Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum help naming an old b mo...
the Blog Two New Genres: History ...
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
The Milk of Sorrow (2009)
Share Post to Facebook
Posted to your Facebook profile
Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: A slow-paced drama about the attempts of a daughter to bury her recently-deceased mother in her home village.
AKA: Teta Asustada, La
Country: Peru, Spain
Directed By: Claudia Llosa
Written By: Claudia Llosa
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na IMDb-byvotes
66
T4
na scanoni
65
T5
na nubiabe
89
T5
na kafkalamak
80
T7
na DianaC
68
T6
na Bitch Alert
80
T8
Llosa's film balances style and content perfectly. Every shot has it's own life, it's own purpose in the structure. La teta asustada might seem rather slow, but the pace is always consistent and reflects not only the personality of the protagonist, but also the peruvian state of mind in relation to their violent past. The film continues to reflect the modern day Peru by contrasting the old traditions with the new culture. The ancient quechuese songs are intertwined with modern phenomena.
na flowing
43
T2
na graveyardtan
85
T8
Milk of Sorrow is filled with vibrant, inspired imagery, with some of its greatest scenes with little or no dialouge. Things get a little weighed down by symbolism at times, but there is a life in this film that's extremely refreshing.
na balseiros
30
T1
na mitchelly
70
T2
na NPA
84
T10
na AVclub
8
T7
na jenya291182
86
T8
na Sissy Boy
60
T6
na atreides
84
T5
na Rufflesack
75
T7
What was most memorable about this for me was the outstandingly gorgeous mise-en-scene, with the most dazzling use of color I've seen in years. I loved how the main character's thoroughly slow movements was reflected in the tempo of the film. Has a surprising amount of humorous moments as well.
na Meta Critic
68
T8
na Dery
65
T6
na marrie86
50
T8
na captainqwert
80
T7
na alive75
50
T4
na ghostmap
80
T6
na Ercan
6
T6
na ggggg1
83
T7
na maroline
76
T5
na Ram0n
66
T3
na pl_
70
T6
na lopopo
82
T3
na jef costello
75
T6
na Rocko
75
T5
na Raimondi
75
T8
na Siltem
80
T10
na PeaceAnarchy
82
T7
I love all the little things the film does in depicting culture, class differences, personalities, etc. I also like the film's general style: Contemplative but always engaging. I don't really understand the main character, though, and that makes it hard to get fully behind it.
na ratometer
69
T2
na Mochard
37
T1
na spider_7
40
T1
na RoXoN
80
T7
na samourai
94
T3
na cambelboy
67
T5
na adrianavb
80
T10
La actuación de Magaly Solier es impecable, los picos del guión son increíble está muy bien redactada la película. La fotografía me pareció brillante, arriesgada en algunos casos pero funciona muy bien.
na M_A
89
T10
na MartinTeller
85
T9
A strikingly beautiful and unusual allegory for a country coping with pain, it's about a girl who believes she has been cursed. Magaly Solier is superb as Fausta in the lead; not a lot of dialogue, but her fear and quiet intensity burns in her eyes. The cinematography is just gorgeous, as is the gentle score (Fausta and her mother's made-up songs play a major role in the storytelling as well). A very interesting look at Peruvian culture as well as an intriguing, subdued psychological drama.
na benedetti
54
T2
na burflok
73
T9
na whitelighter
51
T1
na KasperL
40
T3
na Veterini
72
T4
na Vasily
60
T3
na Guillaume
60
T2
na Adriano
65
T7
na avgcrtckr
57
T6
na itsirc
80
T10
na LordBeefJerk
30
T2
na karolcrist
86
T9
na isaachayes
10
T1
na OzGrenouille
80
T5
na mCihhh
20
T1
na jeff_v
55
T2
na Christophilm
20
T2
na kelpy
78
T7
na mklehner
67
T3
na macumbalove
50
T6
na fellipe_1806
40
T1
na Eldarion
72
T5
na kluch-f
95
T7
na Ludium
73
T5
na NRM01
53
T4
na Pari
91
T10
na Octave
78
T9
na walkabout
64
T5
na sbirko
60
T5
na Cuculiza
75
T7
na Achk
5
T4
na orkopires
10
T1
na Roberta
73
T5
na winds
4
T3
na Pats_London
79
T5
na nomadica
90
T10
na mitsu
90
T8
na screentime
68
T6
na guvolefou
71
T4
na phxrabello
80
T8
na Andariele
72
T5
na SlantMag
35
T10
"The legacy of sexualized violence is the chief generational inheritance in Claudia Llosa's incisive, carefully observed Golden Bear-winner." - Andrew Schenker
na ppinocchio
79
T6
na astrakhan
82
T9
For a European viewer, the film is a culture shock, and the gradual discovery of the faraway Peruvian civilisation is paralleled in the slow revealing of the central character, a beautiful but shy teenage girl. The camera frequently shoots her head-on in varying degrees of close-up, a very intimate technique which also amplifies the tension in several scenes. It's nicely-shot, well-acted, and powerful in a restrained way, but ultimately its semi-magical exoticism is the film's trump card.
na kubrick86
67
T4
na pzingg
90
T7
90 for a drama set in the real slums of Lima and with a Grey Gardens type of bourgeois mansion, and for a boat in the desert. Solier seems like an alien supermodel planted in the midst of the wonderful non-actors, but her silence is captivating.
na filmaffinity
59
T4
na glm
73
T6
73.250
na Grouchy
85
T7
na RealMacgyver
20
T1
na jazzer
40
T1
na zwyk
62
T4
na PeregrinVelo
67
T6
na Drakula
100
T9
na Gody85
58
T7
na ArmondWhite
5
T7
"If you accurately described each scene, you'd have a book of poetry. That's how detailed and vivid are The Milk of Sorrow's rhythms."
na ayset
57
T3
na richiodo
91
T9
na Komond
45
T3
na SeanBerndorff
45
T3
na wronguy
89
T6
na franjox
92
T8
na JoO
73
T4
na djemba
87
T9
na efedanisman
60
T3
na kastenm
41
T1
na jfisherman
60
T1
na juanita
80
T7
na felipelahm
55
T4
It's a film filled with an amazing cinematography, which is almost a character in the plot. Claudia Llosa can't sustain the powerful first minutes through the whole picture though.
na sur
87
T6
na gazpacho
65
T7
na Llanirev
50
T2
na elmakebabi
66
T5
na hehejaja
60
T4
A nice - but sadly unforceful - film. Pretty forgettable.
na pcolangelo
95
T6
na Patryk
42
T1
na MCR
68
T7
na micmac•
72
T7
na schnofel
60
T6
na Enzio
90
T8
na bob
76
T6
na SirRobbie
80
T8
na lunk
80
T5
na nrm5
56
T5
na kris2222
87
T8
na batui
75
T7
na grunkeke
82
T1
na las
75
T5
na igel
62
T2
na jaque_line
98
T7
na Bondo
53
T1
na fuser
70
T6
na buak
95
T10
4 Nisan 09, 28. ist. film fest. & 16:00 | Yeni Rüya & festivalin ilk gununde, festivalin en basarili filmi olabilir. pek basarili bulmayan elestirmenlerin aksine, simgesel anlatimi ve peruya ozgu atmosferiyle unutulmasi guc bir film. hafizama derin bir sekilde kazindi. 'Unutulmaz' bir deneyim.
na kokirijazz
4
T6
na cranky
86
T10
na Naughty
10
T2
Boring! Dull! Lifeless! The brightest star of the film had no lines whatsoever and is best when mashed and served with butter!
na kasator
50
T2
na dirtyzen
63
T7
na Scampi
70
T6
na kneudorf
65
T8
na obtiosov
50
T2
na palma
85
T8
na nuncasesabe
69
T7
na isabellacn
78
T7
na imdb
80
T10
na henrybr
72
T4
na ARUCARD
80
T6
na erikkirtley
86
T8
na chewbacca
80
T8
Average Tier 5.47 from 151 Rankings rss