Overplays the god and miracle thing and there isn't really much original about this story. Still despite these things I could not help myself not to fall in love with these characters, even some I initially thought that I hated, which is no small feat.

A story about True love. This movie will surely make you smile, cry and fall inlove at the same time.

Everything is just so happy. Even the sadness is happy.

Most quiet geese ever.

Though it is immediatly apparent who the people in the story are in the modern time this romance was about as fresh as they get these days.

If your trying to watch a good historical romance do yourself a favor and try out Reds and Atonement.

Having read the book first, I was extremely excited to find out that this was being produced. The story was simple enough that a direct translation to the screen could be done without losing anything essential to the love story. Unfortunately, they totally botched this movie up, dramatically changing the characters while keeping only some of the superficial storyline. I can't think of another movie that has disappointed me more. Read the book, and avoid the movie...

Something about McAdams and Gosling made me like this, although the old couple melodrama almost canceled it out.

My girlfriend really loved it, but this really isn't a story for me. The acting is good, the story is good, it's romantic, nobody will deny that, but it just doesn't appeal to me.. But hey, I've seen worse chick flicks, and this one really isn't that bad. It's a good movie, but just not my kind of films..

Holy crap, is this strange. This is one the chickiest chick flicks you will ever see, and it is actually good. If you watch this with your woman, she will think you are awesome and you will actually enjoy the movie. Both lead actors are very good in this movie.