The main beef I have with Criticker's interface is that I don't understand the difference between the wish list and the built-in Remembered Films collection. I think that the Wish List should operate more like a regular collection.
For instance, you can search from your Remembered Films and export the collection, but you can't from the Wish List. Also when I do a search on a film and click to see the details before I rank it, I can see "Add to my wishlist", but there is no "Remember" or "Save to Remembered Films" link there. The only way I even found out about Remembered Films was when I was looking at the "Other Recommendations" in Explore > Recommendations, where there is a tiny "remember" link under the movie images.
In summary, I'd like to see more "Remembers" sprinkled around, and also make the Wish List a built-in collection so it can be searched and exported.
Ideas to improve Criticker and new feature requests
Yeah, we totally agree with this actually. The Wish List was an idea which was around before we introduced Collections. The functionality is so similar, that we plan on merging them -- that is, getting rid of "Wish Lists" as they exist now, and just replacing it with Collections -- similar to how we do with "Remembered", "Ignored", and "Featured" Films.