Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Jim Jarmusch's Dead Man...
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
The Hospital (1971)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Black comedy in which a suicidal doctor struggles to find meaning in his life while a murderer stalks the halls of his hospital. (imdb)
Poster submitted by Gauntlet
Genres: Comedy, Drama
Country: USA
Directed By: Arthur Hiller
Written By: Paddy Chayefsky
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na CMQuinn
70
T6
na screentime
76
T8
na jodamico
76
T6
na moviefreak
90
T9
na by Devol
73
T5
na cat9man
80
T6
na Dogubomb
80
T10
na DMCrimson
80
T7
na magnoliakid
94
T8
na Al Chambers
88
T6
na jeff_v
79
T9
na Fetsch
71
T6
na danielldb
80
T9
na owen1218
75
T7
na keskin
72
T7
na cwratliff
90
T7
na IMDb-byvotes
72
T6
na carpuzz
80
T9
na Valenzetti
78
T6
na JooJoo
5
T4
It becomes such a trouble with this rating system to factor in how much a 15-20 minute error in writing can affect an otherwise enjoyable time. Some of it is seriously faulted so I'm gonna round this one down - despite George C. Scott being his usual outstanding self.
na Bacchanalian
75
T7
na JangoB
56
T2
na wetwillies
90
T7
What Network does for TV is what The Hospital does for hospitals. Its performances like these that make me love George C. Scott. Such an under-appreciated actor. Chayefsky's writing is strong, even if I don't love the ending.
na avgcrtckr
62
T6
na Forrester
50
T2
na jkwall
8
T9
The movie is at its best when it sticks to being darkly funny. Unfortunately it occasionally devolves into overblown melodrama.
na JJ1986
60
T6
na pzingg
90
T7
na nilkynarfy
90
T10
Sometimes, all it really takes is one outstanding actor playing one brilliant character with something to say and enough time to say it.
na thatgreatwar
70
T6
na jonnykungfu
70
T6
na DePalma
65
T7
na Cabrera
85
T6
na anime salve
86
T5
na rant1229
80
T8
na brianrobot
4
T7
na Antares
67
T5
na Luna6ix
75
T4
a black comedy of the most bizarre kind, it ends up being so straight faced that you're obligated to take it seriously, this leaves most of the comedic elements in a flat or simply morbid state. it's a decent plot and cheyefsky can write of course, but none of it succeeds in the way intended.
na JJJames
75
T6
na winds
4
T3
na jonjj7
60
T4
na meerkat
85
T7
Funny, frighteningly realistic in its absurdity. Again, I heart Paddy Chayefsky!
na genuwine57
78
T5
na kangadoodoo
55
T4
na Pingy
88
T6
na Kermit
87
T6
na RNG
17
T2
na laika
75
T7
na LordofDance
55
T8
na burhenn
90
T7
na DancingP
72
T6
na djross
70
T7
na KungFuDolly
7
T7
na dogbelly
74
T5
na Jack_Murphy
74
T7
na RPMcMurphy
64
T6
na supergloo
9
T9
na moeta2
86
T7
na Scarface
65
T5
na ZombieBuffet
65
T7
na cosmovitelli
63
T5
na Jgirl2688
57
T3
na KMcNeil
50
T5
na DavidKahane
48
T3
While some hints of Chayefsky's glass-shard sensibility come through, the film is very clunky, perhaps an indication of the importance of a gifted director coaxing his dense cascade of words into something fully believable. The film plays like a revamp of St. Elsewhere penned by Aaron Sorkin for HBO, which probably makes it sound cooler than it is. Scott is bracing and gripping. Diana Rigg is another matter. She seems completely incapable of making a single line of her dialogue seem natural.
na Barthalen
81
T8
Scott really nails the role and made me forget the other (weaker) performances. Could've been more interesting without the murderer plot, but I was still glued to the screen throughout.
na MrsEmmaPeel
75
T5
na lebasi
3
T5
na dagda2
87
T8
na comanchex
58
T2
na madisalvador
70
T8
na rb42083
80
T6
na barfly
68
T6
na miss jesus
69
T7
na filmaffinity
61
T4
na jsim596
3
T6
na imdb
72
T8
na dr. radical
53
T2
na Replicant
9
T10
na FitFortDanga
66
T4
Nowhere near as good, nor in the same league as the earlier Chayefsky/Hiller collaboration, The Americanization of Emily. The story is a blend of medical thriller and satire, not very satisfying on either front. The script has a few good lines, but overall it was lackluster. George C. Scott is terrific as always and handles the material with skill... too bad Diana Rigg isn't playing on his level. Not a bad movie by any means, just far from a great one.
Average Tier 6.16 from 79 Rankings rss