Mutlaka izlenmeli, hatta 2. kez izlenmesi sart! Orada olup deliler gibi soru sormak isteyeceksiniz.

While the beginning is quite promising, it gets gradually more and more silly until it culminates in an explosion of sheer stupidity which you probably expect since a certain moment, but hope that the movie can't be that predicable.

Nice one... I was expecting smth else but am delightful with what I got. I was tied to screen with utmost interest for the full duration and am definitely gonna see it a couple of more times. The biggest part of the credit should go to script writers. Still I think it would have been better if it had ended without resolving the doubts. And the romance part was a bit weak and seemed irrelevant but good movie nevertheless.

What an interesting film. I'm glad I got used to the acting/direction; well worth it.

Small movie. No CGI. Just a few people sitting in a room, discussing an outrageous idea. But it still is one of the best (Sci-Fi) movies ever made.

Definitely a movie that keeps you interested and leaves a mental mark, but it had all the cinematography of a radio drama, a medium it's better suited for.

Proof that a compelling concept and interesting characters trump shoddy craftsmanship. Yes, the acting is spotty and the camerawork and lighting are mediocre. Its budget is apparent, but because of the general simplicity these faults aren't very distracting. It's not very cinematic, but the ideas presented through a single conversation provide the movie with more than enough kinetic energy. Truly fascinating and thoughtful.

One of my favorite movies. Everything happens in the living room of a cabin where they disguss wether or not the protagonist is who he says he is. Just fantastic.

Sublime. Positively sublime.

As evilchaser says, if it was made in the '60, it would would have been a classic. Although it made me think about lots of things, I don't think I'll bear this movie in mind for long.

What an aggravating film! A for concept, but D for execution The acting is sub-par throughout (except for Tony Todd). The script feels unnatural, so that doesn't help. The 'professors' are peddling pseudo-intellectual claptrap. Most of them are unlikable and, fucking hell, outright stupid. And so, so many things make no sense. I wanted to like this. I really did, and on some level I like bits of it, tiny bits.

I can appreciate it.

No action or special effects. Just great story telling. This movie will really make you think. Awesome!

Science fiction at its best and purest

While the directing is lacking (the zero budget shows), the brilliance of this movie is in the writing. The reactions of the characters to John's story felt so real. Just the right amount of skepticism is presented to keep the viewer connected to the premise. All the logical questions are asked and many interesting concepts are discussed. I felt like I was in the room with these people hearing John's unbelievable story. One of the most engaging and thought provoking movies I've ever seen.

Such a captivating story that at this point I don't really care if it's got any merits as a film. Some might find certain parts of it dull, and the ending is a bit on the boring side, but that doesn't take anything away from the intriguing story and the fascinating arguments.

A wonderful idea, a decent script screwed up completely by mediocre acting and terrible direction.

The story's pretty cool and gets better as it goes along, but the acting is terrible making a film that already is very reliant on suspension of disbelief that much harder to take seriously. And I hated the soundtrack. Still, that it can remain interesting with such mediocre production values says something about the film.

06 temmuz 09. & http://sineofrenik.blogspot.com/2009/07/man-from-earth-2007.html

You can only wonder what would have happened if this had been made by people actually good at filmmaking - and if the writer had had a little more life to work on the script's edges - but the fact that it's still very compelling is a testament to the strengh of this kind of story. Really, is there a premise that sounds more fascinating than this when you first hear it? There is room to tackle literally any subject, and enough dialogue for multiple films. Maybe they'll shoot one every century?

Pretty good story.

Poorly made movie in many ways, but a pretty interesting idea that makes you think about a few things.