Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Guess the movie from th...
the Blog DVD Report - May 22nd
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
The Lost Honor of Katharina Blum (1975)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Katharina Blum is a young handsome German maid. She meets Ludwig, and they fall in love at once. They spend the night together... (imdb)
Poster submitted by Faceplant
AKA: Verlorene Ehre der Katharina Blum
Genre: Drama
Country: West Germany
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na JooJoo
7
T8
na chiphall72
71
T6
na Warren
85
T7
na IMDb-byvotes
75
T7
na Neonman
75
T5
An investigative piece of work, but unlike the news, it manages to find time to also investigate the emotions felt by our title character.
na bood
70
T5
na Gurrkin
65
T7
na danielldb
80
T9
na 100euro
85
T8
na default93
40
T3
na chemical404
70
T9
History repeats itself, and now we often see how little human rights mean in 'war on terrorism'. The film is not very subtle. Obviously the source material was written by someone who passionately hated tabloids and political climate in 70's West Germany. Because of that, film often feels exaggerated and unconvincing. But in the end, it makes its point.
na vsls
80
T9
na jclim00
8
T7
Margarethe von Trotta's quiet beauty and restrained anger make this movie for me. I feel like the presentation of the police and the yellow paper was a little too over the top, but that's coming from the viewpoint of someone who knows very little about that region and time period. Could have used a little more subtlety in the organizations, but otherwise a great movie.
na cinebaixar
79
T5
na welike
20
T5
na Sinister
78
T6
na cinema_hell
80
T6
na ehrenkm
55
T2
na pavementSAW
80
T5
na billkerwin
86
T8
In spite of the timely theme of terrorism, this indictment of police bullies and tabloid journalists looks dated, its villains lacking the subtlety of a first-rate film. The feminist perspective is also heavy-handed, but it is interesting to observe how the male investigators assume that mere political suspicion is enough to justify sexual insults to a woman. It is Angela Winkler's Katharina, however, that redeems this agit-prop screenplay: her innocence and nobility are memorable, moving.
na kuzu
82
T8
na Ibn Salami
8
T8
na Lopokin
70
T7
na ???
33
T4
Frustrating spectacle of misogyny and male/bureaucratic dominance. It leaves you angry, but nothing more than that.
na Valenzetti
82
T7
It's hard not to compare this to Haneke's work, and I think ultimately it's hurt by its relative lack of focus. It seems that a film seeking to expose and combat violence inherent in social systems should either overwhelm with the same voice, as Haneke, or pursue a form of love that escapes the normal bounds, as this seems poised to do but never realizes. It's good, but not entirely successful.
na popolinka
74
T8
na DrinkMilk
83
T10
na kyvetti
80
T9
na nicson
70
T8
na Charlie
90
T10
na guvolefou
81
T8
na Hofschneider
71
T5
na winds
7
T10
na Alon Reter
45
T3
Schlöndorff shows us a frustrating spectacle of misogyny and male/bureaucratic dominance. It leaves you angry, but also unsatisfied because it's uninspired and unimaginative. Sorry, I'm not into 100% political art.
na Rumplesink
80
T8
na NRM01
65
T8
na FancyClown
46
T1
na kronstadtli
80
T8
na sawyer
55
T5
na avgcrtckr
70
T8
na umka
87
T10
na nuotio
57
T6
na NathanDarko
72
T4
na micko
36
T3
na Darbicus
75
T8
na Moribunny
88
T10
A bit contrived in some ways, but nevertheless contains so many valuable truths that its implausibilities are excused. Much more than just a venomous swat at the tabloid BILD, this is a far-reaching critique of a society perceived as patriarchal, misogynistic and (the West German version of) McCarthyist. Blum's interrogator, for one, uses criminal and political allegations as excuses to ravage her personal lifestyle, bullying her about her sexual behavior etc. Quite powerful.
na Potzblitz
94
T9
A classic of German cinema, "Katharina Blum" is a relentless attack on the German tabloid BILD, one of the most despicable "newspapers" in the world. The film, although slightly exaggerated, is based on a large number of similar cases where they gladly ruined lifes just to increase their sales. Yes, Schloendorff is raging against the machine; but believe me, he's completely justified.
na Udo S.
95
T5
na joyjo
75
T6
na LordofDance
90
T10
na electriccafe
85
T9
na gnep
79
T10
na sidehacker
37
T2
na laika
80
T8
na Vardaman
96
T9
na amanohyo
55
T7
na Sebastian
61
T4
na schnofel
66
T7
na PeaceAnarchy
92
T10
na FitFortDanga
72
T5
Reminded me of The Life of David Gale in that it undermines its message by having a somewhat less than sympathetic lead character/victim. Yes, it's sad that the police gave her such a hard time, and the press railroaded her, and her neighbors and friends treated her so poorly. But let's face it, she made she some lousy decisions and wasn't exactly innocent.
na DBibby
89
T10
na Nessalk
83
T7
na flaneur
78
T6
na kangadoodoo
90
T10
na laertes
72
T8
na caffe
82
T8
na oaic
75
T6
na Theodora
78
T7
na dumbjaw
78
T9
na muutanet
78
T8
Flick starts a bit stiff, but the story appears to be very intersting. In the beginning it looks like an unrighteous attack towards a single female and her private life, but the story grows to be an attack against cruel tabloids. I don't know how important the theme was for Germany, but I found the end a bit too underlining.
na InaFerrer
78
T9
na Ali_V.
75
T5
na lebasi
4
T7
na boatsfloat
70
T3
na psim
23
T1
na tathiel
87
T9
na postmodifier
85
T8
na syvyys
88
T9
na excowboy
77
T9
na popinio
75
T5
na DingDang
65
T3
na hehejaja
80
T8
An outraged cry out against the often chaotic, pressing injustice of mass media's intrusive influence on/over peoples' lives, Schlöndorff and von Trotta's film is calm and sober in shape but furious at heart. I especially liked Angela Winkler in the role as the troubled female protagonist, acting her guts out (in a restrained, but heartfelt manner), and the decisively tender camera work... The film is not without its flaws, but it's impressive in its resolution and (ambiguous) soreness.
na Gilly
80
T8
na filmaffinity
70
T8
na imdb
75
T9
na dissidentdov
95
T10
Average Tier 7 from 86 Rankings rss