Criticker.com - Film Recommendations and Community
currently at ...
the Forum Jim Jarmusch's Dead Man...
the Blog DVD Report - February 7th
login | register
0 films ranked
You Explore Interact Resources
Search
Profile All Your Rankings Starred Reviews Your Best TCIs PSIs Kumpels Wishlist
Random Film
The Singing Detective (1986)

Probable Score
Not Enough Info
Rank It
500 characters left
Summary: Detective novelist Philip Marlow (Michael Gambon) suffers from the crippling disease of psoriatic arthropathy. Confined to a hospital bed, Marlow mentally rewrites his early Chandleresque thriller, "The Singing Detective," with himself in the title role, drifting into a surreal 1945 fantasy of spies and criminals, along with vivid memories of a childhood in the Forest of Dean... (imdb)
Poster submitted by SirRobbie
Country: Australia, UK
Directed By: Jon Amiel
Written By: Dennis Potter
More information at the Internet Movie Database
Ratings
Loading Products from Amazon and Ebay
Loading...
Loading...
Show:All Rankings | With Reviews
Order by:TCI | Tier | Date Ranked | # Stars (Reviews)
TCI User Score
na KTP
100
T10
na elmakebabi
60
T4
na waddayanuts
28
T1
Not my taste at all. The humour was off, the neo noir stuff was childish. One of the worst attempts at making a noir. Gambon does a good job, though. Just a shame his skin decease made him so repulsive.
na Hysteria
85
T10
na anime salve
90
T10
na darthfrede
80
T9
na Sduck25
30
T9
na Henrik
90
T10
na jef costello
91
T10
na Tds4a
90
T10
na KristianGSA
85
T10
na rottentomat
100
T10
na buser333
41
T3
na richard7422
85
T7
na Psst
85
T9
na PerryStroika
86
T10
Gambon is a great actor. Tour through the fantasy life of a tortured mind. Dense, convoluted, full of mysterious connections and internal correspondences. The structures of the symbols and events and their interrelations are as complicated as anything you will find in any novel by Joyce or Proust. Impressive.
na caffe
78
T7
na IMDb-byvotes
89
T10
na Darkling
95
T10
na jonnykungfu
85
T9
na PeaceAnarchy
93
T10
It's a detective story, a character study and a bitter musical/comedy all rolled up into one. I really don't know how to describe the film, it relies so much on the finely balanced tone that just barely holds a grip on reality. Excellent characterizations and performances, but none better than Michael Gambon who gets better and better with each episode as the nuance of his character consumes the larger narrative in spectacular surrealism.
na sjostrand
60
T8
na Electronic6
94
T10
na SirRobbie
80
T8
Need to see it again with some subtitles - just too much going on. One thing is sure, though - Gambon is brilliant.
na winds
6
T8
na Rumplesink
85
T9
na pzingg
98
T10
na Leland
90
T9
na filmaffinity
80
T10
na avgcrtckr
85
T10
na ledcollector
55
T3
na PaulMorel
86
T9
na JAK
5
T9
na gleeb
87
T10
Worth the time it takes to see it. Am I right?
na cat9man
86
T8
na pomattovich
87
T8
na Enygma
95
T10
na mrkwst22
94
T9
na Crazy Jack
90
T10
na winbran
96
T10
na MoaM
100
T10
Best 6 hours you'll ever spend.
na djross
80
T9
na philocrates
100
T10
Excellent with scenes that sometimes have you sitting still in shock. If you are looking for that bright happy ending it isn't here.
na digitalmonk
88
T10
na Gobman
90
T9
na experimental
81
T8
na bluesoul
89
T9
na terrymac
75
T8
na miss jesus
70
T7
na welike
30
T7
na muutanet
97
T10
The ultimate tv series. Intensity lasts all six episodes. Dennis Potter's best work. Joanne Whalley fresh and young black eyed nurse. Neil Hardwick reedited his Pakanamaan kartta (Off the Map) tv series after seeing this one.
na KungFuDolly
4
T4
na KasperL
90
T10
na hekkon
95
T10
na Kavu
65
T5
Well written and brilliantly acted, especially by Gambon, but doesn't have anything to make up for the very slow pacing. I completely lost interest halfway through.
na RNG
68
T7
na Julius
90
T8
na gert
85
T10
na prowler
91
T10
gambon is godly. a bit too long winded, but the final episode makes it all worth it
na Risselada
85
T8
na kyle.loomis
9
T10
na Jazzaloha
84
T10
One of the best TV shows (mini-series) of all-time. The psychological complexity took me by surprise.
na banjobanjar
96
T9
na empire434
100
T10
na jeff_v
97
T10
na dmk
88
T10
na billkerwin
95
T10
One of the finest mini-series ever. The writing is first-rate. Grim, dyspeptic, but somehow life-affirming even amid the bleakness. Gambon is great. And Dennis Potter's choice of period music is inspired.
na gauden
100
T10
na rfullen
90
T9
na Horopito
85
na Evan Waters
95
T10
na imdb
90
T10
na wokelstein
49
T3
na Stain
80
T7
Not as good as I hoped -- sometimes it comes dangerously close to wearing out its welcome, what with its insistence on making every point about half a dozen times. For the most part, however, it's engaging, and refreshingly weird... especially for something made for British TV
na sunhill
88
T10
na Rolad
60
T3
na supergloo
9
T9
Average Tier 8.51 from 77 Rankings rss