorphoses
85
T9
na td888
76
T7
Interesting to watch, but not a master-piece for me
na filmaffinity
75
T9
na schnofel
86
T10
na TroyAnderson
74
T8
na Carlospro
100
T10
na rb42083
75
T2
na negative
3
T8
na htcaetano
100
T10
na KarenKrist89
80
T1
na just_nobody
90
T8
na Guernica
61
T7
na b4con
96
T10
na purity
3
T9
na columbiatch
60
T5
na Sissy Boy
85
T10
na losrasputin
82
T7
na KGB
89
T10
A very interesting film by Herzog (And to think I was foolish enough not to like 'Aguirre' when I saw it!), with an intriguing beggining that once you saw you can't help but watch the whole film. Bruno S. is no less then fantastic, and the production - rather it is rumors or not (And in the case of Herzog it is very possible), it is very interesting to see how unique was the production of such a unique film.
na LuizOliveira
100
T10
na JesseHoffman
80
T7
na zachsavage
73
T4
na viva hate
8
T7
na Raiders
88
T9
na PeaceAnarchy
90
T10
Fascinatingly bizarre. A very interesting story and Herzog is just the person to tell it. At times it's slow but it has a charm and mystery that draws you in.
na vincente
85
T10
The beginning was pretty slow - But watching Kasper learning things was the best part. All togehter a great story und it proofs it again that real life writes the best movies.
na demonhatesme
93
T9
na crmassari
80
T9
na CHOICECOD
78
T5
na theyshoot07
77
T7
# 462
na TJ Ximenez
100
T9
na Landstander
7
T7
na rudolf55
92
T8
na BLH
80
T5
na poltergeist
78
T9
na HKi
66
T3
na boatsfloat
90
T9
na lumor_
55
T5
na lebasi
3
T5
na issou
94
T10
na Nic01101011
80
T6
na goldenbeetle
86
T5
na Potzblitz
94
T9
na JJJames
88
T9
na Theyshootpic
62
T7
na antitype
86
T9
na comanchex
88
T9
na WaitingScene
99
T10
na PabloWeston
75
T4
na amerigo
79
T6
Herzog definitely has an eye for aesthetics and prefers to painstakingly make this the focus of his narrative--in other words this film is very slow. But unlike, Tarkovsky and Kubrick who usually manage to charge the atmosphere with emotions, this film concentrates too much on the real. It's beautiful and at times haunting, but mostly hollow.
na kennardjon
90
T10
na karolcrist
87
T10
na carolgesser
70
T7
na DougReese
65
T7
na guimast
89
T9
na danielldb
75
T7
na Odradek
85
T10
na TedDedon
93
T10
Kaspar Hauser is one of Herzog's most interesting movies and is surely among his best work overall.
na lauratron
89
T9
na jphnc
80
T6
na JakeAesthete
55
T6
na Antoine
93
T9
na imdb
81
T10
na Stimmer
90
T7
na FitFortDanga
89
T10
Another excellent Herzog movie. Bruno S. is quite a find, I couldn't imagine anyone else doing this. What an odd and amazing story. It's very haunting and beautiful, and has a Zen quality to it. Also the application of the much-abused Pachebel's Canon is one of the best I know of.
na DTI
83
T7
na RadioFreeLee
89
T8
na Ali_V.
76
T6
na DCC
80
T5
na Nasenbiber
84
T10
na Magb
85
T8
The story of Kaspar Hauser is both bizarre and human. Bruno S. does a great job as Kaspar. The film is, as others have pointed out, a bit slow and not as extraordinary as, say, Aguirre, but I think it succeeds admirably on its own terms.
na payidar
90
T9
na data
95
T9
na BaalMan
85
T8
na Pestilence
95
T10
na daniel.kojak
86
T10
na childintime
90
T10
na penguinbob31
75
T5
na Gody85
87
T10
na doyone
79
T8
na Alphaville
75
T9
na asdfghjkl
100
T10
na JooJoo
90
T10
na AFlickering
75
T9
typical herzog, bizarre and entrancing story about rehabilitating a mysterious wild retard
na Infenso
85
T10
na Stain
80
T7
na frederic_g54
91
T10
"The Enigma of Kaspar Hauser" is as mysterious as it is intoxicating. Bruno S. is amazing as the troubled, traumatized Kaspar. This films didn't necessarily open my eyes, but rather re-affirmed my view of the world. The work of a genius ? Not really... this is a work of a humanist.
na Ariaz
95
T10
na Sinkpisser
99
T7
na sanjuro
100
T10
na madderroot
66
T7
na pow
75
T8
na mistercheech
33
T2
seriously, i thought this was really great. i've just had it up to fucking here with all this arty farty bullshit.
na the bird
93
T10
na Kerc
70
T3
na gleeb
81
T9
na dorirafael
82
T9
na coutinho
96
T10
na Mingus
3
T9
na PierreTheron
87
T7
Herzog is true to form, painting a vivid tale suffused with poignant imagery and the protagonist's introspection. It's by no means Werner's best, but it is quite easy to sympathize with Kaspar and the film reveals the subjectivity of human interpretation regarding our developed and environmentally influenced worldviews, so doubtless there are some clever and thoughtful themes to be mused over. Beautifully shot and framed as Herzog's standards required, while being entertaining and complex.
na vsls
70
T7
na Farzan
95
T10
The story of Kaspar Hauser is absolutely incredible, and when Herzog directs the story his own way, you end up watching a masterpiece. Bruno S. is absolutely amazing as Hauser, considering a 42 year old is playing a 16 year old. The entire film is brimming with emotion. The character of Kaspar Hauser is so well done, that it felt like he was alongside me. I guarantee, from start to finish, you will not be disappointed.
na dodesukadent
85
T7
na renatcath
95
T10
na cristi
100
T10
na winds
6
T7
na Huuliharppu
8
T8
na calee21
92
T8
na velocipedist
80
T9
na bsantos
81
T9
na Siltem
80
T10
na bmmello
80
T6
na trailblazers
86
T9
na Rafaelol
100
T10
na manonwire
85
T8
na excowboy
99
T10
na forgetregret
70
T7
na mathias
80
T9
na Merc
85
T9
na juliomadiaga
87
T6
na Mango
3
T3
na oalerabelo
80
T6
na chrisssslim
89
T8
na jimmynmu
95
T10
Hauser's innocence is quite touching, something that is obviously connected to Bruno's real life. Of course all of the good things that are usually in Herzog's films are here, but it's the charming honesty from Kaspar Hauser that creates emotional impact. The ending is also among Herzog's best, really powerful.
na Detonathor
90
T9
na ratedec10
70
T3
An uneasy film to watch...almost like watching a horror flick.
na jewellrunner
86
T9
na Mclusky84
78
T8
na mikeparasol
95
T10
na Derekstar
80
T7
This story, which I had never heard of before, is absolutely captivating. It took me several sittings to get through the movie, even though I was memorized by Kasper Hauser while when he was on screen. This makes this film hard to rate. I loved that Herzog didn't try to romanticize Hauser the way that that those in the 19th century did. If there was any hint of idealizing Hauser as a "noble savage," Herzog tears it to pieces in the final scene of the film. My God, how depressing.
na lchaussard
77
T4
na owen1218
85
T9
na steve112sms
86
T7
na epillepsy
61
T5
na kinofil
90
T7
na juacade
97
T10
na anderton
95
T10
na zombieman
85
T9
na ponton
97
T9
na Johnny Case
80
T10
na MoaM
90
T10
na francoe
75
T8
na to_te_rzydy
87
T6
na mrpixies
97
T9
na mcbob71
95
T9
na PimpPanda
89
T8
na ffiamma
60
T7
na viniciusjn
100
T10
250 rankings displayed. Click here to see all 393
rss