stunning (yet very cliche) photography and nothing else... boring, dull and predictable storytelling..last act is very rushed...

GOD DAMN. This was stunning, powerful.

aşkın doğasını çok iyi inceleyen ve romantik doğa görüntüleriyle çok iyi bir film."makbuz istiyorum."

My first encounter with what I imagine is a superfluous adaptation of Brontë's celebrated novel that's at one time touching and utterly forgettable. There was something strikingly economical about the film's opening in its evocation of the novel's tumultuous passion with little dialogue and jolting shots of a stunningly desolate moorland. Yet a decidedly weak Howson and a more conventional 2nd act don't establish their ill-fated romance as a deep and complex love. *need to watch Wyler's version*

It looks and feels wonderful - just like you're there. It worked better in the childhood part, but still is amazing as a whole. Those HEIGHTS were really, really WUTHERING.

nisan 12, ist film fest & Wuthering Heights, özellikle mekan ve kamera kullanımı ile başlı başına bir duygu dünyası yaratmayı başarıyor. Filmin tek eksik noktası, başkaraktere empati duymamız için o karakterin film boyunca eziyet çektiğni görmemiz. Wuthering Heights, çok özgün bir kitap uyarlaması. Festivalde izlediğim en başarılı filmlerden biri.

Hmmm. The whole film is suitably bleak and the young actors are fantastic. Some of the camera work works fantastically. On the other hand, that same camera work massively gets in the way sometimes, and the rack focus often looks very amateurish. The third act is a mess though, we never get a feel for Heathcliffe as a man, just a characture of desperation. I left pretty unsatisfied, but after sleeping on it the whole left a bleak and sad impression.

Visceral, elemental and often very beautiful, this is a really impressionistic take on what it must have been really like to love in this time and place. Superb.

An unusual, unflinching take on the classic novel. The short, often blunt scenes had a play-like feel to them, interspersed with shots of heathland and nature - though after a while this repetition went from thoughtful to a little irritating. However, this film is soaked in the harsh, dramatic geography of the Yorkshire moors, which I loved. That connection to the novel excused it from rather simplifying the central characters and not exploring fully the idea "what if Heathcliff was black?"

Unreal.

Gets dangerously close to being a full-blown artwank stinker. Nothing much works in this overwrought, dull mess, but there's some nice photography (and some annoying showiness) and the kid playing young Heathciff was good. I was really ready to love it, but no. Hopefully Arnold redeems herself with her next film.