kyle.loomis wrote:The popular opinion is that many people, including myself, would like a Criticker-style TV recommendation engine, but completely separate. The problem that comes up though is whether to do it by episode, season, or series.
I personally wouldn't mind having both but I get that some people want strictly movies or perhaps even TV shows. But there is always the chance they could have a "Turn TV/Movie Recommendations ON/OFF" button for that.
As for episode, season, series. I think episodes would be much too tedious as where there is so many and having to rate them would be difficult unless you have just recently watched them. Series I think would be too broad where there is so much to some series and you might not like every season of the show. Seasons however (at least to me) feel more like a movie for the most part. They usually tell one story and for the most part resolve whatever conflict happens at the end of the season making the seasons after it similar to sequels.
However I have no idea how difficult this would actually be to do so I'm not going to act like it NEEDS to be done. If they choose to eventually add a feature like this, then awesome. Either way the site is still amazing and kudos to those that keep it up and running.